Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneral TopicsCat AnecdotesHealth and BehaviorRescue
CatKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Cat Forum / General Topics / December 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Woman will spend tonight in the woods for abandoning cats

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
tomsmith@____no____.com - 23 Nov 2005 15:15 GMT
Google Search exactly like this
"Michelle Murray" +kittens
and you'll get around 115 articles about this.
Here are TWO of them (below)

FROM:
http://www.news-herald.com/site/news.cfm?newsid=15598408&BRD=1698&PAG=461&dept_i
d=21849&rfi=6


Judge makes ruling to show suspect what it was like for the kittens
she abandoned

Michelle Murray will now have the opportunity to experience what the
dozens of kittens felt the night she abandoned them at two Lake
Metroparks in September.
Painesville Municipal Court Judge Michael A. Cicconetti on Thursday
sentenced Murray, 25, of Painesville Township, to jail time.
But he added a stipulation to ensure that Murray "suffer the same
consequences as those kittens."
"You can listen to the coyotes, hear the raccoons in the dark of
night," said Cicconetti, who grew increasingly annoyed at Murray's
apology attempts in court.
On the night before Thanksgiving, when Murray reports to the Lake
County Jail in Painesville, she will be forced to spend a night alone
in a remote area of a Lake County Metropark, according to Cicconetti
sentence.
Being allowed only water, she will not be provided with food, beverage
or shelter. Murray must remain in that location until "the light of
dawn on Nov. 24," according to the sentence.
Ranger Chief Mike Burko said he has not yet chosen the Metropark, but
will provide her with a walkie-talkie in case of emergency.
Cicconetti, known for his unusual sentences, gave Murray the maximum
sentence of 90 days in jail.
But the judge suspended 60 days and allowed 15 days to be served under
house arrest.
After returning from the wild on Thanksgiving, she will serve 14 days
in the Lake County Jail.
The suspended jail time hinges on two conditions:
n Murray may not own or care for any animals in the next three years.
n She must pay $3,200 to the Lake County Humane Society and $500 to
the Metropark rangers for costs they incurred due to her actions.
"I'm sorry. I truly am sorry. I never meant for any of this to
happen," Murray told the judge before the sentence.
She said she tried to contact the Lake County Humane Society, but
eventually panicked after three cages of cats were dropped off at her
home.
"It doesn't make any difference," the judge
said.
"People panic and commit crimes, they use drugs, they commit domestic
violence. But this wasn't one incident. You did it again the next
day."
Murray admitted to using another alias on a Web site to try to adopt
out another stray cat since she pleaded guilty to abandoning domestic
animals on Oct. 13.
She said she used the fake name because nobody would take a cat from
her if she used her own name. That cat was eventually adopted by the
Humane Society, but was so ill, it was euthanized the day it came in.
Candace Hertzel, executive director of the Lake County Humane Society,
said 15 of the kittens that were rescued had been adopted; 12 still
remain without homes.
"We're very pleasantly surprised by the sentence. It's a small piece
of justice suffered for some of these already deceased kittens,"
Hertzel said outside the courtroom following the sentence.
Prosecutor Russ Meraglio said he was pleased as well. He had
recommended jail time for the second-degree misdemeanor.
Sharon Moten, who gave a mother cat and four kittens to Murray 10 days
prior to her abandoning the animals, still felt the guilt of not
knowing the fate of all of her cats.
"I told her to call me if she couldn't handle them," Moten said.
She hoped the sentence would prompt donations to the Humane Society.
"It's one of the only ways I can feel better about what happened," she
said.

©The News-Herald 2005

========================

Another article

========================

FROM:
http://www.cleveland.com/lake/plaindealer/index.ssf?/base/lake/113231020533860.x
ml&coll=2


Woman must spend night in the woods for abandoning cats
Judge imposes sentence for leaving 40 kittens in parks
Friday, November 18, 2005
Michael Scott
Plain Dealer Reporter
Painesville- Michelle Murray will shiver through a winter night in the
woods with no food, lights or shelter as part of a court-imposed
sentence for abandoning 40 kittens in two parks.

Municipal Judge Michael Cicconetti said Lake Metroparks rangers will
take the 26-year-old Painesville Township woman into the forest at
dusk Wednesday and pick her up at dawn on Thanksgiving Day.

Rangers also will monitor Murray to make sure she is safe and does not
freeze. The National Weather Service forecast for next Wednesday night
is for a chance of snow with a low of 23 degrees.

   
"At least she gets the choice to bundle up for the night," Cicconetti
said in a Thursday interview. "The animals she left never had that
choice."

Murray pleaded guilty last month to a misdemeanor charge of abandoning
animals after identification collars on the kittens led investigators
back to her. The kittens, some as young as 4 weeks, were found by
hikers in mid-September in Mason's Landing in Leroy Township and
Indian Point Park in Perry Township.

Nine later died or were euthanized because they couldn't be saved.

Cicconetti, who has a reputation for imposing unorthodox punishments,
offered Murray a choice: Three months behind bars or one night in the
woods followed by 14 days in jail, 15 days of house arrest and three
years of probation.

In addition to the jail time, Murray must pay $3,200 restitution to
the Lake County Humane Society and $500 to the Metroparks. The judge
also ruled that she can no longer own pets.

In a Thursday interview, Murray said a stranger left the kittens on
her doorstep and the local animal shelter refused to help her. So she
said she left the kittens in parks "to force the humane society to do
something."

The mother of three children and two stepchildren agreed to the night
in the woods only because she could not afford to spend 90 days in
jail.

"But it's inhumane for the judge to send me out in the cold with
nothing but the clothes on my back," she said.

Candace Hertzel, executive director of the humane society, denied that
her agency refused to help Murray. Hertzel also said Cicconetti's
sentence delivers a powerful message.

"At least in Painesville, if you hurt animals, you will pay the
price," she said.

============================
See a video here
http://www.newsnet5.com/news/5346814/detail.html
============================

Some history about this case here
http://www.newsnet5.com/family/5035918/detail.html
============================

National News here:
http://www.upi.com/NewsTrack/view.php?StoryID=20051118-115848-2452r
============================
whayface - 23 Nov 2005 16:11 GMT
They need to do this to more people and then maybe they would think twice before they
abandon animals.

WAY TO GO JUDGE !!!!

>Google Search exactly like this
>"Michelle Murray" +kittens
[quoted text clipped - 136 lines]
>"At least in Painesville, if you hurt animals, you will pay the
>price," she said.
~*Connie*~ - 23 Nov 2005 23:57 GMT
I heard this on the today show.. Diane Sawyer thought that cats live in the
wild so the punishment seemed to exceed the crime.  Apparently she didn't
listen to herself when she stated earlier that nine of the cats died due to
exposure.

I personally am THRILLED at this.. the more exposure to how wrong dumping
companion animals the better!  (although Diane Sawyer needs a good education
herself apparently)
> Google Search exactly like this
> "Michelle Murray" +kittens
[quoted text clipped - 148 lines]
> http://www.upi.com/NewsTrack/view.php?StoryID=20051118-115848-2452r
> ============================
avante - 24 Nov 2005 00:36 GMT
I hadn't heard about this... but am all for it! the punishmnet should
fit the crime! I seem to attract strays, and spend the next several
days (and sometimes the cost of spaying/neuturing... and "first
time-owner costs ie: litterbox, food etc") to find a good home for a
cat...  Maybe they should have made her spend the night AND
legitimately placed a homeless "baby"... I could send her some bills :-)
No More  Retail - 24 Nov 2005 05:23 GMT
they announced today the punishment has changed  the woman is to spend
tonight in the outdoors but the park rangers decide if it is too cold and
can bring her in  plus now there is also 2 weeks of jail time added    she
still should have gotten the 90 days and the fine it would have been worse
punishment.  You know that those rangers will come in as soon as they are
cold
>I hadn't heard about this... but am all for it! the punishmnet should
> fit the crime! I seem to attract strays, and spend the next several
> days (and sometimes the cost of spaying/neuturing... and "first
> time-owner costs ie: litterbox, food etc") to find a good home for a
> cat...  Maybe they should have made her spend the night AND
> legitimately placed a homeless "baby"... I could send her some bills :-)
tomsmith@____no____.com - 10 Dec 2005 05:22 GMT
There was a followup on the news about this.

She was out there 4 hours and they brought her in.  It was a heavy
snowstorm.  She was equipped with a 2-way radio for safety.  The judge
told the rangers to bring her in after 4 hours.

Tom

------------------

>they announced today the punishment has changed  the woman is to spend
>tonight in the outdoors but the park rangers decide if it is too cold and
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>> cat...  Maybe they should have made her spend the night AND
>> legitimately placed a homeless "baby"... I could send her some bills :-)
whayface - 10 Dec 2005 14:34 GMT
Hopefully she got the idea and found out in the 4 hours a little of what the poor cats had
to go through.

My daughter has a nieghbor that I would like to do something like this to.  He has a male
Siameese cross cat that someone gave him when it was smaller and he never had him nuetered
so now he sprays.  He leaves him out most of the time because of it regardless of the
weather.  At times when I go home from my daughters he will be setting in front of door in
the cold and snow waiting for someone to let him in and it breaks my heart.

Finnally I put an old pillow and an old comforter under his porch when he was not home.
There are a couple holes big enough for the cats to get in and it was a chore getting
these under there !!  Then this past fall I gathered up a bunch of leaves and worked them
under there so now he has a place to sleep out of the weather and a choice of what to lay
on.  Plus it is sandy under there and the area is large enough so he can go without having
to go out in the snow.

I try to go over at least daily to feed him and when he realizes I am there he comes
running to greet me and I put food and drink in his under porch home for him.  The so
called owner thinks it is funny the way he has taking to me.  He says that if it by the
door when he goes in or out he lets him in.  I wold like to make him sleep under his porch
for just one night !!

>There was a followup on the news about this.
>
>She was out there 4 hours and they brought her in.  It was a heavy
>snowstorm.  She was equipped with a 2-way radio for safety.  The judge
>told the rangers to bring her in after 4 hours.

>>they announced today the punishment has changed  the woman is to spend
>>tonight in the outdoors but the park rangers decide if it is too cold and
>>can bring her in  plus now there is also 2 weeks of jail time added    she
>>still should have gotten the 90 days and the fine it would have been worse
>>punishment.  You know that those rangers will come in as soon as they are
>>cold

>>>I hadn't heard about this... but am all for it! the punishmnet should
>>> fit the crime! I seem to attract strays, and spend the next several
>>> days (and sometimes the cost of spaying/neuturing... and "first
>>> time-owner costs ie: litterbox, food etc") to find a good home for a
>>> cat...  Maybe they should have made her spend the night AND
>>> legitimately placed a homeless "baby"... I could send her some bills :-)
Howard Beale - 25 Nov 2005 17:25 GMT
I hope that devil worshipper freezes and gets frost bite causing her to have
amputation for what she did to those poor cats.  Die, bitch, die!

> Google Search exactly like this
> "Michelle Murray" +kittens
[quoted text clipped - 148 lines]
> http://www.upi.com/NewsTrack/view.php?StoryID=20051118-115848-2452r
> ============================
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.