Home | Contact Us | FAQ | Search & Site Map | Link to Us
Sign In | Join | Other 45 Sites in Network
Home
Discussion GroupsGeneral TopicsCat AnecdotesHealth and BehaviorRescue
CatKB.com
Contact UsLink To UsSearch & Site Map

Cat Forum / Health and Behavior / May 2006

Tip: Looking for answers? Try searching our database.

Inappropriate toileting... I'm at the end of my rope!

Thread view: 
Enable EMail Alerts  Start New Thread
Thread rating: 
the Furrsome Foursome - 04 May 2005 12:39 GMT
Hello, all....

It's been a couple years since I've done more than occasionally read
here (I'm an old, old, OLD timer from when there was just
rec.pets.cats, though I recognize so few names now).

I am posting in a last-ditch cry for help.  After years of being the
"cat therapist" all my friends turn to... I may have been beat.

Maui is a goofy seal-point Siamese, adopted from my vet a year and a
half ago after Lenny and Lucy passed away.  He came with a partner,
Blue.   They had been left to my vet after ther previous person died.
Other than rather stressed at all the changes in their lives, they were
a pair of healthy 7 year old Meezers.

For a year and a half, we've been trying to get Maui to use the
litterbox.  He does... but he also uses the apartment carpet.  And he's
launched his latest escalation of this behaviour recently.

He both urinates and defecates in random spots.  Despite the fact that
there have been 2 or 3 completely clean litterboxes out for him.  He
goes for weeks or a few months without doing this, we think we've
"fixed" it, then the puddles, or worse, just the smells we have to
track down, start again.

We have ruled out organic causes.  He's been to the vet over and over.
He's STAYED at the vet for 2 weeks, then lived in a bathroom for a
week, with perfect litter-box behaviour then soaked the carpet again.

My vet, who is a Guelph and Cornell-trained cat specialist and a damn
good cat shrink herself, has been to my home herself and sat and
watched us, inspected the litterboxes, checked for things she might see
as stresses.... nothing obvious.  She said my litter boxes are cleaner
than hers are some days.  They're the biggest I could get.  We've tried
them covered and uncovered.

No urine crystals or infection.  No apparent pain, masses, tumours...
short of running him through an MRI which I can't do, we can't find
anything.

We've tried Feliway, but this is not spraying/urine marking, it's flat
on the floor, often in the middle of the room.

He's been on Prozac.  He's presently on Clomicalm.  Both may or may not
have helped temporarily - maybe they did or maybe  he just decided to
behave for a bit -  but any effect definitely didn't stick.

We don't yell, scold, or freak out at him, rather we try to reward him
when he uses the litter box, if we're around.  He seems to appreciate
it and will go through spells of coming to "get" me to watch him use
the box and then taking a treat.  But it also doesn't "stick".

The only other thing is he (and his friend Blue) occasionally gets
vetacortyl shots, as every few months he has a flare-up of something
that causes them to groom patches out of their fur.  The toileting
problem hasn't been noticeably tied to this other issue, but again,
it's hard to tell.  Blue doesn't seem to have this issue.

Last night, he soaked my office floor right behind me while I was
sitting right there!  I didn't hear he was in the room until he started
scraping the carpet to "bury" it.  This morning, the puddle was outside
our bedroom door as we got up, fresh and warm.
Like he waited for the alarm, went out the door far enough to pee, and
came back to bed as we were getting up.

I've used enough Nature's miracle to fill a swimming pool by now, and I
am about to get kicked out of my home with all 4 of my cats by a very
unhappy and usually very tolerant partner....

Can ANYONE suggsest ANYTHING I might be missing, that could be doing
this?

I'm about to give in, conclude he just plain doesn't want to be here
(can't handle the multi-cat life with its inevitable scuffles and
disputes) and return him to the vet.  This would not be disatrous for
him, they came with a "bring them back if you ever need to" guarantee
and my vet has offered many times - I just hate to give up, and I had
to separate him from his pal even though they don't seem that attached.
Plus he can be a nice cat when he tries....

Sorry to go on so long.  I just really am at a loss, after 13 years of
being "the cat lady" to everyone who knows me.

Thanks,

Johanna
With a Furrsome (presently) Foursome of Panda-ov-Toes, Sprout!, Maui
and Blue...
kaeli - 04 May 2005 13:47 GMT
> Can ANYONE suggsest ANYTHING I might be missing, that could be doing
> this?

I have no idea, but I hope you get it worked out.
I do have a relative who has this little dog who simply cannot be potty
trained for whatever reason (probably my relative's fault, but who knows).
The dog just doesn't "get" it.
You know what they do?
The dog wears a diaper -- one of those diapers for dogs in heat, with a human
pantyliner in it.

Just a thought, even if it's more amusing thinking about your cat running
around in a diaper than an actual feasible "solution".
Good luck.

Signature

--
~kaeli~
The man who fell into an upholstery machine is fully
recovered.
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart
http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace

Janet B - 04 May 2005 14:01 GMT
>Just a thought, even if it's more amusing thinking about your cat running
>around in a diaper than an actual feasible "solution".
>Good luck.

If I put a diaper on Carey, someone would be removing it.  The other
cat, Carey herself, one of the dogs.  I just can't fathom how that
could possibly be a solution!

Pee on the sofa this morning, after 1.5 good weeks :-(  I am not a
happy 24/7 laundry maid.

Signature

Janet B
www.bestfriendsdogobedience.com
http://pg.photos.yahoo.com/ph/bestfriendsobedience/album

---MIKE--- - 04 May 2005 14:05 GMT
>>She said my litter boxes are cleaner
>> than hers are some days.

Is it possible that your litter boxes are TOO clean?  Sometimes there
needs to be a little smell to remind them what the box is for.

                 ---MIKE---
>>In the White Mountains of New Hampshire
Helen Miles - 04 May 2005 14:17 GMT

> I'm about to give in, conclude he just plain doesn't want to be here
> (can't handle the multi-cat life with its inevitable scuffles and
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> Sorry to go on so long.  I just really am at a loss, after 13 years of
> being "the cat lady" to everyone who knows me.//

When I got Robbie, he came with a history of "middening", which is where
a cat defecates to try and establish his right to use a territory.
Basically, Robbie would just about anywhere - even in front of you. He's
a very "sensitive" cat, very jumpy, as he had an horrendous abouse
history before I got him - the abuse was one of the reasons he came to
Cats Protection.

Because he came into a quiet house, with one other cat and didn't have
to compete for his right over a territory, his middening behaviour
stopped. He now lives on his own with my mom and dad, and his litter box
habits are immaculate.

Has your cat been "mugged" by one of the other cats as he uses the
litter box, making him wary about using it? If you're using an open box,
try a closed one where he feels more secure, or if you're using a closed
one, try an open one where he can see what is going on.

Have you tried changing the type of litter you use? My cat Tiger refuses
point blank to use anything pine based, Robbie won't use anything clay
based. Neither cat likes to use scented litter and both use un-scented
"Yesterdays News" happily.

Maybe he just really wants a home of his own with no other cats.

It really does sound like to me that it is a territory thing - where is
he in the pecking order of the household?

Helen M
Have you tried changing the litter type?
the Furrsome Foursome - 04 May 2005 15:10 GMT
Hiya - well, nice to know I'm at least not alone!

I have indeed thought it is a territory, or territory/anxiety thing.  I
right now have two "pairs" of cats.  Panda and Sprout, who used to be
half of a cuddly foursome, and Maui and Blue, who came as a pair after
Lenny and Lucy both passed away.  There is definitely a two-and-two
dynamic.  "Pecking order" is hard to peg, but wherever he is, I guess
he's not happy.  He has moments of trying to challenge Panda, who I
think is really Top Cat here, and then other moments of letting teeny,
skittish little Blue push him away from his food and he's fine with
that.

Maui and Blue, prior to my house, spent their entire lives in a one
bedroom apartment with one little old lady.  They never saw other
animals and they had never seen *men*, and I have one of those too.
Maui's definitely skittish *at times* - but dang it all, we had a Great
Dane visit for a few days over the holidays and he thought she was the
greatest thing ever and followed her everywhere - so he is not
categorically intimidated by new or strange animals/people.

I have suspected it is a passive-aggressive reaction to my partner.
Maui appears to really seek out Adam's attention at times and then
other times Adam does something and Maui runs away.  By "does
something" I don't mean assaults the cat... I mean he sneezes, or
laughs out loud, or turns the radio on, or just gets up and walks to
another room too fast.  He's a heavy man, occasionally clumsy, and I
think just startles the cats sometimes.  Or maybe he just ignores Maui
at the wrong moment - last night's and this mornings incidents were
timed within minutes of Adam coming home and getting up for work,
respectively, like Maui was looking to attract someone's attention at a
time when we were otherwise busy.

As to other litter box behaviour, Sprout is a boisterous little brat
with a sense of humour, and has had to be actively discouraged from
ambushing other litter box users, which she seems to think is fun.
But it's been over a year since we've caught her doing that and she
prefers to assault Blue, who we've never had cause to suspect in any
incidents more serious than, um, "hangers on" following her out of the
box.  And Panda is grumpy and will hassle Maui over food, or sit in a
door and kindof dare him to walk past her - but again, that seems to
have lessened and the toileting has gotten worse.

We've tried a couple of different litters but I'm nervous about putting
any other cats off the box, as we use wheat litter to avoid their and
my own allergies to the clay dust.  We've tried the boxes covered and
uncovered.  And I don't think they could possibly be *too* clean.  I
scoop at least once and sometimes twice a day, but with 4 cats somone
will inevitably run right in and use it.  I cannot add 4-boxes-plus-one
to this apartment - it is physically too small.  I've gotten to 3, and
the third one will sit for days, unused by ANY of the cats, believe it
or not.  I've tried varying box heights, sizes, configurations and
positions.  I moved a box right over one of the first carpet messes -
and he went right beside it.  I moved it back and just cleaned the
carpet, and he found a completely different spot to go.

I have at times isolated Maui for days at a time with his own box in
our spare bathroom.  He will sometimes go a day or more without using
the box, and when I let him out, he'll go on the carpet.... OR he'll go
right to one of the other boxes and use it!  At another time after
isolation, he HAD been using the box in the bathroom, consistently for
a few days.  Then ran out and went on the carpet anyway.  He screams
the whole time he's in the bathroom so it is not feasible for him to
live in there indefinitely.  Blue also gets upset when he's locked away
and screams OUTside the bathroom.

I am getting close to the conclusion that he just can't cope with
something about the dynamic here.  I feel terrible about losing him,
even though my brain knows that my vet will keep him as a clinic cat.
I feel bad about separating him from Blue, too, but she will be OK
without him - she is VERY people-attached and Maui is just a familiar
pal to her but she'll ignore him if Adam or I am around and sometimes
just hang out on her own regardless.  She doesn't seem to miss him when
he's not around, though she does cling for a bit when he comes back
after an absence, then settle back to herself again.  He might miss her
more, as he's not as people-social.  I'd rather get rid of the carpet
but replacing the flooring in a 1500 sq foot rental we hope to leave in
a year would not be feasible.  The landlord would only replace with
more carpet - at our expense - and if I have to do that I'm only doing
it ONCE (and cleaning like hell to avoid that, anyway).

*sigh*... he may have to resign himself to being a clinic cat.  he will
still be in a multi-cat place, with other *males* even but the vet
claims she has well-sealed floors and lots of cleaning staff (her other
cats are at her shop for the same reason, what's one more?)

Thanks,

Johanna
Karen - 04 May 2005 17:45 GMT
Hmmm. Maybe your partner needs to carry treats/and or be "Feliway scented"?

> I have suspected it is a passive-aggressive reaction to my partner.
> Maui appears to really seek out Adam's attention at times and then
[quoted text clipped - 64 lines]
>
> Johanna
cmtowle - 04 May 2005 20:03 GMT
> Hiya - well, nice to know I'm at least not alone!
>
> I have indeed thought it is a territory, or territory/anxiety thing.

Hi Johanna,

It sounds as though you have indeed done just about everything possible to
make things work. Thank you for posting your experience in such detail, it
gives us a comprehensive picture of what is happening and makes it easier to
come up with possible solutions. I have some thoughts which I hope are
helpful.

I agree with you that it is highly likely a combination of territorial
issues plus anxiety (since both Blue and Maui exhibit fur-pulling behaviour
as you mentioned in your first post, this is another sign of intense
stress). The problem has been going on for quite some time and it does sound
as though the best course of action would be to separate the cats, but I do
not think that removing Maui and making him a clinic cat at your vet's will
resolve the problem for him. He will still be stressed and while it is
commendable that your vet is willing to accept "inappropriate" peeing at the
clinic, he will still be unhappy. The stressors of other animals, animals in
distress, people, men etc. will not have resolved and the comings and goings
at a vet clinic are a lot more stressful than the situation Maui is in now.
If this were my situation, I would try to find a quiet and gentle home for
Blue *and* Maui with a single woman. I know, I know, it's not easy to
re-home adult cats, but it can be done with time and patience and both you
and your partner have demonstrated that you have tons of both.

...snipped...

> There is definitely a two-and-two
> dynamic.  "Pecking order" is hard to peg, but wherever he is, I guess
> he's not happy.  He has moments of trying to challenge Panda, who I
> think is really Top Cat here, and then other moments of letting teeny,
> skittish little Blue push him away from his food and he's fine with
> that.

In the meantime, is it possible to create two territories in your home - one
for each pair to reduce the stressors as much as possible, so that Maui can
start feeling safer?

> Maui and Blue, prior to my house, spent their entire lives in a one
> bedroom apartment with one little old lady.  They never saw other
> animals and they had never seen *men*, and I have one of those too.

...snipped...

> I have suspected it is a passive-aggressive reaction to my partner.

...snipped...

> I am getting close to the conclusion that he just can't cope with
> something about the dynamic here.  I feel terrible about losing him,
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> after an absence, then settle back to herself again.  He might miss her
> more, as he's not as people-social.

The dynamic between them as you describe it is the reason I would re-home
them together.

...snipped...

> *sigh*... he may have to resign himself to being a clinic cat.  he will
> still be in a multi-cat place, with other *males* even but the vet
> claims she has well-sealed floors and lots of cleaning staff (her other
> cats are at her shop for the same reason, what's one more?)

See above why I do not think this is a good idea nor do I think it would be
fair to Maui.

While not the same situation, I can relate. I rescued a starving and very
sick stray last year.  She pulled through and metamorphosed into an
affectionate, healthy, and playful kitty from an emaciated, scared, and
skittish one. I was determined that with careful introductions things would
be just fine between her and the resident kitties. Unfortunately, the
dynamics between them  were extremely stressed from the beginning. After
months of trying just about everything, I had to continue keeping them
segregated and finally came to the conclusion that she would be happier in a
home as an only cat (she had been the only animal in her previous two
homes). I interviewed umpteen potential adopters until I found exactly who I
was looking for. Emma is now a happy and thriving cat and her new human
adores her. It was very difficult to let her go, but I knew what she needed
and that she deserved as stress-free a life as possible.

I hope that you will reconsider placing her at your vet's. By word of mouth,
asking everyone you know, placing posters (with photos of the two) in
unusual places (for example, I used the message boards of several
professional associations) and being very clear about what and who you are
looking for, you will, in time, find someone wonderful for them.

In the meantime, if it is possible in your home for them to have a territory
of their own, things should settle to more tolerable levels for all
concerned.

I hope this helps.

M.

> Thanks,
>
> Johanna
the Furrsome Foursome - 04 May 2005 21:05 GMT
Actually, though, he lived at the vet for quite some time before I got
him... and my adoption "contract" to which I agreed was, if there are
any problems, he will go back to that vet.  He has already lived there
for an extended visit (> 2 weeks) during a particularly bad spell and
exhibited NO inappropriate or stress behaviour while there.

Since being with me in general he is healthier, fatter and more mellow
than with his previous owner, and when visiting the vet he likes to
tour around and hang out with the staff.

Also - the lick dermatitis is allergic, or at least partly so.  They
had it in their previous home and living at the clinic and it responds
immediately to a minimal dose of vetacortyl, clears up in a couple of
days and stays cleared for months.   Food changes would be best, but
finicky and underweight Siamesees that they are, we haven't been able
to find something they WILL eat that solves it.

I'm not talking about dumping him in an uncaring clinic to be just one
more stray underfoot.  Dr. W. has known these cats since they were
born.  She had an agreement with a client to either re-home or take
care of Maui and Blue, and was paid out of their former person's estate
to do so.  She and her staff are all female and Maui loves them.  She
lives in her clinic.  Or, her clinic is in her house, we're sometimes
not sure which it is!  Cats, exams and surgeries downstairs, husband, 7
housecats a squirrel and I think a bird upstairs.   Her clinic cats
have their own room and the run of the reception area complete with
leather sofas and a 6 x 3 x6 foot high cat jungle installation in a
huge glassed in window that's a complete squirrel-watching
entertainment centre.

She regularly takes in, rehabilitates and shelters and adopts out
unwanted cats in addition to her vet practice, expenses out of her own
pocket, but the deal is they come back to her if they can't be lived
with.  She may re-home them if that's appropriate.  I know he won't
just be put down for being a problem.

We shall see.  She's asked if I can keep him through next weekend as
she'd want to quarantine him as a re-admit regardless and her kennel is
full right now.  My man is attached enough to him to be reluctant to
let him go despite the frustration, too.  Unfortunately, our apartment
is ppretty "open concept" except the bathrooms, so it may be back into
the bathroom for  a little time out for him.   And another gallon of
nature's miracle with a valium chaser for me!

Thanks,

Johanna
Philip - 04 May 2005 21:06 GMT
>> I'm about to give in, conclude he just plain doesn't want to be here
>> (can't handle the multi-cat life with its inevitable scuffles and
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> horrendous abouse history before I got him - the abuse was one of the
> reasons he came to Cats Protection.

This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get them
trained right from the beginning.
Monique Y. Mudama - 05 May 2005 05:54 GMT
>> When I got Robbie, he came with a history of "middening", which is
>> where a cat defecates to try and establish his right to use a
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get
> them trained right from the beginning.

"used" cat?

Freak.

Signature

monique

Mary - 05 May 2005 06:02 GMT
> >> When I got Robbie, he came with a history of "middening", which is
> >> where a cat defecates to try and establish his right to use a
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> Freak.

Very nicely put, Monique.
Philip - 05 May 2005 07:10 GMT
>>> When I got Robbie, he came with a history of "middening", which is
>>> where a cat defecates to try and establish his right to use a
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
>
> Freak.

"Used cat"  "Pre-owned"  "Screwed up"  "Uncivilized"  "Space Kitty"  and any
other labels you find unpleasant to your PC senses.

Ever see the movie "Used People", starring Shirley MacLaine?  Does that
title piss you off already?  LOL
Mary - 05 May 2005 07:25 GMT
> >>> When I got Robbie, he came with a history of "middening", which is
> >>> where a cat defecates to try and establish his right to use a
[quoted text clipped - 15 lines]
> Ever see the movie "Used People", starring Shirley MacLaine?  Does that
> title piss you off already?  LOL

Monique might not know that movie. She, like I, am
a tad younger than dirt.
Helen Miles - 05 May 2005 15:33 GMT
> This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get them
> trained right from the beginning.///

My father wouldn't part with Robbie for all the tea in China, and I
wouldn't make him. I don't regret adopting him for one single second. To
see a scared, traumatised, frightened kitty blossom into a loved and
pampered pet who is confident in himself to overcome his fears and
terrors, and now see him spoiled rotten living in the lap of luxury,
because of something *I* was able to do (i.e. adopt him) is THE most
rewarding thing I could ever do.

If anyone has done any training, it's been Robbie training my father how
to pamper him.

I'm glad I don't have your attitude - I've had years and years of
pleasure and companionship from everyone of my *used* cats.

Helen M
Philip - 05 May 2005 16:43 GMT
>> This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get
>> them trained right from the beginning.///
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> Helen M

Dear Helen. You have my attitude but loathe to ever express it. The context
of my comment references taking on a "high effort" training project from a
pound and what to do when you have "reached the end of your rope" (the title
of this thread).  Now your post is very touching, warm and fuzzy. But your
rescue is unlike the original poster's.  Your rescue "fit".... her's has not
in spite of considerable effort.  See the difference?
Helen Miles - 05 May 2005 18:33 GMT
> Now your post is very touching, warm and fuzzy. But your
> rescue is unlike the original poster's.  Your rescue "fit".... her's has not
> in spite of considerable effort.  See the difference?

I'm so glad you found my post warm, touching and fuzzy.

How about I talk about my other *used* cat, Pandora, who after 4 years
wtill has major behaviour problems because of the fact she is semi-feral
and was abused as a kitten. Or shall I tell you about Cleo, who had
serious toileting problems when I first got her because hse had been ill
for so long? I know, I could tell you about my feral sam, who was so
spooky I couldn't handle him.

None of my rescues "fit" as you call it. Every single one of them does
however return affection in their own way. Tell you what, you have your
perfect hallmark "new" kitty that you can train from scratch, and I'll
stick to my "pre-used" rescued kitties who have their problems.

Helen M
Philip - 05 May 2005 19:03 GMT
>> Now your post is very touching, warm and fuzzy. But your
>> rescue is unlike the original poster's.  Your rescue "fit".... her's
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> for so long? I know, I could tell you about my feral sam, who was so
> spooky I couldn't handle him.

When the book comes out in paperback and is a national best seller, I'll
read your copy. ;^)

> None of my rescues "fit" as you call it.

In fact they DO fit because of your need to accomdate "project" kitties. Be
honest. Such "projects" fill a need you have.

> Every single one of them does
> however return affection in their own way.

Being recognized as the food and shelter source does command some respect.

> Tell you what, you have
> your perfect hallmark "new" kitty that you can train from scratch,
> and I'll stick to my "pre-used" rescued kitties who have their
> problems.
>
> Helen M

Whatever, lady.  Now you've drifted off into a holier than thou mode. Have a
good day!
-L. - 05 May 2005 16:22 GMT
> This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get them
> trained right from the beginning.

Gee Phillip, generalize much?

Many many "second-hand" cats make lovely pets.  As do dogs:
http://www.amazon.ca/exec/obidos/ASIN/0876057350/701-9139148-6349156

-L.
Philip - 05 May 2005 17:00 GMT
>> This makes a case for NOT adopting a used cat. Get a new one, get
>> them trained right from the beginning.
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>
> -L.

Is it still too early in my tenure around here to post a bit of male sarcasm
without punctuating with emoticons?  Guess that's the case!  ( |^D   You
know us guys always relate things to cars .... don't you?
Monique Y. Mudama - 05 May 2005 17:55 GMT
> Is it still too early in my tenure around here to post a bit of male
> sarcasm without punctuating with emoticons?  Guess that's the case!
> ( |^D   You know us guys always relate things to cars .... don't
> you?

I don't see anything male or female about this.  I once posted
something about how it's a good thing Oscar is cute, or she'd be out
of here.  I was joking, and I thought it was obvious, but Phil P.
took me to task.  Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom
occasionally post here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes
about pets.  A lot of the people who post here have seen some of the
worst and most negligent sides of pet "ownership."  In light of all of
that ... yes, please do clarify when you're joking.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Philip - 05 May 2005 19:03 GMT
>> Is it still too early in my tenure around here to post a bit of male
>> sarcasm without punctuating with emoticons?  Guess that's the case!
>> ( |^D   You know us guys always relate things to cars .... don't
>> you?
>
> I don't see anything male or female about this.

Well, get educated.  ;^)

> I once posted
> something about how it's a good thing Oscar is cute, or she'd be out
> of here.  I was joking, and I thought it was obvious, but Phil P.
> took me to task.

"Phil P." and I have exchanged pleasantries where I subtly told him to go
lick himself.  ;^)

> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom
> occasionally post here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes
> about pets.  A lot of the people who post here have seen some of the
> worst and most negligent sides of pet "ownership."  In light of all of
> that ... yes, please do clarify when you're joking.

Ok. But colorful and provocative terminology aside, I was NOT joking.
Monique Y. Mudama - 06 May 2005 01:28 GMT
>> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom occasionally post
>> here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes about pets.  A
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> Ok. But colorful and provocative terminology aside, I was NOT
> joking.

Oh.  Well, then, my original comment still stands.

Freak.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Philip - 06 May 2005 07:01 GMT
>>> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom occasionally post
>>> here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes about pets.  A
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> Freak.

Sweetheart .... when you have a cogent thought treat it kindly.  It's in a
strange place.
Noon Cat Nick - 06 May 2005 09:45 GMT
> >>> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom occasionally post
> >>> here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes about pets.  A
[quoted text clipped - 13 lines]
> traipse off to practise the viola da gamba like the apotheosis of
> grandiloquence that I am, you supercilious beings, you. Ta!
Philip - 06 May 2005 18:26 GMT
>>>>> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom occasionally
>>>>> post here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes about
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>> Sweetheart .... when you have a cogent thought treat it kindly.
>> It's in a strange place.

NoonCat takes editorial license:

>>Now pardon me whilst I finish my tea and
>> biscuit and then traipse off to practise the viola da gamba like the
>> apotheosis of grandiloquence that I am, you supercilious beings,
>> you. Ta!
Noon Cat Nick - 06 May 2005 19:18 GMT
> >>>>> Turns out there are a lot of people, some of whom occasionally
> >>>>> post here, who really do have those sorts of attitudes about
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
> >> apotheosis of grandiloquence that I am, you supercilious beings,
> >> you. Ta!

My, you're sentient. For once.
Philip - 04 May 2005 21:06 GMT
> Can ANYONE suggsest ANYTHING I might be missing, that could be doing
> this?
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
>
> Johanna

A truth in life is: Problems scale themselves to our maximum ability to
solve them.  You've met your match. You know it. You're environment is not
agreeable with this particular furry food processor. Turn him in.

One other thing.  If your carpet is covering genuine wood floors, repeated
pissing in any location WILL blacken the wood and make each wood strip
shrink away from adjoining strips. This kind of damage was apparent in a
neighbor's home when they changed their carpeting.  About two thousand
dollars worth of damage.
Noon Cat Nick - 04 May 2005 21:29 GMT
> Hello, all....
>
[quoted text clipped - 67 lines]
> Can ANYONE suggsest ANYTHING I might be missing, that could be doing
> this?

I'm telling you, you've got one angry cat.

I had a cat, Ari, who performed the same behavior you just described.
He'd even do it right in front of me. The vet exam came out fine. Then
the doc suggested that, since we'd moved to a new domicile, Ari had no
place he could call his own. Two other pets (a cat and a dog) plus a new
spouse had left him without his own territory. And he was very upset
about it. So he was doing his part to ruin things for everyone--and
doing it right where we could see him.

At the vet's advice, we put him each night in an unoccupied room with
his own litter box at one end and his food and water at the other. Then
we'd shut the door. He'd howl and scratch to be let out, but we kept him
in there all night long. After three weeks or so, he got the message
that that was *his* room. Then he started going in of his own accord.
Once he did that, the elimination problems ceased. Once in a while he'd
start it again, but another week or so of nightly confinement to the
room would put him back to rights.

HTH.
the Furrsome Foursome - 04 May 2005 22:06 GMT
That's what I'll be doing for now.  He loves his bathroom, too.  He
gets treats in there.  He just hates being *alone* in there.  If one or
both of us is in there with him, he purrs like crazy and can't get
enough petting and bonking.  If I have a bath in there (it's the only
one with a tub) he sits on the edge and talks about his day.  If we
leave him in there by himself, he howls.

Was Ari siamese?  I'm not a very light sleeper, but never did learn to
sleep through howling siamese.  I suppose I could sleep in the tub...

:-)
Noon Cat Nick - 05 May 2005 03:20 GMT
> That's what I'll be doing for now.  He loves his bathroom, too.  He
> gets treats in there.  He just hates being *alone* in there.  If one or
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> Was Ari siamese?  I'm not a very light sleeper, but never did learn to
> sleep through howling siamese.  I suppose I could sleep in the tub...

No, just a somewhat noisy yellow tabby.
Monique Y. Mudama - 05 May 2005 05:51 GMT
> Was Ari siamese?  I'm not a very light sleeper, but never did learn
> to sleep through howling siamese.  I suppose I could sleep in the
> tub...

All the hard surfaces in a bathroom make the sound carry much farther
than it should, too ... I wonder if you could dampen the sound with
blankets or something?  No expert here; just a thought.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Adam Helberg - 04 May 2005 23:37 GMT
> Hello, all....

Assuming there is no organic cause here are a few ideas. My Oreo had a soiling
problem which, knock on wood is gone.

Try to eliminate stress especially from other cats. Don't let stray cats in.

Try adding a third box in a spot where he likes to soil. Sometimes the location of
your box is wrong.

Try Cat Attract Litter. Sometimes a cat does not like the litter.

Although it is not recommended to use punishment, the longer the habit continues the
more difficult it will be to break so you cannot ignore any act of soiling. If you
catch the cat soiling immediately use negative reaction such as water spray, loud
voice. You can also hold the cat's face right onto the area of soiling for a couple
of minutes to negatively associate with the soiling. You can do this even if you
don't catch the cat in the act. Every time you ignore the soiling the behavior
becomes more reinforced so you have to negate this reinforcement.

Adam
zuzu22@webtv.net - 04 May 2005 23:52 GMT
>If you catch the cat soiling immediately
>use negative reaction such as water
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
>behavior becomes more reinforced so you
>have to negate this reinforcement.

To the OP:
IGNORE the above advice. Not only is it incorrect and guaranteed to
cause your cat more stress, it is also abusive.

Megan

                                   
Signature


"The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
nothing."

-Edmund Burke

Learn The TRUTH About Declawing
http://www.stopdeclaw.com

Zuzu's Cats Photo Album:
http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22

"Concerning all acts of initiative (and creation), there is one
elementary truth the ignorance of which kills countless ideas and
splendid plans: that the moment one definitely commits oneself, then
providence moves too. A whole stream of events issues from the decision,
raising in one's favor all manner of unforeseen incidents, meetings and
material assistance, which no man could have dreamt would have come his
way."

- W.H. Murray


Philip - 05 May 2005 00:27 GMT
>> If you catch the cat soiling immediately
>> use negative reaction such as water
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> Megan

Agreed.   Smearing the cat's nose in it's own feces doesn't have the effect
desired by the owner.
cmtowle - 04 May 2005 23:54 GMT
...snipped...

> Although it is not recommended to use punishment, the longer the habit continues the
> more difficult it will be to break so you cannot ignore any act of soiling. If you
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> don't catch the cat in the act. Every time you ignore the soiling the behavior
> becomes more reinforced so you have to negate this reinforcement.

While I agree that the longer the behaviour lasts, the more difficult it is
to undo as it can become a habit, the point is to find out *why* the
"inappropriate" behaviour (from our point of view) is occurring rather than
punish him or her for communicating in one of the ways s/he knows how that
something is amiss. Punishment as you suggest only serves to increase the
already existing stress for the cat and merely creates fear and more
anxiety. It does absolutely nothing to resolve the reason for the behaviour
and is completely devoid of caring and compassion for the animal.

M.

> Adam
Philip - 05 May 2005 00:19 GMT
> ...snipped...
>
[quoted text clipped - 19 lines]
>
> M.

Rubbish.  Compassion is the driving force behind "training."  You do NOT
care if you tolerate bad behavior until / if ever you figure out the "why"
of a behavior.  It does not matter "why."  Write a new script featuring the
new behavior and teach it.

It seems to me that you are another one of those who fails to differentiate
"training" from "punishment."  Punishment is using the cat for football
practice or a Piñata.  Training is coating electrical cords with foul
tasting materials so the cat stops chewing on them or training the cat to
hop up on the people toilet to relieve himself.
cmtowle - 05 May 2005 01:15 GMT
> Rubbish.  Compassion is the driving force behind "training."  You do NOT
> care if you tolerate bad behavior until / if ever you figure out the "why"
> of a behavior.  It does not matter "why."  Write a new script featuring the
> new behavior and teach it.

Following your logic, it would not matter whether the reason for the
"inappropriate" behaviour is medical or not. It would not matter whether
there are stressors causing the behaviour which should be reduced or
eliminated. Sounds to me that what matters is all about making you happy,
not the cat.

> It seems to me that you are another one of those who fails to differentiate
> "training" from "punishment."

The punishment strategies Adam suggested for "inappropriate" elimination:
water spray, loud voice, and holding the cat's face over the soiled area
have absolutely nothing to do with "training" and demonstrate a lack of
understanding of feline behaviour, feline communication, and the
consequences of the suggested punishments.

>Punishment is using the cat for football
> practice or a Piñata.

No, this is abuse.

>Training is coating electrical cords with foul
> tasting materials so the cat stops chewing on them

Yes, this is training and not at all analogous with the strategies suggested
above.

> or training the cat to
> hop up on the people toilet to relieve himself.

While this may be training, it also demonstrates a complete lack of
understanding of feline instincts and behaviour.

M.
Cheryl - 05 May 2005 02:04 GMT
>>Punishment is using the cat for football
>> practice or a Pi¤ata.
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
> While this may be training, it also demonstrates a complete lack
> of understanding of feline instincts and behaviour.

All of your advice is great. Something struck me while reading
Johanna's dilema that something more is going on (OBVIOUSLY!!!),
but I just can't describe what I'm thinking. I know that Sherry had
problems with one of hers, and had to let her cat (can't remember
which one. Frank?) use towels on the bathroom floor and just
launder them frequently. Another poster used newspaper in the
litterbox. Yet another just used a bathmat in the litterbox (this
was recently) because the cat would only go on a bathmat. I had one
who would always go on clothes left on the floor but that was easy
to remedy, and I just didn't leave clothes on the floor.  

All this just reminds me that some cats are just impossible to
"train". They aren't wired like us. Something in their wild nature
doesn't make sense of litterboxes and the stuff we try to pass off
as a toilet. Maybe Johanna could try just plain dirt in the box?
It's messy as hell (had to do that with a neuter/release situation
here with one stray/feral cat).

I wish Johanna the best in whatever she decides is best.

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

Philip - 05 May 2005 03:04 GMT
>>> Punishment is using the cat for football
>>> practice or a Pi¤ata.
[quoted text clipped - 32 lines]
>
> I wish Johanna the best in whatever she decides is best.

Cats are trainable.  Some much more than others.  All we have to do is get
the Bengal owners roused again to prove it. Smarter cats can be toilet
trained, trained to fetch things, trained to walk on a leash, trained to run
to an open car door and hop in, trained to yak furballs only in one place in
the house, trained to accept claw clipping, etc.  Others ... take months
just to find their butts without help.  And let us not overlook owners who
are simply not up to the task of training.  There are some of those here.
Cheryl - 05 May 2005 03:19 GMT
> Cats are trainable.  Some much more than others.  

Key words here. "Some more than others".

Obviously OP's cat isn't as trainable as others, or there is some
other issue. There's a reason for it. Can't dismiss the fact that
what works for most doesn't work for hers. And her cat shouldn't be
given up on, even if it seems all has been tried. I can't say I've
been in that situation because as I said, my problem with
inappropriate elimination was solved by being tidy.

All we have to
> do is get the Bengal owners roused again to prove it. Smarter
> cats can be toilet trained, trained to fetch things, trained to
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> who are simply not up to the task of training.  There are some
> of those here.

You're snarky and boring and mildly entertaining.

Signature

Cheryl

"The clever cat eats cheese and breathes down rat holes with baited
breath."
- W.C. Fields

Philip - 05 May 2005 05:18 GMT
>> Cats are trainable.  Some much more than others.
>
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>
> You're snarky and boring and mildly entertaining.

My post is about trainable cats and secondarily, owners who just are not up
to the task of training.  May I return the 'compliment' by saying you are a
little condescending.
Philip - 05 May 2005 03:04 GMT
>> Rubbish.  Compassion is the driving force behind "training."  You do
>> NOT care if you tolerate bad behavior until / if ever you figure out
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> Following your logic, it would not matter whether the reason for the
> "inappropriate" behaviour is medical or not.

You don't follow the logic.  Animals die because owners believe themselves
qualified to figure out the "why" of a behavior.  It's up to the owner to
quickly and accurately discern medical from psychological. Howver misplaced,
a healthy BM precludes a medical condition.  Nobody has identified other
than ... a healthy but misplaced turd.

> It would not matter
> whether there are stressors causing the behaviour which should be
> reduced or eliminated. Sounds to me that what matters is all about
> making you happy, not the cat.

Since you used the word "all", your argument is that of a fanatic. How much
misbehavior will you suffer before you start feeling sorry for yourself?
Where's the human dignity in suffering a house wreaking of urine and feces?
Hmmm?  I know for a fact there are people out there who have such low self
esteem that they come to worship their pets and cater to every percieved
whin.  Pathetic.

>> It seems to me that you are another one of those who fails to
> differentiate
[quoted text clipped - 24 lines]
>
> M.
cmtowle - 05 May 2005 04:58 GMT
> You don't follow the logic.  Animals die because owners believe themselves
> qualified to figure out the "why" of a behavior.

You are right, your logic does not follow.

>It's up to the owner to
> quickly and accurately discern medical from psychological.

Ah, so it *is* important to discern the "why" of a behaviour.

>Howver misplaced,
> a healthy BM precludes a medical condition.  Nobody has identified other
> than ... a healthy but misplaced turd.

So a behaviour that occurs because of stress is not worthy of the same
caring and attentive inquiry as one based on a medical condition? Why not?

> > It would not matter
> > whether there are stressors causing the behaviour which should be
> > reduced or eliminated. Sounds to me that what matters is all about
> > making you happy, not the cat.
>
> Since you used the word "all", your argument is that of a fanatic.

Hardly, but be my guest, take the "all" away and my view still stands.

>How much
> misbehavior will you suffer before you start feeling sorry for yourself?

Ah, but you see, if one attempts to find the "why" diligently and if one
either gets assistance from a feline specialist or is experienced enough to
sleuth it out on one's own *and* is compassionate (I know, I know, a red
flag word for you), the situation does not get to the point you describe
above and below.

> Where's the human dignity in suffering a house wreaking of urine and feces?

A house reeking of urine and feces is a house with humans who are either
uncaring or uneducated in terms of cat care.

> Hmmm?  I know for a fact there are people out there who have such low self
> esteem that they come to worship their pets and cater to every percieved
> whin.  Pathetic.

Once again, your logic does not follow and your propensity for labelling
people makes *you* sound extreme.

M.
Philip - 05 May 2005 07:06 GMT
snip
>> It's up to the owner to
>> quickly and accurately discern medical from psychological.
>
> Ah, so it *is* important to discern the "why" of a behaviour.

I see we are separated by a common language.  I've met those who think if
only they can out psyche the cat, that they can fix the cat.  What is
incumbent upon the cat owner is to quickly discern behavior issues from
medical and act accordingly.  Figuring out the "why" is secondary and if
medical, better dealt with by a medical professional. Understand better?

The rest of your post is mildly provocative drivel, "M".
cmtowle - 05 May 2005 16:56 GMT
> > Ah, so it *is* important to discern the "why" of a behaviour.
>
> I see we are separated by a common language.  I've met those who think if
> only they can out psyche the cat, that they can fix the cat.

Apparently, because we disagree, you choose to misinterpret what I have
stated. Or, perhaps you are not able or willing to *hear* what is being said
because of the views and values you have demonstrated in your posts. I will
try again.

Attempting to discern what is causing a particular behaviour, which to those
who share their lives with animals with an attitude of caring and compassion
indicates a sign of distress, is not about one's ability to "out psyche" or
"fix" the cat. It is about creating a feline-friendly environment in which
the particular animal is as content as possible.

>What is
> incumbent upon the cat owner is to quickly discern behavior issues from
> medical and act accordingly.  Figuring out the "why" is secondary and if
> medical, better dealt with by a medical professional. Understand better?
>
> The rest of your post is mildly provocative drivel, "M".

Also apparent in your posts is your propensity to dismiss with derision that
with which you do not agree. It is unfortunate that you choose to react
defensively rather than learn something and be open to the  people in this
world you label "PC" and "dysfunctional" who have an exquisite sensitivity
for animals, human and non. People who would not label animals that come
with challenges as "used" any more than they would equate humans with
inanimate objects.

M.
Philip - 05 May 2005 17:53 GMT
>>> Ah, so it *is* important to discern the "why" of a behaviour.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> Apparently, because we disagree, you choose to misinterpret what I
> have stated.
snip

Opening with the word "Apparently ..." tells me I was correct in my
assessment of our communication, setting aside all that followed.  Yes, you
choose to misinterpret for reasons familiar only to you.
Biskybabe - 05 May 2005 18:28 GMT
>>> Ah, so it *is* important to discern the "why" of a behaviour.
>>
[quoted text clipped - 11 lines]
> "fix" the cat. It is about creating a feline-friendly environment in which
> the particular animal is as content as possible.

It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
animal that the behaviour is unacceptable.

For instance, one of our cats will strike at me when she gets
overexcited during a petting session. When this happened, I would tell
her no, remove her from the bed and then ignore her for a period of
time. I also tried to identify what I was doing to trigger the
behaviour and be more aware of her body language during a petting
session so that she didn't have the urge to strike.

What ended up happening is not only did the frequency of striking
decrease, but the severity has as well. She sometimes still does it,
but now it's with less force and she keeps her claws sheathed. I also
will make her sit or give her some toys to derail whatever it is that's
going on in her brain that's causing her to build up to a strike.

The combination of training and awareness has been extremely effective.

bisky
Philip - 05 May 2005 19:03 GMT
> It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
> unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
[quoted text clipped - 6 lines]
> behaviour and be more aware of her body language during a petting
> session so that she didn't have the urge to strike.

It occurred to you that the "strike" was the cat communicating a desire to
cease petting her .... and that you might be a little dense about picking up
the clue?  My last cat would communicate his desire to stop stroking him
with a polite nip.  I soon figured out this warning nip would be preceded by
a cessation in purring.  Clue.  No purring ceased ... stop stroking. "Enough
already" from the cat.

snip
> The combination of training and awareness has been extremely
> effective.
> bisky

You are a bit brighter and observant than some others here.
Biskybabe - 05 May 2005 20:48 GMT
>> It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
>> unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
[quoted text clipped - 10 lines]
> to cease petting her .... and that you might be a little dense about
> picking up the clue?

That is irrelevant. Striking is an inappropriate way to communicate
with humans. She can find another way to communicate her wishes to me,
but she cannot strike or bite me or anyone else. The communication is
fine, the method is unacceptable.

b
Philip - 05 May 2005 23:17 GMT
>>> It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
>>> unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> That is irrelevant.

It's the WHOLE POINT, silly.

> Striking is an inappropriate way to communicate
> with humans.

However unpleasant the "communication", what is ... is.  So I see this as a
two fold problem.  The Human needs to become more in tune with this
particular puss and the Cat needs to be taught some other course of action
to convey the message "Stop fussing with me."   Do  you disagree?

>She can find another way to communicate her wishes to me,
> but she cannot strike or bite me or anyone else. The communication is
> fine, the method is unacceptable.
>
> b

Why should she? You have a cat that resorts to physical measures to convey
the message because you are a little dense and a little intense, for her
liking.  LOL  But don't escalate this into a bitchfight.  For what it's
worth, some people stroke and scratch a cat with their fingernails while
other just rub with the tips of their fingers.  Try changing your style and
definitly shorten your petting time.
Biskybabe - 06 May 2005 00:00 GMT
>>>> It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
>>>> unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
[quoted text clipped - 14 lines]
>
> It's the WHOLE POINT, silly.

No, the why is irrelevant. It is unacceptable behaviour and she cannot
communicate with humans that way.

But I come from the large animal bit of the world where it doesn't
matter why horse/cow/whatever decides to invade your space, they can
kill you without meaning to.

>> Striking is an inappropriate way to communicate
>> with humans.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> of action to convey the message "Stop fussing with me."   Do  you
> disagree?

Did you read what I originally wrote? I think if you read what I
originally wrote you will find your answer.

>> She can find another way to communicate her wishes to me,
>> but she cannot strike or bite me or anyone else. The communication is
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
>
> Why should she?

Because that is not acceptable for her to do. It is not an appropriate
way to communicate with humans. She's smart and she is completely
capable of learning how to communicate with us in ways that don't
involve inappropriate aggression.

> You have a cat that resorts to physical measures to convey the message
> because you are a little dense and a little intense, for her liking.  
> LOL  But don't escalate this into a bitchfight.

It's not a bitchfight. It's simple rules. Similarly, she's not allowed
on the table or the counters as long as a human is around (I'm not dumb
enough to expect that they stay off the table when someone's not
around, although neither cat gets up there often). She's not allowed to
claw the furniture, a rule we even enforce with the feral who comes
inside sometimes.

As to the 'petting sessions are so long' I don't believe that because
it hasn't always been triggered by me petting her. It's very clear
she's getting *excited* and happy and droolly and she starts moving
around and won't settle ... and then those ears go back and I know that
we need to stop the disconnect between her forebrain and her hindbrain
before the hindbrain takes over and she does something her forebrain
knows she shouldn't.

One of my responses was to teach her to sit on command. When she starts
getting too excited, she has to sit if she wants more pets or
interactions with the human. The whole process between me saying "sit"
and her actually doing it makes her sort stuff out and re-engage her
forebrain and calm down and everyone's happy.

I use the terms 'forebrain' and 'hindbrain' very loosely in this post.
They are a descriptor of her different behavious. Forebrain are those
behaviours we taught her after trapping her and moving her inside.
Hindbrain are those instinctive behaviours and the ones she learned as
a feral kitten.

As a side affect, she's learned that if she can make the humans pet her
by sitting next to them.

bisky
Philip - 06 May 2005 05:14 GMT
>>>>> It strikes me that one can look for the causes of an unwanted /
>>>>> unacceptable behaviour at the same time as one communicates to the
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
> No, the why is irrelevant. It is unacceptable behaviour and she cannot
> communicate with humans that way.

Oh?  Does she "communicate" with *just* *you* in this physical manner?

> But I come from the large animal bit of the world where it doesn't
> matter why horse/cow/whatever decides to invade your space, they can
> kill you without meaning to.

So are you projecting this history of yours onto a small animal?

snip
> One of my responses was to teach her to sit on command. When she
> starts getting too excited, she has to sit if she wants more pets or
[quoted text clipped - 12 lines]
>
> bisky

IF?  What's the rest of that thought?
Adam Helberg - 05 May 2005 01:55 GMT
> ...snipped...
>
[quoted text clipped - 22 lines]
>
> M.

You need to look for causes and stressors and try to eliminate those, but once a
behavior becomes a habit (assuming there is no medical cause) it can perpetuate even
with removal of the original cause, as cats in particular are creatures of habit.

If you ignore the episodes of soiling and just clean up the behavior will become a
habit and you're doomed to failure. IMO.

My cat Oreo that I adopted was an abandoned, declawed cat that was soiling when I
first got her.  She also soiled a couple of years later after I adopted a kitten.
Both times I've been able to train her out of this with the methods I mentioned (not
just negative behavior mod). The number of times that I actually had to use the
negative behavior mod was very small but each time it helped.

Adam
Philip - 05 May 2005 03:04 GMT
> You need to look for causes and stressors and try to eliminate those,
> but once a behavior becomes a habit (assuming there is no medical
> cause) it can perpetuate even with removal of the original cause, as
> cats in particular are creatures of habit.
> If you ignore the episodes of soiling and just clean up the behavior
> will become a habit and you're doomed to failure. IMO.

Agreed.

> My cat Oreo that I adopted was an abandoned, declawed cat that was
> soiling when I first got her.  She also soiled a couple of years
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> negative behavior mod was very small but each time it helped.
> Adam

In the ears of some here, what corrective measures you took will be equated
to shaving the cat bald and tying it up outside in the snow.  Really.
Philip - 04 May 2005 23:55 GMT
snip
> Although it is not recommended to use punishment, the longer the
> habit continues the more difficult it will be to break so you cannot
> ignore any act of soiling. If you catch the cat soiling immediately
> use negative reaction such as water spray, loud voice. You can also
> hold the cat's face right onto the area of soiling for a couple of
> minutes to negatively associate with the soiling.

While I agree with you (rebuke inappropriate behavior AS it is happening or
within a minute of the transgression), you're likely to get wails of rebuke
from the dysfunctionally compassionate members here.  ;-)   Swift kitty
relocation whilst urinating gets the message across.  I did this single
handed by grabbing a handful of skin between the shoulders and a rag in the
other hand positioned under the tail. Deposit cat in litter box.  Never took
very many of those "moments" to get the message across.

> You can do this even if you don't catch the cat in the act.

Unlike dogs, cats need immediate situation correction to "get it."  It may
take a dozen times for a particularly stupid or angry puss.

> Every time you ignore soiling the behavior becomes more reinforced so you
> have to negate this reinforcement.
> Adam

NO sh.t!   LOL
Monique Y. Mudama - 05 May 2005 05:46 GMT
> Adam Helberg wrote: snip
>
>> You can do this even if you don't catch the cat in the act.
>
> Unlike dogs, cats need immediate situation correction to "get it."
> It may take a dozen times for a particularly stupid or angry puss.

This doesn't work for dogs, either.  Just don't shove an animal's nose
in its own waste.

Signature

monique, who spoils Oscar unmercifully

pictures: http://www.bounceswoosh.org/rpca

Adam Helberg - 05 May 2005 06:35 GMT
>> Adam Helberg wrote: snip
>>
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> This doesn't work for dogs, either.  Just don't shove an animal's nose
> in its own waste.

Firstly, you don't have any ideas just criticism. Secondly, you don't necessarily
have to shove the animals nose *into* it's waste, and you *don't* smear the waste on
the animal, as someone else said. You can hold the cat's face close the waste to make
this an unpleasant experience. You are trying to get a negative association with
soiling outside the box. If you do nothing the behavior gets reinforced--each time
the cat soils outside the box it feels rewarded and the habit is strengthened.

It' important to try to remove stresses that can cause the cat to soil.  If you
combine removing stress and behavior modification the system should work, and once
the cat starts using the box again that behavior gets reinforced and you should be on
your way.

Adam
Philip - 05 May 2005 07:06 GMT
>> Adam Helberg wrote: snip
>>
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> This doesn't work for dogs, either.  Just don't shove an animal's nose
> in its own waste.

A notable difference concerning dogs is that this kind of negative
experience (rubbing their nose in the poop) sometimes results in a dog that
will eat its own misplaced excrement (or vomit) so as to hide the evidence
that would lead to another unpleasant rebuke by the owner.  Let's not
mention that TV commercial where the dog drinks out of the toilet bowl and
then runs over to the door and licks its owner's face (the woman unknowing).
blkcatgal - 05 May 2005 00:09 GMT
Not that I'm a big proponent of meds, but why did you stop using the prozac
and clomicalm?  I have a cat that sprays, definitely territorial, and he has
been on prozac which has really helped curb his spraying.  It takes about 4
weeks to see the full effect of the meds.  Sounds like if the meds helped,
you may want to keep him on it.  Beats cleaning up the messes on the floor.

Also, there is a litter called "Cat Attract" which is suppose to help
inappropriate elimination problems.  I have never used it myself but it may
be worth trying.

Sue
> Hello, all....
>
[quoted text clipped - 84 lines]
> With a Furrsome (presently) Foursome of Panda-ov-Toes, Sprout!, Maui
> and Blue...
Philip - 05 May 2005 00:27 GMT
> Also, there is a litter called "Cat Attract" which is suppose to help
> inappropriate elimination problems.  I have never used it myself but
> it may be worth trying.
>
> Sue

Why would *you* use a litterbox instead of a toilet?   ;-)
bigbadbarry - 05 May 2005 04:49 GMT
> Hello, all....

He's doing it to get attention.
Adam Helberg - 05 May 2005 19:31 GMT
> Hello, all....
>
[quoted text clipped - 84 lines]
> With a Furrsome (presently) Foursome of Panda-ov-Toes, Sprout!, Maui
> and Blue...

Something else to add. If you buy a bag of Cat Attract litter it comes with a very
good booklet on this problem.

Adam
BarB - 05 May 2005 21:07 GMT
>Hello, all....
>
>It's been a couple years since I've done more than occasionally read
>here (I'm an old, old, OLD timer from when there was just
>rec.pets.cats, though I recognize so few names now).

Ha, I remember Panda-ov-Toes.

>I am posting in a last-ditch cry for help.  After years of being the
>"cat therapist" all my friends turn to... I may have been beat.
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>litterbox.  He does... but he also uses the apartment carpet.  And he's
>launched his latest escalation of this behaviour recently.

Why is it frequently the super-intelligent, high-strung, people-
oriented, highly-vocal Siamese who does this? I've been through it
with two, run all the tests, did everything imaginable and the
solution finally came down to a new home. I just have too many cats
coming and going, I guess.

Peekaboo would pee in front of me on the bed and sometimes on me.  I
got so I would carry her to the litterbox and tell her to pee and she
would. Of course if I waited too long or was gone, she peed on the
bed instead. I finally found a home for her on trial with a couple of
guys who thought her behavior was a hoot. Now she can be prima donna
only cat. She is quite happy, they are happy and the behavior has
ceased.

Geordie also peed all over. I never did quite figure out why. He was
born here to a mother whom I still have. Confine him to a separate
room or cage and he howled non-stop. Again, a new and quieter home
where he could have ALL the attention seemed to be the answer.

Good luck,

BarB
Philip - 05 May 2005 23:17 GMT
> Why is it frequently the super-intelligent, high-strung, people-
> oriented, highly-vocal Siamese who does this? I've been through it
[quoted text clipped - 18 lines]
>
> BarB

You sleep alone, don't you.  LOL  Wouldn't be surprised if you lived alone
too!
mlbriggs - 27 May 2006 19:06 GMT
> Hello, all....
>
[quoted text clipped - 82 lines]
> With a Furrsome (presently) Foursome of Panda-ov-Toes, Sprout!, Maui and
> Blue...

Sounds like you have tried everything except the squirt bottle.  Of
course, this would only be used if caught in the act.MLB
 
Sign In
Join
My Latest Posts
My Monitored Threads
My Blog
My Photo Gallery
My Profile
My Homepage

Start New Thread
Enable EMail Alerts
Rate this Thread



©2008 Advenet LLC   Privacy Policy - Terms of Use
This website includes both content owned or controlled by Advenet as well as content owned or controlled by third parties.