if a dog and cat about similar size get into a dispute, who usually
relents? Do they fight or
make peace (or at least distance). I'm thinking
about getting a dog and I don't know if my cat will like the new
intruder. Can I trust they
will behave when left home alone?
Dragonblaze - 23 Nov 2005 12:11 GMT
Unfortunately cats are very territorial animals and will resent the
intrusion of even a strange cat - let alone a dog - into what they see
as their turf. One of my older cats never took to a new cat I brought
in, but eventually they reached a sort of an armed truce. But as you
know, cats are individuals, and without knowing your cat I can't
predict at all whether your cat will ever accept an intruder. I think
it would be a very bad idea to leave them alone and together at home
when you're away. At least in the beginning lock the dog in the
separate room the cat will have no access to. Under no circumstances
lock the cat in, as she/he will resent the dog even more.
Cheers,
Dragonblaze
shortfuse - 23 Nov 2005 13:11 GMT
From what experience I have, a dog usually is more to accept a cat than vice
versa...May be because it knows better than to fool around with a cat.;)
> Unfortunately cats are very territorial animals and will resent the
> intrusion of even a strange cat - let alone a dog - into what they see
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> Cheers,
> Dragonblaze
Kitty Doodle Dog - 23 Nov 2005 14:34 GMT
so i take it that the general consensus is that a cat can beat up a
dog? I would've
thought that the loud bark and bigger mouth of a dog can scare away a
cat.
> From what experience I have, a dog usually is more to accept a cat than vice
> versa...May be because it knows better than to fool around with a cat.;)
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> > Cheers,
> > Dragonblaze
shortfuse - 23 Nov 2005 20:31 GMT
I had a cat once who took on a German Shepard...You should had seen that dog
run!!!!
> so i take it that the general consensus is that a cat can beat up a
> dog? I would've
[quoted text clipped - 17 lines]
>> > Cheers,
>> > Dragonblaze
~shady angel~ - 24 Nov 2005 22:49 GMT
> so i take it that the general consensus is that a cat can beat up a
> dog? I would've
> thought that the loud bark and bigger mouth of a dog can scare away a
> cat.
My dog being a bigun would be able to bite a cat in half but hasn't the
nature so I guess it depends on the dog.

Signature
~shady angel~
when one and only one person perceives a certain reality, and (virtually)
all others perceive another, isn't that generally considered "delusional?"
>> From what experience I have, a dog usually is more to accept a cat
>> than vice versa...May be because it knows better than to fool around
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>>> Cheers,
>>> Dragonblaze
Kitty Doodle Dog - 24 Nov 2005 23:18 GMT
don't be so sure -- weren't there numerous reports of packs of hungry
dogs in
New Orleans after the flooding? i bet if your dog was hungry enough,
it would join with its
buddies, surround a cat, and eat it.
> > so i take it that the general consensus is that a cat can beat up a
> > dog? I would've
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
> >>> Cheers,
> >>> Dragonblaze
bodacious - 25 Nov 2005 21:58 GMT
That, or genius.

Signature
L'arrivant de tous les courriers électroniques et le départ de cet
ordinateur sont vérifiés pour les virus par Norton AntiVirus.
>> so i take it that the general consensus is that a cat can beat up a
>> dog? I would've
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
>>>> Cheers,
>>>> Dragonblaze
mlabofski@yahoo.co.uk - 24 Nov 2005 15:06 GMT
> if a dog and cat about similar size get into a dispute, who usually
> relents? Do they fight or
> make peace (or at least distance). I'm thinking
> about getting a dog and I don't know if my cat will like the new
> intruder. Can I trust they
> will behave when left home alone?
I think unless the dog is a cat hunter, the cat will always win, from
my experience anyway, of seeing a poor dog grooming a cat then as soon
as the cat had had enough she turned round and slashed it's nose,
making it bleed. Cats are much cleverer and less willing to please
than dogs (which is why we love em!) - they can climb trees after
tormenting a friendly dog that just wants to play, and after all, dogs
have masters, cats have slaves!
edie humperdink - 24 Nov 2005 20:20 GMT
interesting. i guess claws beat a big jaw. i wonder if cats know
enough to stay away from
a bulldog.
KG - 24 Nov 2005 15:27 GMT
One day I found 3 stray kittens living under my house. So I started feeding
them so I could get them to come out. They were shy little buggers. Soon
they started coming out on the patio. Still wouldn't let me near them. Very
feral it seemed.
One day I heard a dog barking. I went outside and my black male cat (Dunn)
followed me out. The kittens were so afraid of the huge dog they didn't even
try to run. The dog was easy 5 times the size of my dunn but in a split
second, a black flash went by me and was on that dog before I could even do
anything. It took me about 2 seconds to realize I should have been worried
about the dog. My cat tore him up. Never seen the dog in the area again. :)
I don't believe in violence of any type. But I think I would place my money
on the cat.
I miss my Dunn, he passed last summer and my Precious passed last winter.
(note: Those kittens eventually let me pick them up. 2 went to a next door
neighbor who wanted a couple of cats for pets after losing one of her own..
The other one now lives with me.)
> if a dog and cat about similar size get into a dispute, who usually
> relents? Do they fight or
> make peace (or at least distance). I'm thinking
> about getting a dog and I don't know if my cat will like the new
> intruder. Can I trust they
> will behave when left home alone?
~shady angel~ - 24 Nov 2005 22:46 GMT
> if a dog and cat about similar size get into a dispute, who usually
> relents? Do they fight or
> make peace (or at least distance). I'm thinking
> about getting a dog and I don't know if my cat will like the new
> intruder. Can I trust they
> will behave when left home alone?
Well I am far from an expert at this but just the other day, I heard what I
thought was two tom cats scrapping it out.
To be safe as my dog has killed a opossum before and has an intrest in the
nieghbours 11 or so cats I went out and called him too find scratches all
over his nose. Couldn't find any cat's (good sign) but the next day a cat
sat just infront of the gate where cujo could see it but not get to it and
just stared at him. I think it was getting it's own back with phycological
warfare!
I know this doesn't really answer you question but unless you get a puppy
and raise it with cats I think you are asking for trouble IMO.
Good luck.

Signature
~shady angel~
when one and only one person perceives a certain reality, and (virtually)
all others perceive another, isn't that generally considered "delusional?"
Adam Helberg - 25 Nov 2005 04:10 GMT
> if a dog and cat about similar size get into a dispute, who usually
> relents? Do they fight or
> make peace (or at least distance). I'm thinking
> about getting a dog and I don't know if my cat will like the new
> intruder. Can I trust they
> will behave when left home alone?
I don't think a cat would attack a dog even if it were the same size, a strange dog
may attack a cat. Most likely the cat would run away to avoid a fight, but if
cornered the cat (with claws) would probably hurt the dog and the dog would run away,
given that they are the same size.
Adam
Kitty Doodle Dog - 25 Nov 2005 21:50 GMT
if cats are such great fighters, why do gamblers fight dogs and
chickens, but never cats? (I'm just asking; I don't condone the
exploitation of ANY animals for entertainment. I don't even like the
circus, since cirucuses are insulting to animals.)