Cat Forum / Rescue / October 2003
gone. :o(
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Aphrodite's Cat - 13 Oct 2003 23:00 GMT It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, today I had to turn them over to the SPCA to get put down. If treated, it could have been a total cure or someone could have a sickly cat for the rest of their lives.
RIP Idwal- light ginger male, all 4s stuck in the food bowl RIP Anwen- blue, loved to be cuddled while everyone was asleep RIP Branwyn- torti female, was a mess with her food RIP Cadfael- champagne male, ate like a gentleman RIP Llew- dark ginger male, loved to climb the curtains in the kitchen
They're with their mum now. They were very much loved while they were with me and they will never be forgotten.
*cries some more*
Aphrodite's Cat
Mary - 14 Oct 2003 00:02 GMT >It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, today I >had to turn them over to the SPCA to get put down. If treated, it could >have been a total cure or someone could have a sickly cat for the rest of >their lives. I don't understand. They just needed antibiotics. All of my fosters cats and kittens had URI. I just gave them clavamox and they were all fine in a few days. None were sickly forever. Am I missing something here?
MaryL - 14 Oct 2003 00:47 GMT > >It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, today I > >had to turn them over to the SPCA to get put down. If treated, it could [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > kittens had URI. I just gave them clavamox and they were all fine in a few > days. None were sickly forever. Am I missing something here? I am wondering the same thing. It doesn't make sense to have a policy to automatically euthanize when they have a foster home with someone who loves them and is willing to provide care. Why don't they at least give the kittens a chance?
MaryL (take out the litter to reply)
Aphrodite's Cat - 14 Oct 2003 00:52 GMT For them, it would be like having a perpetual cold, possibly thousands of dollars in vet visits over the course of their lives and of course, they could be potential carriers, causing a spiral of sickness among other cats in the shelters and in homes.
I trust the vets' advice and I also trust the SPCA inspector's advice. Besides, they weren't mine to decide on to begin with. We were fostering them for an animal control officer. They were rightly his. He made the decision. We have to live with it. I don't have the money to put 5 kittens on antibiotics, as well as my other 2 if they contracted it. The SPCA doesn't have the money to do it either. It wasn't my decision and I'm not going to torture myself with the notion of "what if they were mine".
I stand by the decision of the SPCA. I also stand by my own principles of not fostering any more kittens. I can not emotionally cope with the loss or potential loss.
 Signature Aphrodite's Cat ~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~ If I become an evil Overlord Rule # 64: I will see a competent psychiatrist and get cured of all extremely unusual phobias and bizarre compulsive habits which could prove to be a disadvantage. ~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~
> >It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, today I > >had to turn them over to the SPCA to get put down. If treated, it could [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > kittens had URI. I just gave them clavamox and they were all fine in a few > days. None were sickly forever. Am I missing something here? MaryL - 14 Oct 2003 01:05 GMT > For them, it would be like having a perpetual cold, possibly thousands of > dollars in vet visits over the course of their lives and of course, they [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > them for an animal control officer. They were rightly his. He made the > decision. We have to live with it.
> I stand by the decision of the SPCA. I also stand by my own principles of > not fostering any more kittens. I can not emotionally cope with the loss or > potential loss. I still question the SPCA's decision unless there is something here that I don't know. However, you are not in a position to make the decision -- and you have my sincere condolences. It must be incredibly painful to be placed in a position where you must relinquish your charges in that way. As you said, don't torture yourself.
MaryL (take out the litter to reply)
Cheryl - 14 Oct 2003 01:11 GMT > I stand by the decision of the SPCA. I also stand by my own > principles of not fostering any more kittens. I can not > emotionally cope with the loss or potential loss. I'm very sorry you lost the kittens. Bless you for trying and this is one of the things our local SPCA tells new fosterers: That kittens do die. They are fragile and they are always exposed to many bugs and bacteria when they are either at the shelter or at clinics being vetted. Our SPCA has similar policies about euthanizing kittens, though they usually give them more of a chance but know you did what you could do and if you can't handle it, bless you for acknowledging that in the beginning. I am not sure I could foster sick kittens, either. I had to "kennel" for 60 cats one long weekend in the summer and it broke my heart how many were sick and those that didn't make it. Purrs to you for loving them. Rescue groups have different policies based on how many resources and volunteers are available to help. How about fostering the older ones? :)
The Puppy Wizard - 22 Oct 2003 00:52 GMT HOWE abHOWET the whole damned bunch of you quit HEELPIN critters?
> > I stand by the decision of the SPCA. I also stand by my own > > principles of not fostering any more kittens. I can not [quoted text clipped - 13 lines] > policies based on how many resources and volunteers are available to > help. How about fostering the older ones? :) Mary - 14 Oct 2003 15:46 GMT >He made the >decision. We have to live with it. I don't have the money to put 5 kittens >on antibiotics, as well as my other 2 if they contracted it. The SPCA >doesn't have the money to do it either. I buy clavamox for $6 a bottle. That's all it would have taken. I don't believe this is a real post. Every cat I've ever gotten from a shelter had upper respiratory infections which is easily cured with antibiotics in a few days. They aren't sick for life. Either the cats had something else like FLV, FIV, or this post isn't real. If someone couldn't afford $6 for antibiotics, they couldn't afford catfood or litter. If someone is fostering for the ASPCA, I'd think they'd give the people some antibiotics for free.
Aphrodite's Cat - 14 Oct 2003 20:38 GMT If you think my pain at giving these kittens over to be euthanased is a joke, then f*ck off.
Fact is that the kittens didn't even belong to the SPCA- and no it's NOT the ASPCA, it's the RSPCA. I don't live in the States. We were fostering them for a family who wasn't able to care for them because of their jobs. He couldn't pay for the antibiotics because things are a bit more expensive over here than the "everything costs $1" USA.
NNTR, I'm unsubbing to usenet where there aren't as many stupid people who want to save all the cutsie animals. I live in a world where nothing's fair. This wasn't fair. I'm going to deal with it. I'm sorry that you can't. -- Aphrodite's Cat. ~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~ "Silly customer, you cannot hurt a twinkie!" -Apu ~*~*~*~*~*~*~*~
> >He made the > >decision. We have to live with it. I don't have the money to put 5 kittens [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > couldn't afford catfood or litter. If someone is fostering for the ASPCA, I'd > think they'd give the people some antibiotics for free. Iso - 14 Oct 2003 21:50 GMT Very well said!
> If you think my pain at giving these kittens over to be euthanased is a > joke, then f*ck off. [quoted text clipped - 37 lines] > Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). > Version: 6.0.522 / Virus Database: 320 - Release Date: 9/30/2003 Mary - 15 Oct 2003 00:43 GMT >If you think my pain at giving these kittens over to be euthanased is a >joke, then f*ck off. [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] >couldn't pay for the antibiotics because things are a bit more expensive >over here than the "everything costs $1" USA. You are in Australia. This is your RSPCA. It says here they will tend to injured or ill animals. http://www.rspca.org.au/ It says they teach people how to properly care for animals. It costs $1 each to euthanize, more to dispose of the body, antibiotics would be cheaper. Maybe there was more wrong with the cats. If your RSPCA did euthanize cats that only needed basic normal care, you should tell them that is wrong. I am emailing them right now and telling them that what they did was wrong, if it happened. FYI I buy my antibiotics through the mail. I even buy stuff from Canada where it's cheaper than the US.
Elvis Parsely - 16 Oct 2003 18:04 GMT >If you think my pain at giving these kittens over to be euthanased is a >joke, then f*ck off. [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >fair. This wasn't fair. I'm going to deal with it. I'm sorry that you >can't. I agree with you 100 percent. Americans are too pampered and judgmental. They have no perspective on the reality of the world.
I have seen some of the worst examples in this group.
Jade
frlpwr - 14 Oct 2003 17:30 GMT > For them, it would be like having a perpetual cold, possibly thousands of > dollars in vet visits over the course of their lives and of course, they > could be potential carriers, causing a spiral of sickness among other cats > in the shelters and in homes. This is ridiculous. One box of Clavamox, enough to treat four kittens for seven days, costs around $5.00. The only upper respiratory infection that can last a life time and cause cats to be longterm carriers is herpes and even this is manageable.
I can't believe any SPCA that is so cavalier about euthanizing treatable animals can find anyone willing to foster.
Mary - 15 Oct 2003 19:04 GMT > It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, today I > had to turn them over to the SPCA to get put down. If treated, it could [quoted text clipped - 18 lines] > Checked by AVG anti-virus system (http://www.grisoft.com). > Version: 6.0.522 / Virus Database: 320 - Release Date: 10/7/2003 Nest time you do something like this, please consider not announcing it. The only one who benefits from a confession is the confessor.
Elvis Parsely - 16 Oct 2003 18:06 GMT >> It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, >today I [quoted text clipped - 26 lines] >Nest time you do something like this, please consider not announcing >it. The only one who benefits from a confession is the confessor. Net time, I think certain individuals in this group might consider not being so judgmental about other people's situations and crucify them because of their own blind devotion to cat rescue.
Jade
Karen M. - 16 Oct 2003 23:35 GMT > >> It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, > today I [quoted text clipped - 32 lines] > > Jade Whoa-ho there. Isn't that what this group is about? Rescue? Otherwise, why post? I don't blame the poster, but I do question the RSPCA's decision, though it's not an uncommon one. I can't pass judgement for I don't know all the details. I adopted a kitten from one of my local shelters, who said she would probably be killed as she had a URI and they were crowded. I brought her home, she gave it to my male. He developed a horrid URI, herpes strain, that put him in the hospital for a week. Had he not died a few months later of unrelated causes, I would probably have a still sniffly, prone to viral outbreaks, yet mainly healthy cat on my hands. If that is what the RSPCA was afraid of - that the kittens would continue to get sick over time - that that might be why they decided to kill them, I don't know. But I don't think this is a good reason for *any* shelter to kill a cat. URI's are easy and, unless your cat decides a hospital stay would be pleasant, affordable to treat. Just IMO.
Karen M.
Elvis Parsely - 17 Oct 2003 13:31 GMT >> >> It turns out that my fosters had an upper respiratory infection- so, >> today I [quoted text clipped - 48 lines] >easy and, unless your cat decides a hospital stay would be pleasant, >affordable to treat. Just IMO. And that's your opinion, which is fine. I'm saying opinions about what is most humane for rescued kittens may vary in this group and I think that, as you say, without knowing all the details or the situation (YOu never could from what gets posted here) it is wrong to go screeching off at someone because of a decision that they made.
Living things die (even cute living things) that's a fact of life and we can't save every kitten. Respecting other peoples decisions and opinions would be a lot more productive and positive.
Just *MY* opinion.
Jade
>Karen M.
|
|
|