Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneral TopicsCat AnecdotesHealth and BehaviorRescue
CatKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Cat Forum / Health and Behavior / May 2005

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Loving cats <> taking care of cats

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
Brian Link - 20 May 2005 02:54 GMT
This is just a freeform musing occasioned by several recent events -

1. Tammy Quist's homepage slogan "She will never know freedom, can she
at least know compassion?" (http://www.wildcatsanctuary.org/index.htm)
2. The decision to find another home for Henry even though I loved him
3. The "hard tasks" Megan endured to get Henry acclimated.
4. Dealing with Louis' piss problem
5. Thinking while at the vet's that they had such a horrid job..
seeing sick cats and putting some to sleep

Now, the thing these have in common is the fact that the nutty cat
lover like myself quails at the "inconvenience" for the cat. Tammy's
(and Megan's) necessary work secluding and "inconveniencing" the cat
for their own good - so that they could live successfully with other
cats. Realizing that just loving Henry was not the same as convincing
him and Louis to get along. Realizing that a possible two week
seclusion period might be necessary to get Louis re-potty-trained.
Realizing that euthanasia is indeed the most sympathetic thing we can
do.

Cat hoarders don't understand this. They think bringing the stray in
from outside, while being incapable of caring for them, is a favor to
the cat. It's a favor to their own unformed emotional maturity.

The owner whose cat is in utter misery with a terminal illness, who
keeps the cat around for years, suffering, doesn't understand this.

I really love cats - but I don't have the maturity that people like
Tammy and Megan have to realize that anthropomorphizing cats is a
dangerous thing, since the very fact they're living indoors with us is
an unnatural convention.

The newest thing is switching our cats to wet food. Tiger's pretty
mad. The weak, immature cat-lover in me says "oh, Tiger shouldn't be
inconvenienced. Just give him his dry food back" while the smarter
person says "hey, all indications are that this step is in the cat's
best interest".

I dunno. Do you guys know what I'm talking about? I want these kitties
to be extremely happy - and have trouble looking past the short-term
problems toward the benefit over the long haul.

Breeders, trainers, fosters, vets - these guys are at a different
emotional level than most of us are required to attain. They know that
sometimes that cat's gonna be pissed, but it's for their own good. The
rest of us struggle with this, I guess.

BLink
sriddles@aol.com - 20 May 2005 03:53 GMT
> This is just a freeform musing occasioned by several recent events -
>
[quoted text clipped - 44 lines]
>
> BLink

I also have a hard time medicating/pilling or otherwise doing something
to my cats that I know is going to make them mad. I have a hard time
saying "no" when they want outside late in the day. It's just your
compassionate nature that doesn't want to inflict pain or or piss them
off, or make them think you're "punishing" them.
Funny thing is, I don't have a problem in the world pilling other cats.
Just mine. Even weirder, my daughter is an RN, and she can NOT inject
cats.
I don't have a problem with euthanasia for a very ill pet, not if it's
performed properly. I never have. I just have a problem with suffering.
Sherry
Monique Y. Mudama - 20 May 2005 05:35 GMT
> I also have a hard time medicating/pilling or otherwise doing
> something to my cats that I know is going to make them mad. I have a
> hard time saying "no" when they want outside late in the day. It's
> just your compassionate nature that doesn't want to inflict pain or
> or piss them off, or make them think you're "punishing" them.

For me, I think it's the fact that I cannot, and will never be able
to, tell them *why*.  As far as the cat's concerned, you're just being
arbitrarily mean.  I'll never be able to explain to Oscar why I have
to put her in the plastic thing, subject her to a noisy moving thing,
and then allow a stranger to touch her.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

bigbadbarry - 20 May 2005 06:30 GMT
"Monique Y. Mudama" <spam@bounceswoosh.org> wrote in message
> For me, I think it's the fact that I cannot, and will never be able
> to, tell them *why*.  As far as the cat's concerned, you're just being
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

If and when you have to put him in a carrier, just talk to her

Shure the one act of crating in itself is one thing, but don't underestimate
her, she trusts you right.

The whole experience will register in her mind, not the one deed.

Just think, at some point you are also going to be the one who opens her
prison door! lol
(once your back home)
Monique Y. Mudama - 20 May 2005 15:27 GMT
> "Monique Y. Mudama" <spam@bounceswoosh.org> wrote in message
>> For me, I think it's the fact that I cannot, and will never be able
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> Just think, at some point you are also going to be the one who opens
> her prison door! lol (once your back home)

She's fine once she gets home.  She doesn't "punish" me or avoid me or
anything.  I just feel so bad when I see how obviously scared she is.
The whole drive to the vet's, she's meowing, "Let me out, Mom.  Mom?
Mom?  Why are you doing this, mom?"

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Monique Y. Mudama - 20 May 2005 17:34 GMT
> She's fine once she gets home.  She doesn't "punish" me or avoid me
> or anything.  I just feel so bad when I see how obviously scared she
> is.  The whole drive to the vet's, she's meowing, "Let me out, Mom.
> Mom?  Mom?  Why are you doing this, mom?"

Which of course is me anthropomorphising her.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Cheryl - 20 May 2005 21:03 GMT
> For me, I think it's the fact that I cannot, and will never be
> able to, tell them *why*.  As far as the cat's concerned, you're
> just being arbitrarily mean.  I'll never be able to explain to
> Oscar why I have to put her in the plastic thing, subject her to
> a noisy moving thing, and then allow a stranger to touch her.

The worse for me is the constant crying in the carrier on the way to
the vet. :( So sad-sounding. They're usually quiet coming home
though. Hmm, I supose they know they're going home? :)

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

-L. - 20 May 2005 06:28 GMT
> This is just a freeform musing occasioned by several recent events -
>
[quoted text clipped - 35 lines]
>
> I dunno. Do you guys know what I'm talking about?

Yep.  Sure do.

>I want these kitties
> to be extremely happy - and have trouble looking past the short-term
> problems toward the benefit over the long haul.

Nothing exeplified that sort of feelinmg than when I had to take my
8-week old infant son in for his first vaccinations.  Broke my heart.

> Breeders, trainers, fosters, vets - these guys are at a different
> emotional level than most of us are required to attain. They know that
> sometimes that cat's gonna be pissed, but it's for their own good. The
> rest of us struggle with this, I guess.

I still struggle with it, even after having worked in the rescue field
for so long.

Nothing worse than having to euthanize your own pet.  It's bad enough
doing it to a sick animal for whom you are not the guardian.  It's
worse doing it to a healthy animal for lack of home.  But doing it to
your own animal is one of the most gut wrenching things you will ever
do.  It's a power I am glad I have yet sorry that I have as well.

I don't understand people who don't stay with their animal during
euthanasia.  I don't care how hard it is, IMO, it's disgraceful not to
be there with the animal during its final moments.  I found myself
drawn to the animals at the vet who were merely dropped off for euth.
I felt like they needed and deserved someone, and since nobody else
really "got it" except for one other tech, she and I would always be
the ones to be there for the animal.  It really made me hate people
sometimes.

-L.
Philip - 20 May 2005 07:32 GMT
snip
> I don't understand people who don't stay with their animal during
> euthanasia.  I don't care how hard it is, IMO, it's disgraceful not to
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>
> -L.

Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having its
eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
their pet's euthanisation from those who won't.
-L. - 20 May 2005 08:32 GMT
> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having its
> eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
> their pet's euthanisation from those who won't.

I don't know what you are talking about as an animals eyes remain open
when it is euthanized.  If you are saying you would rather remember
seeing the animal alive, that's just a cop out to spare your own
feelings.  Your animal's last memory will be of being scared and alone
at the hands of a stranger.  Who deserves to carry the burden - you or
your beloved pet?  I know I want my animals to know they were loved by
ME right until the last breath.

-L.
Philip - 20 May 2005 10:38 GMT
>> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as
>> having its eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
>
> -L.

Now you are anthropomorphizing a bit, Lyn.
Phil P. - 20 May 2005 19:21 GMT
> >> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as
> >> having its eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> Now you are anthropomorphizing a bit, Lyn.

No- its called compassion, empathy and fulfilling an obligation to a
life-long friend, you f.cking decrepit old piece of sh.t.
Dom - 22 May 2005 04:55 GMT
>  Your animal's last memory will be of being scared and alone
> at the hands of a stranger.  Who deserves to carry the burden - you or
> your beloved pet?  I know I want my animals to know they were loved by
> ME right until the last breath.

This was the hardest part of having Nic euthanized.  The vet had taken
him away to place a cath but his veins were shot and she couldn't get
one in.  They came back and asked if they could sedate him to make
things easier.  Because I was upset and not thinking straight, I
agreed.    Which meant that the next time I saw him, he was asleep...I
never really got to tell him goodbye. I mean, I held him while they
gave the final shot, but that's not the same. I should have insisted on
going back with him.  My cat's last memory was of stranger's touching
him and hurting him and I wasn't there.  I will NEVER forgive myself
for that.  It haunts me.  That was over a year ago and I'm sobbing just
thinking about, because I can't believe I let that happen.  I honestly
did want to be there with him, to let him know I was doing this because
I loved him so damned much, but I just...I wasn't thinking.  It breaks
my heart when people just drop off their pets and they're all alone.
But if it helps anyone out there, we really do treat such animals with
love and respect. We try to make things gentle and peaceful.  Grief
makes people do things they regret sometimes.  I had time to prepare
for Nic's death and I still lost my head and did something terrible.
How much worst must it be for someone who wasn't expecting it, as in
the case of an accident or sudden illness?  I guess I'm just saying
that I do think owners should stay with their pets...but I don't want
to judge too harshly anyone who does not because I've been there and it
rips me apart inside.

Sethran
-L. - 22 May 2005 08:15 GMT
> This was the hardest part of having Nic euthanized.  The vet had taken
> him away to place a cath but his veins were shot and she couldn't get
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> did want to be there with him, to let him know I was doing this because
> I loved him so damned much, but I just...I wasn't thinking.

He knows you loved him.  You can bet on that.

> It breaks
> my heart when people just drop off their pets and they're all alone.
> But if it helps anyone out there, we really do treat such animals with
> love and respect. We try to make things gentle and peaceful.

Are you a vet tech too?  I was for awhile - I took the job for fun,
just to learn more about vet medicine.  I lved that job in so many
ways.  I'd do it again in a heartbeat.  I, too, always tried to make
the transition easy for the animals, to let them know they are loved.

Grief
> makes people do things they regret sometimes.  I had time to prepare
> for Nic's death and I still lost my head and did something terrible.
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> to judge too harshly anyone who does not because I've been there and it
> rips me apart inside.

Oh absolutely.  I have BTDT when myu Mom died unexpectedly.  It kills
me still.

-L.
MaryL - 20 May 2005 12:25 GMT
> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having its
> eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
> their pet's euthanisation from those who won't.

I held each of my cats when they had to be euthanized.  I was not watching
their eyes; I was stroking them and taling to them.  Was it difficult?  Yes,
very difficult -- but I considered that to be my last gift of love to a
beloved companion.  When I think of these wonderful pets, I think of their
personalities and the special times we had together; I seldom think of that
last moment of euthanasia, but I also don't "block" it -- that was a
difficult time but was not traumatic to me because I was concentrating on
assuring that my cat's last moments would be as peaceful as possible and not
moments filled with fear (as would happend if they were left alone in a
vet's office).

MaryL
the Furrsome Foursome - 20 May 2005 13:34 GMT
I made the hard choice,when my dear Lenny became ill but resisted any
definitive diagnosis, to let him have exploratory surgery, in the hope
that what was causing his illness was a cohesive tumour that could be
removed.  It wasn't, and he was euthanized during the surgery, when
they found it was hopeless.  *I* wanted him back, but I couldn't put
him through the pain and confusion of recovery, only to have him
continue to waste away for a couple  more weeks.  The most devastating
though is that the last thing he knew was I left him.

He liked his vet and I had spent more than an hour with him, waiting
for the specialist surgeon, while he sat in a window and watched
squirrels and stole the clinic cats' toys and water.  They let me carry
him back to the surgery - but if I'd ever done this before, I'd have
know to ask if I could stay until he was sedated.  He was a very
attached and very vocal cat, and called after me as I left the room.

When his companion Lucy passed a couple months later, I was there with
her.  No surgery that time.  She had palpable, large, sudden tumour
growth.  Yeah, it was damn hard, but I stayed with her.  My vet gave
her a sedative shot first, on a nice blanket-covered exam table, and
she walked back across the table into my arms and hunkered down.    I
got to talk to her and pet her as she drifted off.

I don't think it's anthorpomorphizing to understand the difference
between an anxious, confused, or scared animal and one that is
comforted and calm because their familiar person is right there with
them.  Letting Lucy go was easier, because I knew she was tired and
sick and loney without her Lenny, but also because I knew she was calm
and comfortable.

Johanna
MaryL - 20 May 2005 14:09 GMT
>I made the hard choice,when my dear Lenny became ill but resisted any
> definitive diagnosis, to let him have exploratory surgery, in the hope
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> continue to waste away for a couple  more weeks.  The most devastating
> though is that the last thing he knew was I left him.

Don't beat yourself over this.  Lenny was unconscious when he was
euthanized, and he did not have any conception at that time that you had
"left him."  It would have been far worse -- in fact, it would have been
cruelty -- to try to keep him just for another week or two.  You made the
right decision.

<snip>
> When his companion Lucy passed a couple months later, I was there with
> her.  No surgery that time.  She had palpable, large, sudden tumour
> growth.  Yeah, it was damn hard, but I stayed with her.  My vet gave
> her a sedative shot first, on a nice blanket-covered exam table, and
> she walked back across the table into my arms and hunkered down.    I
> got to talk to her and pet her as she drifted off.

My experience was similar except that I held each of my cats while they were
given a sedating injection, then euthanized.  Both of them were completely
calm at the time, and that means a lot of me.  I said earlier that I
consider this to be a "final gift of love" (which I do).  Oddly, I think it
was also a gift to myself because I know there was no fear or pain for them
at the end, and they were in the arms of someone who loved them (and they
knew it).

> I don't think it's anthorpomorphizing to understand the difference
> between an anxious, confused, or scared animal and one that is
> comforted and calm because their familiar person is right there with
> them.  Letting Lucy go was easier, because I knew she was tired and
> sick and loney without her Lenny, but also because I knew she was calm
> and comfortable.

Agreed!

> Johanna

--
MaryL
Furrsome Foursome - 20 May 2005 14:38 GMT
Hey, Mary -

Oh, I'm not "beating myself up" over it.  And I know Lenny was unaware
when he was euthanized.   My comment was more that if I ever have to do
that again.... commit an animal to an unknown like that... I'd want to
stay until he was sedated/unconscious.  I know I did the right thing,
but the last that we saw of each other was me putting him down on the
prep table and walking out of the room.  We both could have been a
little more comforted if I'd been there while he drifted off.

In the end, yeah, it was a harder difference for me than for him.
Probably once I was out the door, he turned back to the vet and the
techs and said "'kay, what's up girls?  Somebody pet me!" - he was a
very social boy and like I said, he generally liked his vets and staff.
My boyfriend would tell me that when I left the apartment, Lenny would
yell after me for a few minutes - he never did that when my guy went
out and I stayed home - but then he'd settle down and go look for the
next person to hang out with.

But I made a note for myself - if its ever a decision I have to make
again, I'll stay with my furry buddy during the prep, until they're
beyond awareness.   I think a vet who wouldn't accomodate that is not a
vet to whom I want to take my business.

Cheers,

Johanna
Philip - 20 May 2005 18:54 GMT
snip

> I don't think it's anthropomorphizing to understand the difference
> between an anxious, confused, or scared animal and one that is
> comforted and calm because their familiar person is right there with
> them.

I would agree.

>  Letting Lucy go was easier, because I knew she was tired and
> sick and lonely without her Lenny, but also because I knew she was calm
> and comfortable.
>
> Johanna

Now you're anthropomorphizing a bit.
Cheryl - 20 May 2005 21:15 GMT
> I made the hard choice,when my dear Lenny became ill but
> resisted any definitive diagnosis, to let him have exploratory
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> for a couple  more weeks.  The most devastating though is that
> the last thing he knew was I left him.

But the thing he knew the most was how much you loved him and cared
for him every day from the time you were united right through to
that day.

> He liked his vet and I had spent more than an hour with him,
> waiting for the specialist surgeon, while he sat in a window and
> watched squirrels and stole the clinic cats' toys and water.

Aww.. I like the sound of that. When my poor Shadow had to be left
at the animal hospital, the techs liked him so much that they made
sure to put him in a cage closest to the window so he could look
outside. I was grateful for their care.

<snip>

> When his companion Lucy passed a couple months later, I was
> there with her.  

<snip>
That's rough. Two so close together. Something that anyone with
cats of the same age has experienced. :(

> I don't think it's anthorpomorphizing to understand the
> difference between an anxious, confused, or scared animal and
> one that is comforted and calm because their familiar person is
> right there with them.  Letting Lucy go was easier, because I
> knew she was tired and sick and loney without her Lenny, but
> also because I knew she was calm and comfortable.

It isn't. And I completely agree. I wouldn't have it done without
being there no matter how painful it is.

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

Mary - 20 May 2005 17:27 GMT
> > Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having its
> > eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> moments filled with fear (as would happend if they were left alone in a
> vet's office).

Beautifully put, MaryL. I would not allow any of my animals to go through it
alone if I had the choice. They love and trust me and so my voice and smell
and touch comforts them.
Janet B - 20 May 2005 17:39 GMT
>Beautifully put, MaryL. I would not allow any of my animals to go through it
>alone if I had the choice. They love and trust me and so my voice and smell
>and touch comforts them.

OMG yes.  As far as "eyes", my vet (during the only euthanasia of one
of my own pets I've had to deal with) had prepared the whole setup so
carefully, including pre-euthanasia sedative, etc of course, a
blanket, and my wonderful dog in front of me, not facing me.  I
watched him go and gently closed his eyes as he went.  It was a very
peaceful experience, and one I cannot imagine failing to do - we owe
it to them.

Signature

Janet B
www.bestfriendsdogobedience.com
http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/bestfriendsobedience/album

MaryL - 20 May 2005 17:51 GMT
>> > Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having
> its
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
> smell
> and touch comforts them.

Thanks.  Our furbabies deserve to have our love and attention "to the very
end."

MaryL
Mary - 20 May 2005 18:03 GMT
> >> > Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having
> > its
[quoted text clipped - 26 lines]
> Thanks.  Our furbabies deserve to have our love and attention "to the very
> end."

And while they may not understand *words* they understand that our scent,
voice, and touch means
love and safety and that comforts them. It is what they
die feeling--and a good death, if there is such a thing.
Achh, where are my babies, I have to go give them hugs!
bigbadbarry - 20 May 2005 20:15 GMT
> And while they may not understand *words*

I made an observation this morning, it was raining, :) and cat wanted out!

I said, "rrrain" he cocked his to one side, and went and sat down.
-L. - 20 May 2005 17:54 GMT
> I held each of my cats when they had to be euthanized.  I was not watching
> their eyes; I was stroking them and taling to them.  Was it difficult?  Yes,
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> MaryL

And people forget that death is *part of* life.  I cannot imagine
abandoning my animal at his or her final moments any more than I could
imagine doing so to a loved one.  You learn so much when a loved one
dies - whether it be human or non-human.

-L.
MaryL - 20 May 2005 18:21 GMT
>> I held each of my cats when they had to be euthanized.  I was not
> watching
[quoted text clipped - 23 lines]
>
> -L.

Absolutely.  My brother-in-law died of leukemia a number of years ago, and
we learned the value of those who were willing to endure some "discomfort"
themselves in order to comfort him.  Some who had been good friends never
came to the hospital; they said it made them uncomfortable (but think of how
uncomfortable *he* was).  Those who truly could show compassion ignored
their own discomfort in order to comfort him.  The same thing is true of our
beloved pets.  How can anyone possibly claim to love a cat or dog and then
simply leave that same pet at the vet's for euthanasia because it would
"hurt" too much to see their companion die???  That is simply selfishness.

MaryL
Mary - 20 May 2005 17:09 GMT
> snip
> > I don't understand people who don't stay with their animal during
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
> their pet's euthanisation from those who won't.

Their eyes do not close when they are euthanized. Actually the saddest thing
is the limp tail. I was with my
cat for *her* comfort, not for mine.
bigbadbarry - 21 May 2005 02:15 GMT
>I was with my
> cat for *her* comfort, not for mine.

Bless your heart.
Mary - 21 May 2005 05:27 GMT
> >I was with my
> > cat for *her* comfort, not for mine.
>
> Bless your heart.

You would, and will, do the same if you have to face this
with any cat. You're a good old soul. The soul part is old, not you, see. :)
kaeli - 23 May 2005 14:36 GMT
> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as having its
> eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what separates those who watch
> their pet's euthanisation from those who won't.

For some, that is possibly true.

For others, it's about ourselves as well as our pets. I had to be present for
my cats who were PTS because all I could think about was how I didn't want
them to feel frightened and abandoned at their time of death. And I wanted to
be assured that they *didn't* suffer at that time. I wanted their last memory
to be of me holding them and petting them, not some stranger putting them on
a cold table and sticking them with a needle. It sure made me feel better
(later -- I was a wreck at the time) and I truly hope it made a difference
for my kitties.
My last memories of my cats who have been PTS is them looking peaceful, lying
on a towel, like they were sleeping. This is not a bad memory to have. It
makes me feel good that I know they were indeed at peace when they died.

Signature

--
~kaeli~
A plateau is a high form of flattery.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

Philip - 23 May 2005 17:40 GMT
>> Do you wish to cherish the memory of your pet's last moments as
>> having its eyes open ... or closed?  This I believe is what
>> separates those who watch their pet's euthanisation from those who
>> won't.
>
> For some, that is possibly true.

Hi Kaeli.  Did you notice how literal one member here became ... stating
that a euthanasized cat dies with its eyes still open?  Talk about missing
the big picture.  Sheesh.

> For others, it's about ourselves as well as our pets. I had to be
> present for my cats who were PTS because all I could think about was
> how I didn't want them to feel frightened and abandoned at their time
> of death. And I wanted to be assured that they *didn't* suffer at
> that time. I wanted their last memory...

It's actually YOUR last memory.  Memories disappear with brain death.

> ... to be of me holding them and
> petting them, not some stranger putting them on a cold table and
> sticking them with a needle. It sure made me feel better (later -- I
> was a wreck at the time) and I truly hope it made a difference for my
> kitties.

Of course. You still have the rest of your life to process the grief and
loss.

> My last memories of my cats who have been PTS is them looking
> peaceful, lying on a towel, like they were sleeping. This is not a
> bad memory to have. It makes me feel good that I know they were
> indeed at peace when they died.

That final image is a powerful one. Choose it wisely. It will be with you
for a long time.
Mary - 23 May 2005 18:11 GMT
"Philip" <1chip-state1@earthlink.n0t> wrote >
> Hi Kaeli.  Did you notice how literal one member here became ... stating
> that a euthanasized cat dies with its eyes still open?  Talk about missing
> the big picture.  Sheesh.

Right. The fact is you have never been with an animal that you had
euthanized, or you would have known that.
kaeli - 23 May 2005 19:58 GMT
> > For others, it's about ourselves as well as our pets. I had to be
> > present for my cats who were PTS because all I could think about was
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> It's actually YOUR last memory.  Memories disappear with brain death.

Yes and no.
It is my last memory of them, true.
But I meant it's the last thing they experience -- now who's being too
literal? LOL
Also, I don't rule out the possibility of life after death in some form or
another, so I can't rule out the possibility that we do actually remember
things after we die somehow. I have seen no true proof either way (nor do I
expect to), and it's against my scientific mind, yet my spiritual mind wants
to think it is true...so I figure I might as well err on the side of caution.
It doesn't hurt anything for me to be there, and there is a chance that it
hurts my beloved pet for me to NOT be there. Actually, for those few minutes
before death, it's nearly a guarantee that it hurts them if I'm not there.
So, I have to be there.

> > My last memories of my cats who have been PTS is them looking
> > peaceful, lying on a towel, like they were sleeping. This is not a
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> That final image is a powerful one. Choose it wisely. It will be with you
> for a long time.

So very true.
Choose wisely whether to acompany your pet to be PTS also because it's not
like you can ever change your mind. If you choose to not go, then later you
feel guilty, you're pretty much feeling guilty over that for the rest of your
life, to some extent. I didn't go with my dog when I was a kid and it bothers
me to this day. Whether the feelings are rational or anthropomorphizing or
not is subjective and debatable. The fact is, I feel them and they suck.

That's why this decision is such a difficult one for many people -- you can't
take it back. My Mom almost didn't go with our Tom when it was his time. She
said she just couldn't do it, that it hurt too much. She was going to have me
take him. We all loved him, and he loved us, but Mom was his favorite person.
I told her I would take him, but explained that she might feel guilty over it
later if she didn't go. She decided to go. She thanked me later and told me
how much it eased her mind to know that his last moments were indeed
peaceful.
It's as much, if not more so, for our own peace of mind as for our pet's,
when you really think about it. All I know is that I have only NOT gone once,
and I regret that a lot. I have never regretted being there. So, that's why I
have to go.

Signature

--
~kaeli~
Local Area Network in Australia:... the LAN down under.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

Philip - 23 May 2005 20:43 GMT
>>> For others, it's about ourselves as well as our pets. I had to be
>>> present for my cats who were PTS because all I could think about was
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> death, it's nearly a guarantee that it hurts them if I'm not there.
> So, I have to be there.

You do have an unusual level of wisdom for your years, Kaeli.

"Better to conduct your life as if there is a Heaven but then find out there
isn't one .... than to conduct yourself as if there is no Heaven and then
find out there is."

>>> My last memories of my cats who have been PTS is them looking
>>> peaceful, lying on a towel, like they were sleeping. This is not a
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> feelings are rational or anthropomorphizing or not is subjective and
> debatable. The fact is, I feel them and they suck.

You were a kid. Gathering wisdom requires life experiences.

> That's why this decision is such a difficult one for many people --
> you can't take it back. My Mom almost didn't go with our Tom when it
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
>
> --
bigbadbarry - 23 May 2005 21:47 GMT
"kaeli"

> This is not a bad memory to have. It
> makes me feel good that I know they were indeed at peace when they died.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
> http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

I'm jumping in middle of thread, want to say, my Aunt had her cat "Bentley"
cremated, now Bentley sits on the fireplace mantle.

--
Barry

... Women and cats are both black at night. - Bosnia ...
Cheryl - 20 May 2005 21:07 GMT
> Nothing worse than having to euthanize your own pet.  It's bad
> enough doing it to a sick animal for whom you are not the
> guardian.  It's worse doing it to a healthy animal for lack of
> home.  But doing it to your own animal is one of the most gut
> wrenching things you will ever do.  It's a power I am glad I
> have yet sorry that I have as well.

Agreed. I often think about my 2 most recent - Shadow (Jul-04) and
Marley (Feb-02). :( They were obviously ready to go, but I wasn't
ready to let them go. It's a gift to be able to do so, though.

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

Cheryl - 20 May 2005 20:57 GMT
> I dunno. Do you guys know what I'm talking about? I want these
> kitties to be extremely happy - and have trouble looking past
> the short-term problems toward the benefit over the long haul.

Cats have short memories. When they're happy and healthy again (if
they were sick that is) they won't remember what they went through to
get well. Then again, if its something that goes on for a long time
(being attacked by another cat for example, over and over again, for
a long time before the human steps in) it can cause long term trauma
that may never be overcome.

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

Philip - 21 May 2005 05:33 GMT
>> I dunno. Do you guys know what I'm talking about? I want these
>> kitties to be extremely happy - and have trouble looking past
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> a long time before the human steps in) it can cause long term trauma
> that may never be overcome.

Oh yeah, right.  When your cat's only experiences in a car are going to the
vet ... cats don't forget the horrors at the end of the "leaving home" ride.
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.