
Signature
David Stevenson Storypage: http://blakjak.com/sty_menu.htm
Liverpool, England, UK <cat2@blakjak.com> Emails welcome
Nanki Poo: SI O+W B 11 Y L+ W++ C+ I T+ A- E H++ V- F Q P+ B+ PA+ PL SC
Minke: SI W+Cp B 2 Y L W+ C++ I T A- E H++ V++ F- Q- P B PA+ PL+ SC-
On Mon, 14 Feb 2005 23:14:48 +0000 (UTC), David Stevenson
<cat2@nospam.demon.co.uk>
>>On Mon, 14 Feb 2005 17:14:32 +0000 (UTC), David Stevenson
>><cat2@nospam.demon.co.uk>
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> No, it isn't. No doubt you have made a mistake sometime in your life
>which has made other people suffer.
Hmm - let me think about that. No, I don't think I've ever physically
made any living being suffer through a mistake I've made, but if I had
or if I'm forgetting something, then criticism would be appropriate.
Okay, my memory just kicked in - I do remember 1 instance of my hurting
my cat (of all people) once.
I came home and I did look to make sure she didn't slip past me as I
entered, but she somehow managed to do so without my seeing her. I then
shut the door and she got caught in it.
I'm not sure that actually qualifies as "suffering", but she was in pain
for a brief instant and she squealed and ran and hid afterward (inside
where it was safer), but 5 minutes later she acted as if nothing had
happened - except now she doesn't try to dart outside whenever the door
opens, so some good actually came of it.
I suppose you can criticize me for this, but there is 1 big difference
and that is that I did not mean to shut the door on her.
The OP did intentionally let his indoor cat go outdoors in a new
neighborhood. He didn't even indicate that he knew the neighborhood
would be relatively safe for his pet. He doesn't say where he lives, so
I won't conjecture at specific dangers, but that could be deadly in some
places. In fact, couldn't simply climbing into a car engine turn
deadly?
>You have no doubt felt terrible.
In the above case, I did feel terrible for an instant, then I merely
felt bad for a little while, but I got over it rather quickly. Had I
intentionally hurt her, I would still feel bad about it now.
>That did not give people the right to act as total sh.ts.
I see you're posting from the UK and I know you have some limitations on
free speech there, but in the US we are still free to say things even if
you feel it makes us look like "total sh.ts".
The first poster, who you chastised was actually very nice about it I
thought.
Reproduced here:
| Talk about closing the barn door after the horse has gone!
That's too harsh for you?
| Why did you put her out alone? And then leave her out all night?
Valid questions
| All you can do now is try to find her and pray she is still alive.
Sound advice
| Purrs for the poor lost kitty.
Sympathy for the missing's plight.
That all seems fairly polite to me, especially considering the situation
and the medium (usenet). Then the OP comes back and calls him/her "a
real bastard" and claims he didn't do what he had just admitted to doing
(leaving her outside all alone).
"rinse cycle" wasn't quite so polite, but by that point the OP had
already flipped out and started calling reasonable people "real
bastards". But even after that, the worst thing he said was
"Outrageous".
It seems to me the only "total sh.ts" in this thread are you and the OP.