Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneral TopicsCat AnecdotesHealth and BehaviorRescue
CatKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Cat Forum / General Topics / August 2007

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Advice please - boyfriend/cat issue.

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Jamie - 13 Aug 2007 11:29 GMT
Hello all.

First time poster to this newsgroup and I am hoping I can get some
valuable advice please.

I have owned a cat for 7 years. She is a sweetheart with a mental age
of -2 (!) and a dribble problem !  For 5 out of the 7 years, I held
down a relationship with a complete narcissist which I almost moved in
with and thank goodness I didn't.  Finally got out of the relationship
and one of the conditions that was going to be laid down was that if I
moved in with him, the cat went.

I am now in a relationship with someone else - someone that really is
horizontal in most things and whom I love and care for very much. He
always appeared to like my cat and they got on well.

Recently, we moved in together.  I was forced to sell my house because
of financial problems and as we get along great, he asked me to move
in with him.  And it was fine to bring the cat.......3 months on, things
in that area have broken down somewhat.  It's one bedroom flat.  The
cat was used to going out and now she's not able to. She recently went
"on holiday" to my mom's whilst we went away and her personality
changed loads since she came back - having the freedom of the house
and being put back in a flat I think didn't go down too well........

I have worked what I think is a compromise out with my other half.
The cat goes to my mom's for 6-12 months whilst we sort out bigger
living accommodation such as a house.  If my mom will have her - still
waiting on the answer. That way, I know the cat will go to a good
home, where I can visit and she will have the run of a large house and
garden too.

Thing is, I have read on here some other posts whereby the general
reaction was dump the boyfriend, keep the cat.  He is upset that he
can't seem to tolerate her and I tried playing the card of "lose the
cat, lose me," but in all honesty I don't want to lose him because we
have great friendship that I think runs very deep but I still feel
lost.  I have descended on this guy, who has been so accommodating
with me moving in and accepted me dumping loads of stuff in the flat
but surely it's not fair for me to impose something that he can't deal
with ?

Thing is, I am sure it will be better for the cat to have somewhere
where she can roam free rather than being couped up all day everyday
and it would only be temporary......

Any help or advice appreciated.

Thank you.

Jamie
studio - 13 Aug 2007 17:27 GMT
> First time poster to this newsgroup and I am hoping I can get some
> valuable advice please.

Welcome to the group.
Much valuable information regarding cats can be had here.

> Finally got out of the relationship
> and one of the conditions that was going to be laid down was that if I
> moved in with him, the cat went.

Stop right there...don't need to hear anymore.
Unfortunately, you and your pet are a package deal.
To do otherwise is to break a personal contract of responsibility to
care
for the pet.
If your friend can't understand that, they can't understand you.
Just remember, if one contract can be broken, they all can be broken.
Not a good basis to start a relationship with pets, much less humans.

Personally, I would never consider anyone that couldn't understand
why the personal responsibility I've undertaken can't be compromised.
Diana - 13 Aug 2007 18:13 GMT
> > First time poster to this newsgroup and I am hoping I can get some
> > valuable advice please.
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
> Personally, I would never consider anyone that couldn't understand
> why the personal responsibility I've undertaken can't be compromised.

Studio, you didn't read enough to see what what the OP was asking.  She
ended the relationship with first guy, and she and cat are living with
second guy in a small flat which doesn't suit the cat.  Second guy had
welcomed the cat, but the cat is apparently not happy, and second guy
and cat aren't getting on terribly well under the cramped conditions.  
She's asking about letting the cat go to her mom's house where there is
lots more room, which the cat likes.  She's saying 6 to 12 months, until
they can get into a bigger place.  The cat has stayed with the mom
before, and this really sounds like the better situation to me.  My
thinking is that perhaps the cat has been and will be moved too much,
and would prefer settling into a stable home and staying there.  Give
her post a read and see what you think.

Diana
Sharona Fleming - 13 Aug 2007 20:00 GMT
>Studio, you didn't read enough to see what what the OP was asking.  She
>ended the relationship with first guy, and she and cat are living with
>second guy in a small flat which doesn't suit the cat.  Second guy had
>welcomed the cat, but the cat is apparently not happy, and second guy
>and cat aren't getting on terribly well under the cramped conditions.  
I reread the post several times.   Are you saying the cat prefers
living at moms hosue since it is a larger area?   Sure sounds like the
cat prefers moms where it has the run of the house instead of
a cramped apartment that has what two rooms?

Could there be external factors influencing the cat here?  
Maybe the apartment/neigbors have another cat, excesisve
noise, or something else the cat won't tolerate?

Could it be that mom spoils the cat while the BF doesn't?

Finaly maybe the cat is objecting to not being able to go outside?
Maybe it used to be an outdoor cat?
Diana - 14 Aug 2007 00:22 GMT
> >Studio, you didn't read enough to see what what the OP was asking.  She
> >ended the relationship with first guy, and she and cat are living with
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Finaly maybe the cat is objecting to not being able to go outside?
> Maybe it used to be an outdoor cat?

I figure something like all of the above, yeah.  So maybe if she gets
"permission" to give the cat to her mom, everybody wins.
studio - 14 Aug 2007 18:06 GMT
> Studio, you didn't read enough to see what what the OP was asking.  

You're probably right.
Sounds like kitty needs to stay at moms permanently, and daughter
should pay for all of kitties food permanently.
William Graham - 14 Aug 2007 03:22 GMT
> Hello all.
>
[quoted text clipped - 47 lines]
>
> Jamie

I would let the cat live with my parents until and unless I acquired a
larger place to live so it could enjoy life with more room to run
around.....You will be visiting there from time to time, so the cat will
know that you haven't abandoned it......
Michael Lane - 14 Aug 2007 14:52 GMT
Jamie wrote about her bo:

He is upset that he can't seem to tolerate her and I tried playing the
card of "lose the cat, lose me,"

---------------------------------------------

Bo's come & go but your cat will love you for ever. The three biggest
lies in the world are , I will love you forever, I want c__ in your
mouth, & trust me.

Michael Lane

It ain't bragging, if you can back it up___
                                            Dizzy Dean
philo - 19 Aug 2007 21:02 GMT
> Hello all.
>
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
> Recently, we moved in together.  I was forced to sell my house because
> of financial problems and as we get along great, he asked me to move

<snip>

Many years ago...I was in a similar situation in that my decision boiled
down to getting rid of either the cat or the girlfriend.

A horrible decision to make...but the cat won!

That was something like 25 years ago and I have *never* regretted the
decision!
The fact that she now looks like a football player has not hurt my lact of
regret <G>
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.