Cat Forum / General Topics / March 2006
Insulted by attitude towards cats on CSI
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Catgirl - 12 Mar 2006 06:47 GMT Tonight's episode of CSI... yet another example of how cats are treated in the media that ticks me off. The attitude portrayed towards the cats in this show are as if they are no more than vermin, mere things...to be sneered at and shuddered at, annoyances at best, to be caged up and hauled off to who cares where. There is no empathy towards them whatsoever... feeding into the idea and promoting the idea that its OK to not feel anything for them.
I am no fogey and we have 12 happy kitties in our household. If we could, we would care for more. When I get old, and if I find myself alone, I guess I'll be one of the "crazy old cat ladies" referred to so negatively in this and many other shows and movies. Oh, let's NOT promote the idea that cats provide a valuable source of love for many people... children... women and men of all ages... including little old ladies.
I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...?
Catgirl
Wayne Boatwright - 12 Mar 2006 07:30 GMT On Sat 11 Mar 2006 10:47:07p, Thus Spake Zarathustra, or was it Catgirl?
> Tonight's episode of CSI... yet another example of how cats are treated > in the media that ticks me off. The attitude portrayed towards the [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats > and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...? Indeed I do. We have five very happy cats of varying ages in our household. They are a privileged and cherished lot, and our home would feel empty without them.
I totally cannot understand people's negative attitude toward cats. One thing I do believe is that many people resent their independence.
 Signature Wayne Boatwright o¿o ____________________
BIOYA
Dr. Woodard - 12 Mar 2006 08:25 GMT >> I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats >> and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...? [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] >I totally cannot understand people's negative attitude toward cats. One >thing I do believe is that many people resent their independence. Since I didn't see the show i'm not going to comment on how it was presented.
I haven't noticed other shows being anti-cat.
Matthew AKA NMR ( NO MORE RETAIL ) - 12 Mar 2006 12:06 GMT Well I have seen alot of shows always have the furballs in a bad situation like getting run over or trapped somewhere quote un quote comical. But have seen the reverse where the show goes out of its way to use the furballs in tear jerker fashion. We until recently had 6 cats now 5 if any one made a comment on us old folks being senile my response would be half a peace sign my 12 inch boot up their a@@ as I picked them up and tossed them out the door
>>> I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats >>> and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...? [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption > =---- Dr. Woodard - 12 Mar 2006 15:47 GMT On Sun, 12 Mar 2006 11:06:50 GMT, "Matthew AKA NMR \( NO MORE RETAIL \)" <10 points a troll @linethetrollsup.com> wrote:
>Well I have seen alot of shows always have the furballs in a bad situation >like getting run over or trapped somewhere quote un quote comical. But have >seen the reverse where the show goes out of its way to use the furballs in >tear jerker fashion. Maybe you're watching the wrong shows. The ones i've seen haven't abused casts.
I would point out on a recent episode of SVU they used cat hair to put the perp at the scene of the crime. Nothing disparaging about cats.
Charmed had a cat in earlier seasons. Nothing really bad.
Then there is Gilmore Girls. Episode 5: 5. Cinnamon's Wake (edit) First aired: 11/2/2000 Writer: Daniel Palladino Director: Michael Katleman Guest star: Liz Torres (Miss Patty), Sally Struthers (Babette Dell), Ted Rooney (Morey Dell), Scott Cohen (Max Medina), Jared Padalecki (Dean Forester) , Darlene Kardon (Cashier), Jean-Paul Vignon (Andre), Floyd Van Buskirk (Jed), DeLauné Michel (Dr. Jeannie)
During their weekly dinner at Emily's, Lorelai learns of her cousin Claudia's funeral, but as she didn't know the woman, she doesn't want to go. The next day Rory reminds Lorelai of the Chilton bake sale, and on their way out they meet their neighbors Babette and Morey out walking their cat Cinnamon. At the Chilton bake sale, Lorelai sees Max Medina and is cold to him, but after he tells her that he wants to help Rory and be friends, she agrees to meet him for coffee. Lorelai meets with Max, who says that they should date. Lorelai thinks it's a bad idea. Max proceeds to tell her that they are attracted to each other, and after a sad story about seizing the day, Lorelai agrees to dinner. At Luke's Lorelai gets a call from Rory, who tells Lorelai that Cinnamon, the cat, has died. While at Cinnamon's wake, Rory goes outside only to see Max. She demands an explanation from Lorelai. She tells Rory that she really likes Max, and Rory says that's OK, she was just upset that Lorelai didn't talk to her about it. Emily calls when they get home and is upset that Lorelai went to a cat's funeral rather than her cousin Claudia's. Rory tells Lorelai that it is OK that Lorelai likes and dates Max.
Gilmore Girls is the best show on the planet right now.
Oh and speaking of cats, there is the show Early Edition where this guy tomorrows paper today.....delivered by a cat.
I would point out dogs are probably easier to train for a TV show. The cat would just say "You think you're the show runner?"
John - 12 Mar 2006 14:26 GMT Other than The History Channel, The Learning Channel, A&E, The Discovery Channel, and The Weather Channel, there is not a thing on TV worth anybody's time. The Socialist liberal leftist Democreeps in Hollywood have not produced a thing for decades which is worth anybody's time, unless you consider Brokeback Mountain & Desperate Housewives worth *your* time.
Dr. Woodard - 12 Mar 2006 15:54 GMT >Other than The History Channel, The Learning Channel, >A&E, The Discovery Channel, and The Weather Channel, >there is not a thing on TV worth anybody's time. Have to disagree. There is Gilmore Girls, Everwood, Medium, Lost, Charmed, Everybody Hates Chris, L&O.
>The >Socialist liberal leftist Democreeps in Hollywood have not >produced a thing for decades which is worth anybody's time, I would add those studios are owned by republicans.
>unless you consider Brokeback Mountain & Desperate >Housewives worth *your* time. Let me put it this way: I was happily married to my wife of 19 years prior to gay marriage. Today a year and a half after gay marriage here i'm still happily married to my wife.
Some of us are not homophobic.
As for DH, I tried a couple of episodes, never got into the show.
I assume you never actually saw BM?
Matthew AKA NMR ( NO MORE RETAIL ) - 12 Mar 2006 17:01 GMT >>Other than The History Channel, The Learning Channel, >>A&E, The Discovery Channel, and The Weather Channel, [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > > Some of us are not homophobic. You don't have to be homophobic to not to want to waste your time. I am not to each his own but what man wants to go to a movie about 2 alternative cowboys
As for DH, I tried a couple of episodes, never got into
> the show. > > I assume you never actually saw BM? Nope would not spend the money not my style or taste in movies! I haven't seen it but know plenty of people who have and it was not worth their time. 2 buddies are mine that are married male couple are insulted about the movie and many of their crowd of friends fell the same way.
> ----== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com - Unlimited-Unrestricted-Secure Usenet > News==---- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The #1 Newsgroup Service in the World! 120,000+ > Newsgroups > ----= East and West-Coast Server Farms - Total Privacy via Encryption > =---- NanCe - 12 Mar 2006 19:27 GMT >As for DH, I tried a couple of episodes, never got into >> the show. Come on! Not even to watch Gabriela?? Thought all you guys had the hots for her.
NanCe
Dr. Woodard - 12 Mar 2006 23:59 GMT >>As for DH, I tried a couple of episodes, never got into >>> the show. > >Come on! Not even to watch Gabriela?? Thought all you guys had the hots for >her. Nope. Not this guy.
But then I go for Jordan Cavanaugh one hour later on another network.
There is also KE on CI opposite DH.
And then there are the hot women of Charmed (HMC).
I can count on zero fingers the number of women on DH who do it for me.
Catgirl - 12 Mar 2006 19:46 GMT Hi everyone... Yes of course I realize there are tons of shows that don't depict kitties in this light, and tons of shows that are great for PR for them... I'm not upset about those, I am happy about those. But here, in this thread, I was just whining about this particular episode of CSI, which is an example of so many like that.
There's lots of scenes in movies and tv shows that show everything from blase' insensitivity to outright glee at cats being hurt or killed. This is what bothers me. And you don't see it coming when you watch something for the first time. I try to find where to write to voice my sadness at the apparent necessity to showcase cruelty and the tolerance or acceptance of cruelty... and the fact that I won't be watching again, and neither will the folks I know help pay for their posh lifestyles if this is what they are about ... But we need **many** people to do this to have an effect, don't you think? If they think it will hit them in the pocketbook, maybe they'll back off of this approach to delighting the public.
Its everywhere. Just the other night, one of the "hippest" comedies to hit the airwaves (supposedly) advertised themselves... and they chose to showcase a scene where this guy, one of the stars of this new Gift to the Viewers of America, runs over his love interest's cat... and it was supposed to be funny... oh, ha. Yeah. Give us more of THAT and we'll be sure to tune in and support your sponsors, too.
Thanks for letting me rant. Hoping some of you will join me in expressing to the creators of these kinds of shows described above, and to other people too, that this kind of absolute cold, ugly side of humanity towards innocent, satient beings is totally unacceptable. It just scares me that if we don't do something, this kind of mentality will gradually just overtake the majority of us. What kind of world would that be. (shudder)
Reminds me of the old Roman days or something. The distress, pain, and death of innocent beings at our mercy... oh what fun. Happy happy, joy joy, *clap clap clap*. And referring back to the thread in here that discusses where the human hurts and kills the little kitten. Same thing. And for entertainment (not that ANY reason would be valid). Geez. God.
Dr. Woodard - 13 Mar 2006 00:08 GMT >Hi everyone... Yes of course I realize there are tons of shows that >don't depict kitties in this light, and tons of shows that are great >for PR for them... I'm not upset about those, I am happy about those. >But here, in this thread, I was just whining about this particular >episode of CSI, which is an example of so many like that. And i don't watch CSI (any flavor) so I can't comment on it now. Since I missed the first season(s) I won't watch them now.
>Its everywhere. Just the other night, one of the "hippest" comedies to >hit the airwaves (supposedly) advertised themselves... and they chose >to showcase a scene where this guy, one of the stars of this new Gift >to the Viewers of America, runs over his love interest's cat... and it >was supposed to be funny... oh, ha. Yeah. Give us more of THAT and >we'll be sure to tune in and support your sponsors, too. I have no idea what show it was.....the only comedy I watch is Gilmore Girls.
BTW, I have no clue what show you're referring to.
Also around here many shows have a disclaimer ("no animals were harmed in the making of this film."
As far as complaints: send them to the sponsors/the network/the studio/and the FCC for consideration at license renewal time.
John - 12 Mar 2006 19:59 GMT The Socialist Hollywood Democreeps think Americans want to see Faggot Cowboys?
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHA HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
John - 12 Mar 2006 19:57 GMT "Feces-faced Looney leftist wacko Democreep Dr. Woodard" DrWoodardOnDS@hotmail.com> vomited the following psycho-babble in a message ///////////SNIPPED///////////////
Anymore leftist wisdom for us oh Dr Delusional?????????????
ROTFLMAO!
wester@laway.net - 12 Mar 2006 23:34 GMT >>Other than The History Channel, The Learning Channel, >>A&E, The Discovery Channel, and The Weather Channel, >>there is not a thing on TV worth anybody's time. >Have to disagree. There is Gilmore Girls, Everwood, >Medium, Lost, Charmed, Everybody Hates Chris, >L&O. I must disagree. I have not owned a television in over a decade and wouldn't want one. Not only is the programming lame, then you get stuck with those mindless commercials.
Be TV-free!
Matthew AKA NMR ( NO MORE RETAIL ) - 13 Mar 2006 02:34 GMT Heck no that means I would have to communicate with my DW <just kidding ;-) >
>>>Other than The History Channel, The Learning Channel, >>>A&E, The Discovery Channel, and The Weather Channel, [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > Be TV-free! ~*Connie*~ - 12 Mar 2006 15:04 GMT write to them and tell them.
if this turns your stomach, do NOT go see the Brothers Grimm.
> Tonight's episode of CSI... yet another example of how cats are treated > in the media that ticks me off. The attitude portrayed towards the [quoted text clipped - 16 lines] > > Catgirl NanCe - 12 Mar 2006 16:05 GMT >Tonight's episode of CSI... yet another example of how cats are treated >in the media that ticks me off. The attitude portrayed towards the [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] >I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats >and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...? I didn't see it but it doesn't sound good! I've seen movies where it's supposed to be funny when the family cat gets killed (National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation and War of the Roses to name a couple). On the plus side, the weekly show Cold Case portrays cats well. The lead (the blond cop) has two cats; I think one of them has only one eye and the other has three legs. Thought it was great that they were not "perfect" looking cats. One of the other cops came there and said "what's wrong with these cats!?". She looked disgusted with him and said "Nothing!!" Now if only more shows would follow their example.
NanCe
Kelcey - 13 Mar 2006 00:25 GMT >cats in this show are as if they are no more than vermin, mere >things...to be sneered at and shuddered at, annoyances at best, to be [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] >I hope somebody else around here feels the same way I do about how cats >and attitudes about them are portrayed and promoted in the media...? I've noticed this a lot in the entertainment industry also. Cats are picked on more than dogs. It's always been that way, maybe because they're less respected than dogs by so many people. They're more likely to show dogs as heros (Lassie, Rin Tin Tin, Benji, etc.). Maybe because they can learn tricks, help the blind, etc. and thus are deemed more useful by some people. But no one talks about how cats saved people from bubonic plague by killing the rats - they did a great job but it's not a "trick", or how they've helped sick or lonely people just by being comforting. There are even cats who've alerted their owners to the baby not breathing and others who have woken their owners up in a fire. People seem to have a "love em or hate em" attitude about cats and some think of them as "pests" rather than pets. I just know that when someone says they hate cats, I ask them if they've ever had one and 99.9% of the time they say no. All they know about cats is that the neighbour's is pooping in their garden or howling at night; they don't know any of the good stuff. I've also heard people say they didn't like them until they're wife, husband, etc. got one and then they ended up loving the cat. They usually say "I didn't know cats were so affectionate". Anyways, yes, I think cats get a bum rap the most in entertainment; I guess it's supposed to be "funny" when they get killed; don' t get it myself.
|
|
|