We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
months old.
The problem is with Oscar is that he *never* cries/meow's. Casper does all
the time, if hes hungry hell meow, or if he wants some attention hell meow,
if he wants to be out hell meow, or if when the 2 of them and playing and
oscar hurts him he'll meow.
But oscar never does, if he's hungry he wont meow, he just walks around
pestering you till you realise its food he wants, never meows for attention,
hell just do something like run about the place like a lunatic, or quite
often if he tries to play and caspers had enough casper will go for him and
he never even meows then (or even the times when you aciddently stand on
their tail if you havent seen them in the way) he wont meow.
Does any one know why this could be, the only time i have ever heard him
meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
to the vets about 2 months ago.

Signature
Subscribe to the Fire Models Yahoo Group
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/firemodels/join
~*SooZy*~ - 16 Dec 2003 19:09 GMT
> We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> months old.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
> to the vets about 2 months ago.
sounds like a placid chap to me :-)
maybe its because he know you don't talk cat ;-)

Signature
Luv'n'Stuff
*~*SooZy*~*
http://community.webshots.com/user/ragmoor
http://community.webshots.com/user/ragdollcatsuk
Chris B - 16 Dec 2003 23:13 GMT
My cat (Tosca) doesn't meow either! She squeaks occassionally. The only
time I have ever heard her come close to a meow was when she was travelling
in the car with me. I think she's just not very vocal - quite nice really!
> We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> months old.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
> to the vets about 2 months ago.
Gee - 17 Dec 2003 04:00 GMT
"Chris B" <NO SPAM chris.brogan@thefreeinternet.co.uk> wrote in message
>> I think she's just not very vocal - quite nice really!
I dunno if I can agree with that final comment Chris, I find cat's meows
beautiful sounds, and I absolutely love when mine are talking to me or to
each other.
My QT was extremely vocal. He talked to me/complained about everything: i
want food, i want a scratch, I want out, i want in, I want a wee, I just
done a poo, I am bored, I am happy, you name it, he was talking to me all
the time. When he died, this is the thing that killed me the most: the
sudden silence in the house, the quietness that was louder then any
loudspeaker, which, combined with my grief, drove me to a huge depression!
It's been 4 years since he's gone, and I am still beating myself to death
for never recording his voice.
Perhaps, having a cat that isn;t very vocal, you wouldn;t understand my
point, but you must trust me when I tell you that his voice was the most
beautiful music I have ever heard.
Gee
m. L. Briggs - 17 Dec 2003 05:58 GMT
>"Chris B" <NO SPAM chris.brogan@thefreeinternet.co.uk> wrote in message
>
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>
>I do understand. I felt that way about my Siamese (RB).. She had a wonderful voice and talked a lot.
She had trill and chirps and other great sounds. My TuTu (mixed
tabby) has a high rather squeeky voice which is not as pleasing. She
talks to, but it is very different .
Gee - 17 Dec 2003 04:12 GMT
"Spinal" <nooo@spaaaammmm.com> wrote in message news:3fdf4c14$0
> The problem is with Oscar is that he *never* cries/meow's.
>
> Does any one know why this could be, the only time i have ever heard him
> meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
> to the vets about 2 months ago.
I have no definite explanation really, just some guesses. I just know that
some cats are simply not as chatty as others. I have 4 now, and they all
talk occasionally: Shaddow only when she wants a cuddle(usually 3am)-very
sad meow, almost a cry; Tiara when she wants something like food or a
scratch, Tigger when he is looking for Charlie to play, or when he wants me
to adjust my hand to a position in which he can curl up in and sleep; and
Charlie if he wants to go out. Other times they just don;t. If I sometimes
accidently step on one's tail, the scream they produce is so highpitched, I
am often left with a feeling that even though it was suppose to have been
loud, I haven;t actually heard it in full. It made me come to a conclusion
that the sound moved to a frequency I cannot hear.
A neighbour's cat Poppy was similar to yours: she'd open the mouth and meow,
but no sound was coming out. Untill she was extremely upset, like your cat
and others-being driven to the vet, or being hurt.
Perhaps they do produce the sounds. We musn;t forget that we are only humans
and as such way behind the cats in a hearing sense. What we hear is probably
only a tiny portion of what cats can hear. So really, we don;t know if they
meow or not. They just might be using different frequency.
Finally, there is always a medical possibility there. Some humans can;t
speak. Who is to say it can;t happen to a cat. Perhaps born with some
disability, or even got ill at some point and infection damaged something.
Always worth getting vet to check the cat, but if there is nothing medially
wrong, perhaps we humans are just "deaf" :)
Gee
Marek Williams - 17 Dec 2003 07:10 GMT
>The problem is with Oscar is that he *never* cries/meow's. Casper does all
>the time, if hes hungry hell meow, or if he wants some attention hell meow,
>if he wants to be out hell meow, or if when the 2 of them and playing and
>oscar hurts him he'll meow.
When I was caring for an older stray he never ever meowed. Had him for
several months and never a peep out of the old guy.
I asked the same question here and several people said that cats
raised away from humans are frequently silent. Cats that meow
apparently do so because they've learned that it works with humans. If
you've never had a human, I can see why a cat would not learn to meow.
If your cat has always been with humans, then I have no explanation.
--
Bogus e-mail address, but I read this newsgroup regularly, so reply here.
Ivor Jones - 17 Dec 2003 18:24 GMT
> We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> months old.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
> to the vets about 2 months ago.
We had a cat (Daisy) around 20 years ago, the most we ever got from her
was a faint squeak if you caught her by surprise..!
Ivor
Sam Gunnerson - 17 Dec 2003 18:58 GMT
> > We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> > months old.
> >
> > The problem is with Oscar is that he *never* cries/meow's.
Casper does
> all
> > the time, if hes hungry hell meow, or if he wants some attention hell
[quoted text clipped - 48 lines]
>
> Ivor
I had two cats who were brothers. I lost Rudy a few months ago at the age of
21+. Rudy was always extremely vocal, and loud, all the time. His brother
Scuzzy was the silent one until Rudy was gone. Now Scuzzy talks when he
wants something. I have started calling him my puppy because he follows me
around and when I sit he must get in my lap. He sleeps in the bed with us at
night and he is too old to jump down so when he awakens and needs the litter
box he talks and has to be carried to the laundry room (litter box
location). He won?t drink water unless it?s from my cocktail glass,
requires chopped Honeybaked ham for lunch, must have grated Asiago cheese
each evening. Regular canned cat food, special diet, for breakfast and
during the night. Lots of little idiosyncrasies. He is now 21 years and 8
months. Kind of a little weirdo.
m. L. Briggs - 17 Dec 2003 20:16 GMT
>> > We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
>> > months old.
[quoted text clipped - 67 lines]
>during the night. Lots of little idiosyncrasies. He is now 21 years and 8
>months. Kind of a little weirdo.
He sounds like he has been a great friend. Best wishes and Happy
Holidays to all of you.
-=petr0lb0mb=-???? - 22 Dec 2003 01:37 GMT
Did you check to see if Casper had Oscar's tongue?
;-p
> We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> months old.
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> meow a few times was when he was in his cat box on the bus when thaking him
> to the vets about 2 months ago.
JP Hobbs - 28 Dec 2003 09:39 GMT
Wilson never meowed but then I stepped on his tail because
when they dont talk, you *dont*know they are there and actually
he squealed but not too loudly voice found, but he only talks
quietly, and just now I turned round to catch something on the telly
and there he was, sitting at the veranda door and staring at what
had been my back,I suppose he thought he had willed me to turn
around, I went and opened it for him anywayI have heard of other cats
that dont meow I know of three I used to think Wilson had something
wrong with his throat, but no-one seems to know why. Sorry I cant
help you but thought you might like to know that you and he are
not alone in this cheers Jean P.
> We have 2 cats, Casper who is almost 4 years, and Oscar who is about 10
> months old.
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> Subscribe to the Fire Models Yahoo Group
> http://groups.yahoo.com/group/firemodels/join