Cat Forum / Health and Behavior / November 2004
small NO KILL animal shelter in need of your help to fix up donated building!
|
|
Thread rating:  |
The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary - 26 Oct 2004 04:29 GMT Hello fellow animal lovers! I am writing as the coordinator for The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc. a small scale non-profit 501c3 NO KILL small animal shelter. Our shelter was previously located on a farm property, but recently went up for sale leaving us scrambling to find a place for our 150 animals to live. This summer, we received an abadoned and dilapidated property via donation and have been working very hard to fix it up. We seem to have hit a roadblock within the last couple of weeks.
In order to proceed following the proper channels to get us up and running, we need to go through the Township and apply for the proper zoning variances and exceptions and building permits, etc. We estimate this will cost us at least $500-- which is $500 that we simply do not have. We do not want to compromise care of our animals (who are temporarily being sheltered off site until we have everything done properly)and we need to raise funds ASAP! It is a real Catch-22 for us! As many of you know, smaller shelters almost always struggle financially, because donations and funding goes to the large scale, well known shelters, who are often not no-kill!
Any donations, whether small or large, are DESPERATELY needed and always appreciated!!!
Any donations can be sent to: The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc. P.O. Box 194 York New Salem, PA 17371
OR can be conveniently made online with a credit or debit card on the website www.thelastresort.us
We are a 501c3 non-profit and all donations are tax deductable!
PLEASE help us raise these much needed funds! Even if you can only donate a few dollars, it still helps us greatly. Pass this along!!!
Any support and suggestions for raising funds and gaining awareness are always welcome!
Thanks, The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc.
Sherry - 26 Oct 2004 05:17 GMT >Hello fellow animal lovers! >I am writing as the coordinator for The Last Resort Animal [quoted text clipped - 41 lines] >Thanks, >The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc. I admire what you're doing, but I'm curious. You require every relinquished cat come to your shelter with: a $50 fee; proof of spay/neuter/proof of vaccination/proof of feleuk testing. What do you do when someone brings in a stray? Do you *only* take animals that are ready to immediately adopt back out? Makes your org. sound suspicious to the average reader who's 500 miles away. I read your website with interest, and you don't mention grants...have you applied for any? Start-up grants are the easiest and most accessible for shelters to get. Also, and this is just IMO, but I'd lose the "Ed is the Devil" story & segment of the website. It makes your organization look less than credible. Like you said, it's easier for larger, established, professional shelters to get donations. Polish your website, and you'll have more credibility. Also, the photo shows cats, etc. that look dreadfully crowded in one room.. For fundraising ideas, Best Friends is a good resource. Or just network with other shelters. Best of luck.
Sherry
PawsForThought - 26 Oct 2004 13:21 GMT >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary)
>Any donations can be sent to: >The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc. >P.O. Box 194 >York New Salem, PA >17371 Sorry, but I only donate to shelters I know are legitimate, and only shelters in my immediate area. ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
PawsForThought - 26 Oct 2004 13:22 GMT >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) A Gmail accounts for a non-profit group? Sounds fishy. ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Sherry - 26 Oct 2004 14:47 GMT >>From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) > >A Gmail accounts for a non-profit group? Sounds fishy. >________ Lauren, what is Gmail? Thanks Sherry
Barb - 26 Oct 2004 15:47 GMT Well, North Shore Animal League is .org. so your point is well taken.
-- Barb Of course I don't look busy, I did it right the first time.
PawsForThought - 26 Oct 2004 16:57 GMT >From: sriddles@aol.comkitty (Sherry )
>>>From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) >> >>A Gmail accounts for a non-profit group? Sounds fishy. >>________ > >Lauren, what is Gmail? Hi Sherry, GMail is a free account at Google, and pretty untraceable. I don't know, it just seems weird to me that a rescue facility would be using this type of account, but who knows.
Lauren ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Sherry - 26 Oct 2004 20:52 GMT >Hi Sherry, >GMail is a free account at Google, and pretty untraceable. I don't know, it >just seems weird to me that a rescue facility would be using this type of >account, but who knows. > >Lauren I don't mean to be unkind, and I might be very wrong. But that whole deal just smacks of "collectors" to me. That picture of wall-to-wall cats is atrocious, and I just pray those cats aren't kept in those conditions every day. NOTHING is mentioned on the website about qualifiers to adopt a cat, or fees, nothing. That's spooky. Sherry
Sherry
The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary - 28 Oct 2004 04:07 GMT Hi Sherry and Lauren, I am the Coordinator for The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc and the gmail email you see is my personal email address and work email address and you may contact me there for any follup questions/concerns. Our shelter email is caretaker@thelastresort.us however, as the coordinator, I do a lot of the fundraising, research, and internet related things and I often use this email. I posted my original post out of desperation as we have exhausted so many other means for fundraising. We are very alarmed at the unwarranted negative responses we have received. If there were so many concerns, please email them privately instead of publicly bashing a struggling non-profit. Someone referred to not being able to find us on Petfinder-- well please look more closely before publicly stating we are not there-- we are PA 295 on the site. As for the comment "That picture of wall-to-wall cats is atrocious, and I just pray those cats aren't kept in those conditions every day."
That picture was taken in a barn which is over 2000 square feet-- ample room for our cage free, no kill sanctuary!!! In that barn are many different lofts and levels and plenty of places for the animals to roam, climb and play. The reason there are so many cats in view is because they all came down when the food was put out! I think a 2000 square foot area with many levels and room to climb is far more preferred than the crowded cage conditions many of the big name shelters use!
As for adoption, you need to speak to our president, Gina Henderson, at 717 792 3203 or email her at caretaker@thelastresort.us We have a careful application process for adoption-- as many of our animals were dumped once already for reasons such as "they peed outsite the litter box" or "It scratched my furniture" and when we do adoptions we want to make sure we are adopting that cat and finding it a home FOR LIFE!!!
Our President, Gina Henderson, will be posting to give you more information about the shelter. In the meantime, please be more positive and if you have further questions, email them privately. I am very disappointed that I posted here for help and this is what results. We were just hoping to expand on our resources for fundraising as we are thrilled to death when we even get $5 in new donations. Apparently that was a mistake on our part.
On the positive side, all this trouble for us has resulted in 1 donation from someone-- THANK YOU SO MUCH WHOEVER YOU ARE!!! We truly appreciate it! Thank you,
Nicole Newark Shelter Coordinator
> >Hi Sherry, > >GMail is a free account at Google, and pretty untraceable. I don't know, it [quoted text clipped - 11 lines] > > Sherry Gail - 28 Oct 2004 04:51 GMT Where can one send a donation? Gail
> Hi Sherry and Lauren, > I am the Coordinator for The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc and the [quoted text clipped - 70 lines] >> >> Sherry Ibai M - 28 Oct 2004 05:04 GMT >Where can one send a donation? >Gail Hi Gail,
I am a volunteer associated wiht the shelter. First of all I want to thank you for taking interest in the shelter.
Donations can be conveniently made online with a credit or debit card on the website www.thelastresort.us
Donations can also be sent to: The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc. P.O. Box 194 York New Salem, PA 17371
For more information you can email us at caretaker@thelastresort.us or you can call Gina Henderson at 717 792 3203
Gail - 28 Oct 2004 05:12 GMT It will be sent in the mail tomorrow. Gail
>>Where can one send a donation? >>Gail [quoted text clipped - 15 lines] > For more information you can email us at caretaker@thelastresort.us > or you can call Gina Henderson at 717 792 3203 PawsForThought - 28 Oct 2004 13:57 GMT >From: Ibai M ibmNOTTHISst1@Pitt.collegeaddy
>>Where can one send a donation? >>Gail [quoted text clipped - 12 lines] > York New Salem, PA > 17371 Do you have a street address you can give us? ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Sherry - 28 Oct 2004 05:00 GMT We are very alarmed at the unwarranted negative responses we have
>received. If there were so many concerns, please email them privately >instead of publicly bashing a struggling non-profit. I appreciate and understand the needs of a struggling shelter. I am affiliated with a shelter, as are most of the posters here. However, this is a newsgroup for the purpose of discussion, not for soliciting donations. Try to imagine what it would be like if every one of us used it for a forum for fundraising purposes. However, remember it is also a public forum, and any comments "thrown out", so to speak, are subject to public opinion. I did not see any "bashing"...what I read were opinions based on the information that was posted.
Someone referred
>to not being able to find us on Petfinder-- well please look more >closely before publicly stating we are not there-- we are PA 295 on >the site. This is the link that was provided: http://www.petfinder.org/shelters/PA295.html It took me to a page with only your address, phone number. When I clicked on adoptable pets, none came up. When I clicked on "Happy Tails", no further information was available. I'd love to see your animals. Then I did a search for "York New Salem, PA". Your shelter didn't turn up there, either. How do I access them on Petfinders?
>As for the comment "That picture of wall-to-wall cats is atrocious, >and I just pray those cats aren't kept in those conditions every day." [quoted text clipped - 7 lines] >preferred than the crowded cage conditions many of the big name >shelters use! I'm very glad to hear that. But perhaps now you have the perspective of someone who looks at your website without having visited your shelter.
>As for adoption, you need to speak to our president, Gina Henderson, >at 717 792 3203 or email her at caretaker@thelastresort.us [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >adoptions we want to make sure we are adopting that cat and finding it >a home FOR LIFE!!! Still, though, surely you make every attempt to home those cats. I simply don't understand why your adoption fees seem to be secretive, or at least not even addressed in any of your website info.
Sherry
PawsForThought - 28 Oct 2004 14:07 GMT >From: sriddles@aol.comkitty (Sherry )
>We are very alarmed at the unwarranted negative responses we have >>received. If there were so many concerns, please email them privately [quoted text clipped - 52 lines] >understand why your adoption fees seem to be secretive, or at least not even >addressed in any of your website info. I find them VERY suspect. I went to the petfinders page and you're right, there are no animals or anything. Very strange indeed! ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
PawsForThought - 28 Oct 2004 13:26 GMT >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary)
>Hi Sherry and Lauren, >I am the Coordinator for The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc and the [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] >received. If there were so many concerns, please email them privately >instead of publicly bashing a struggling non-profit. Nicole, In my experience, people who post on the internet to total strangers asking for money are very suspect. No one was bashing you or your so-called facility here. We are merely trying to determine whether or not you are a legitimate organization, or just another internet scam. There are many cat lovers here, and we don't want to see anyone taken advantage of by giving money to something that does not exist. It happens every day. In fact, where I work we are representing someone who was recently taken advantage of through an internet scam. So it's very hard to know who to trust these days. As has been stated before, anyone can compile a website and create a non-profit.
Personally, I prefer to donate money to my local rescue facility where I know them to be a legitimate organization and where the animals are getting good care.
If you are indeed a legitimate organization, have you looked into other methods to raise money, perhaps a raffle, or something? Asking for money on the internet, IMO, is not really the way to go.
Lauren ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Mary - 28 Oct 2004 15:40 GMT > >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) > [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > Nicole, > In my experience, people who post on the internet to total strangers asking for money are very suspect.
I never contribute to anything this way, just as a general rule. There are better ways to raise funds, and far too many scam artists out there. Where are the local cat people who ought to be supporting this shelter? And Sherry raises some good points. There is not even enough information online to warrant solicitation of funds online. "Nicole" should know better.
Jessica - 29 Oct 2004 04:24 GMT Hello Everyone...
I suggest before you go on bashing this organization you take some time to educate yourselves regarding all the work they have put in to give these animals a wonderful place to live for now or forever. I fell upon this organization when I was trying to facilitate a rescue of two cats which were living in deplorable conditions. Being a shelter worker for 4+ years as well as a Veterinary Asst. I have seen alot,and I was sure to take the time to see the facility and speak to them before passing the cats on to them. Their facility was a huge barn with heating, furniture, toys, windows, and lots of love. Their cats and rabbits are not only kept clean and given tons of love, their rabbits are let out to play in huge dog runs with cardboard tunnels and baby pools full of bedding as well as volunteers who gave these animals much love.Many owners can't even claim that. I have stopped by and dropped off donations of food and toys several times, each time the facility was clean and everyone was happy. You have NO right to bash them and all of their hard work. You should all be ashamed of yourselves for such postings. Oh and as far as the comment that someone made about the picture of all the cats in a room- well if you consider a huge barn a room then I guess you are right. There is no overcrowding and I would never consider this a case of a collector. But I guess with you never even being there and only ever seeing a picture you would know better. Oh and by the way, how many cats did you all say you have?
> > >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) > [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > raises some good points. There is not even enough information online to > warrant solicitation of funds online. "Nicole" should know better. Sherry - 29 Oct 2004 05:31 GMT > I suggest before you go on bashing this organization you take >some time to educate yourselves regarding all the work they have put >in to give these animals a wonderful place to live for now or forever. Fair enough. So educate us. Again, where could minutes of the last Board of Director's meeting be available to read? Where is the public information regarding your 501c3 status? What is your typical outlay each month for veterinary expenses for the 150 resident cats? How much do you receive in adoption fees, per animal? You can't expect people to blindly give you money on your word. We're hundreds of miles away. A little information helps.
(snipped)
Oh and as far as the comment that
>someone made about the picture of all the cats in a room- well if you >consider a huge barn a room then I guess you are right. Get real. That photograph looked like a hundred cats milling around in a dark cave and you know it. It made the same impression on several people. Are we supposed to be psychic? We can only judge by what you *tell* and show us.
There is no
>overcrowding and I would never consider this a case of a collector. >But I guess with you never even being there and only ever seeing a >picture you would know better. Seeing that picture, and only that picture, we were expected to think those cats lived in a feline utopia? How do you figure that?
Oh and by the way, how many cats did
>you all say you have? I have four. But really I can't see that's any of your business, since I'm not asking you for money. In fact, I don't see the purpose for your entire post at all. Are your whole organization conflict junkies or something?
Sherry
Jessica - 30 Oct 2004 02:17 GMT There seems to be a misunderstanding. You are all assuming that I am a part of this organization, which I am not. I happened upon this rescue while trying to help relocate some cats in desperate need of help. I can not answer your questions regarding funding, adoptions, or minutes. All I can say is that I have been to the facility several times to donate supplies and that the animals are well taken care of. The picture on the web is not how it is, it is not dark, and they have plenty of room. As far as their location- I know that they try to keep that quiet so as to not have people dumping animals there. I don't think there is anything wrong with that. I am sorry if my previous email came across as being rude but I was reacting to what I was reading from all of you- such negativity- I think we all need to focus on what is important- the animals.
> > I suggest before you go on bashing this organization you take > >some time to educate yourselves regarding all the work they have put [quoted text clipped - 34 lines] > > Sherry PawsForThought - 29 Oct 2004 13:07 GMT >From: dogmom@p-a-w-s.com (Jessica) Hello Jessica and welcome. I don't recall seeing you post here before.
>There is no >overcrowding and I would never consider this a case of a collector. >But I guess with you never even being there and only ever seeing a >picture you would know better. Well, I guess none of us will see this place unless your president Gina provides us with an actual street address.
>Oh and by the way, how many cats did >you all say you have? Well, if since you are aking "you all", I assume you mean us as a group. I would say more than can be counted ;)
Lauren ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Ibai M - 29 Oct 2004 14:17 GMT The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary is located at 1149 Stewart Street York, Pa 17404
>>From: dogmom@p-a-w-s.com (Jessica) > [quoted text clipped - 20 lines] >http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html >Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm PawsForThought - 29 Oct 2004 15:58 GMT >From: Ibai M ibmNOTTHISst1@Pitt.collegeaddy
>The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary is located at 1149 Stewart Street >York, Pa 17404 Thank you. Maybe there are some posters who are nearby and might want to visit. ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Sunflower - 26 Oct 2004 16:59 GMT > >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) > > A Gmail accounts for a non-profit group? Sounds fishy. Our Humane Society Yahoo freemail because it's free. ;~) You don't have to pay to register a domain name. And we basically use Petfinder as our website, because it's fairly easy for the non techies to maintain, and again, it's free. We work with lots of small rescues that do the same. One of the gauges of whether a rescue is "legit" is whether or not they're registered with Petfinder. You have to have on file your non profit status and a couple of other things to get a spot there.
FWIW, I could find no listing of The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary on Petfinder. Either this rescue isn't what it says it is, or it's not committed to using all available resources in order to find these animals homes. There is no information about adoption on their website or where the pets can be seen. A "collector" in other words. According to their website, it's not been a 501 c3 organization long enough to get to the 5 year review point. Almost anyone can form a non profit. But, it takes a LOT of work to maintain that status past that 5 year mark. I very well know the costs associated with sheltering abandoned animals, but I really don't see any costs beyond basic housing that the rescue is assuming here. They require a fee, and that that the animals already be spayed or neutered and up to date on shots. What's left to spend money on? Food? You can get that free from local groceries and chain stores.
PawsForThought - 26 Oct 2004 20:45 GMT >From: "Sunflower" sunflwrNOSPAM@midsouth.rr.com
>> >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) >> [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] >on shots. What's left to spend money on? Food? You can get that free from >local groceries and chain stores. Very interesting. Thanks for the reply, Sunflower. I guess the post itself is what threw me. I don't see too many shelters posting in newsgroups asking for money. It just seems suspect. As you say, anyone can form a non-profit. Or, anyone can create a website.
Lauren ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
Jessica - 09 Nov 2004 03:08 GMT I just happened to check back to see what was going to re: Last Resort. I found out about them through Petfinder so I found it odd that you are saying they aren't on Petfinders. I decided to go ahead and check, thinking maybe you were all right(maybe they are off since I found them)......You aren't- they are second from the bottom of the shelter/ rescue list. So I will say this again- educate, research, do what you have to before you make false accusations.
> > >From: nicolenewark@gmail.com (The Last Resort Animal Sanctuary) > > [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > on shots. What's left to spend money on? Food? You can get that free from > local groceries and chain stores. Cathy Friedmann - 09 Nov 2004 02:58 GMT They weren't on there when this was posted before - I'd checked. The page came up empty of any animals.
Cathy
> I just happened to check back to see what was going to re: Last > Resort. I found out about them through Petfinder so I found it odd [quoted text clipped - 29 lines] > > on shots. What's left to spend money on? Food? You can get that free from > > local groceries and chain stores. KellyH - 09 Nov 2004 03:28 GMT > They weren't on there when this was posted before - I'd checked. The page > came up empty of any animals. > > Cathy They actually have some cats listed, one even has a picture! The website is a bit improved, with instructions on how to adopt, adoption fees, and some pictures of available cats. Makes me feel a little better about the place.
 Signature -Kelly kelly at farringtons dot net www.kelltek.com Check out www.snittens.com
Sherry - 09 Nov 2004 03:37 GMT >So I will say this again- educate, research, do >what you have to before you make false accusations. That thread is weeks old, and they have not only changed their Petfinders status, but also changed their website since then. Had you checked when the thread was current, you would not have found them on Petfinders. Sherry
kaeli - 09 Nov 2004 14:34 GMT > I just happened to check back to see what was going to re: Last > Resort. I found out about them through Petfinder so I found it odd [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > shelter/ rescue list. So I will say this again- educate, research, do > what you have to before you make false accusations. Um, you're a little late here. After the whole debacle, they fixed up their stuff.
Which is awesome, because hopefully more kitties will get adopted.
I'll say this again - responding to old threads and assuming everything is the same as it was when the thread was posted is an inaccurate assumption at best. You all know what a.s*u*me does, right? ;)
 Signature -- ~kaeli~ To steal ideas from one person is plagiarism; to steal from many is research. http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace
hamandcheese@betweentheknees.com - 09 Nov 2004 17:27 GMT > You all know what a.s*u*me does, right? ;) Somehow I don't think that is the metaphor you are looking for unless you want to be assed :-)
-mhd
kaeli - 09 Nov 2004 19:42 GMT > > You all know what a.s*u*me does, right? ;) > > Somehow I don't think that is the metaphor you are looking for unless > you want to be assed :-) That's a popular saying around here - 'assume' makes an 'a.s' of 'u' and 'me'.
So, yeah, it was what I was looking for. ;)
 Signature -- ~kaeli~ Does the name Pavlov ring a bell? http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace
Ibai M - 28 Oct 2004 02:49 GMT I have been involved with the last resort animal shelter for some time now. I thought I would post a follow up with a few more links that may help show that the shelter is real and it has been around for quite some time:
http://www.petfinder.org/shelters/PA295.html
http://www.whois.net/whois.cgi2?d=thelastresort.us
http://groups.google.com/groups?q=thelastresort.us&hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&c2coff=1&s afe=off&sa=N&tab=wg
hope it helps,
ibai
Sherry - 28 Oct 2004 03:27 GMT >I have been involved with the last resort animal shelter for some time >now. I thought I would post a follow up with a few more links that [quoted text clipped - 10 lines] > >ibai Thanks for taking time to post the links, but I couldn't find the information I was curious about. The Petfinder link shows zero adoptable animals and zero information save your PO Box and phone number. The second link was just a "who is" for your domain...no real info. there either. The third is just someone's google history with, again, zero information about your shelter. The question that I had was, what is your criteria for adopting animals, fees, etc.? Why do you require a $50 fee PLUS proof of spay/neuter, proof of FeLeuk testing? It sounds like your shelter only takes animals that are ready to adopt back out immediately, but there is no information about adoption fees, etc. on the website. Also, is your cat room that crowded or was that a temporary situation when the photo was taken? Why aren't you taking advantage of Petfinders, and list some animals there? Sherry
Ibai M - 28 Oct 2004 04:18 GMT Sherry,
I will try to answer all of your questions. We spend so much time tending to our primary needs that we don't have too much time left for anything else. We are currently working on a new adoption page. The reason why we have such a strict adoption policy is because we don't get a lot of interest in adoptions and the ones we get are from people who are rejected at other shelters. In fact, we get in more cats than we are able to adopt out. As for the $50 fee-- we give a committment to finding lifelong care for animals... adoption doesn't happen often... we wish more would adopt but in NO-KILL shelters it is simple math-- many more people surrender than adopt. We require proof of leuk/spay, neuter, etc because we use a cage free sheltering system. This is for the health of the animals, if you go in one of better known operations such as the SPCA you will see that they have 4-5 cats in a cage, wall to wall. As for the pictures of the cat room...they were taken in a multiple level-2000 square feet barn with plenty of room for the cats to play climb, etc I hope I addressed all of your questions, if you have any more questions please don't hesitate to ask, either here or calling the shelter on the contact number listed in the the whois information for our domain: 717 792 3203 thank you,
ibai
kaeli - 28 Oct 2004 14:23 GMT > We require proof of leuk/spay, neuter, etc because we use a cage free > sheltering system. A couple shelters in my area are also cage free. They have a vet that does those tests and neuters any intact cats that come in. All incoming cats are quarantined until they pass all tests - THEN they are allowed to be with the rest of the cats.
 Signature -- ~kaeli~ A hangover is the wrath of grapes. http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace
KellyH - 28 Oct 2004 15:07 GMT > As for the $50 fee-- we give a committment to finding lifelong care > for animals... adoption doesn't happen often... we wish more would > adopt but in NO-KILL shelters it is simple math-- many more people > surrender than adopt. Then you all need to take a hard look at what you are doing if adoption is such a rare event. I'm all for careful screening, but you need to effectively communicate HOW a person is supposed to adopt an animal from you. Do they fill out an application? What is the fee? What animals are available for adoption?
No-kill shelters have to walk a fine line or they become a sanctuary. I'm not against sanctuaries, but if a cat is highly adoptable, there is no reason for it to live in a sanctuary instead of a forever home.
Also, by requiring FeLV/FIV testing, up-to-date on shots, and spay/neuter AND a $50 fee, what are you doing about strays? Sounds like you are only taking owner turn-ins who are up-to-date on vetting and have $50 to donate. Those cats should be easy to adopt out. The shelter I am with is also a small, all-volunteer organization that relies primarily on donations. Our main focus is strays. We do take in owner turn-ins on a priority basis. If possible, we try to work with the owners so that they can find some way of keeping their cat. If all else fails, we will take the cat, and we suggest that they have it recently vetted and have a donation, but we don't require it.
As for Petfinder, we have our dogs on Petfinder, as we don't have that many dogs. We have one cat listed on Petfinder as our "SpokesCat" which links to our own website's cat page.
 Signature -Kelly kelly at farringtons dot net www.kelltek.com Check out www.snittens.com
Sunflower - 28 Oct 2004 15:25 GMT > Sherry, > [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > people who are rejected at other shelters. In fact, we get in more > cats than we are able to adopt out. Ok, what are your adoption statistics? I'd be more than happy to tell you our shelter's. 80% of the animals that come through the door find homes, with 10% being euthanized for health reasons, and 10% for overcrowding. And we work damn hard to keep that rehomed figure that high.
How many cats do you take in and how many go out? We took in 282 cats last year and 450 dogs. 80% of them found homes.
How many cats are you currently housing? What is your adoption criteria? What is your adoption fee? How long does it take for a typical adoption to occur? What methods do you utilize to be sure that you find homes for these animals? None are listed on Petfinder and you don't have any information as to how to view the pets at all. Do you do remote location adoptions like at PetSmart?
Just how can one adopt an animal when there is no information about any of the animals or adoption proceedures?
> As for the $50 fee-- we give a committment to finding lifelong care > for animals... adoption doesn't happen often... we wish more would > adopt but in NO-KILL shelters it is simple math-- many more people > surrender than adopt. And many "no kill" shelters are covers for collectors who take in far more animals than they can adequately provide care for, even with donations from the community. If "adoption doesn't happen often", then you have to ask yourself if you are in it for the animals benefit or not. Because it's not beneficial for any animal to *live* in a shelter situation. All animals deserve to own their own people to provide them with individual loving attention. And the fact that your group isn't very successful at doing this is a huge red flag.
Where can one go to see a copy of the minutes of the meetings of your organization as well as the required financial report information? That is required to be public information for any 501 c3 and ours is available at our shelter. Where is yours? A PO box isn't an acceptible location. Care to tell us how much money in fees were taken in last year? How about donations? Donations in kind? What were the outgoing expenses? What was the largest slice of that pie? I can tell you that veterinary expenses were approximately 85% of our approximately $34K and our primary income was from adoption fees and one or two large donations. Care to be that candid about your group in public where it counts?
> We require proof of leuk/spay, neuter, etc because we use a cage free > sheltering system. This is for the health of the animals, if you go in [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > level-2000 square feet barn with plenty of room for the cats to play > climb, etc HSUS guidelines on feline housing will tell you exactly how much square footage a cat should be allotted. (Are you aware of what that figure is?) Any organization that does not abide by that is inhumane in it's housing policies. On that, we agree. Our shelter utilizes a cattery for our longer term residents as well. *We* spay and neuter and vaccinate the animals before they're allowed to run in there though. Every animal that comes through our doors leaves up to date on shots and spayed or neutered. These are just the costs of running a rescue. If you don't take any animals in that need these services, then you're not really running a rescue. And if you can't afford to provide these services to the animals that need them, perhaps you'd best reassess whether or not your group has the financial savvy to run a real rescue group. It's just like finding an animal a responsible home. It takes more than love. People who "love animals" and take in large number of them but don't provide them with any medical care from their own pocket or personal attention because of the large number of animals are COLLECTORS. And the really do believe that they are "saving animals". But the reality check is, they're actually creating more animal suffering, not less.
> I hope I addressed all of your questions, if you have any more > questions please don't hesitate to ask, either here or calling the [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > > ibai Ibai M - 29 Oct 2004 14:37 GMT I asked Gina Henderson abot our statistics so I can give you an accurate answer. However, I can tell you now that we do not take in more animals than we can take care of. You euthanized over 70 animals last year because you did not have space for them? That is a horrible thing to do, if you can not care for them then do not take them in, they might still have a chance to find another place, but not after you euthanize them! We are perfectly aware of HSUS guidelines, our shelter meets and exceeds them. You keep calling us collectors, when it could not be further from the truth, yet YOU took over 70 animals more than you could care of last year for the solely reason to try to profit from them and when you realized you couldn't you killed them.
>> Sherry, >> [quoted text clipped - 83 lines] >> >> ibai Sherry - 29 Oct 2004 15:05 GMT >You keep calling us collectors, when it could not be further from the >truth, yet YOU took over 70 animals more than you could care of last >year for the solely reason to try to profit from them and when you >realized you couldn't you killed them. What a line of utter BS. You just KEEP digging yourself in deeper and making Last Resort sound worse. 1. A stray cat comes to Shelter A (was Sunflower OP you're replying to?) A stray cat is vetted, fed, cared for, loved and given a *chance for adoption*, and saved from suffering death by starvation or disease or injury on the streets. 1. A cat comes to Last Resort. Woops! Strays cats don't come with $50, and vet-check-spay certificates. So, it's "Bye bye Kitty" -- you can't check in. Cat probably ends up taken to a kill facility, or worse, dumped. It would seem that your mission is to re-locate the healthy cats people relinquish, while continuing to feed and care for the 150 you don't intend to try to adopt out. A humane society's mission is to allieve suffering first.
I find it HIGHLY ironic that you're accusing her shelter of "trying to profit" -- YOUR SHELTER is the one that requires a $50 bill with each intake.
Sherry
PawsForThought - 29 Oct 2004 15:35 GMT >From: sriddles@aol.comkitty (Sherry )
>>You keep calling us collectors, when it could not be further from the >>truth, yet YOU took over 70 animals more than you could care of last [quoted text clipped - 21 lines] > >Sherry I think you summed them up perfectly, Sherry. I feel sorry for all the animals that are turned away from them because they can't get their $50. This is certainly a shelter I would not want to support. ________ See my cats: http://community.webshots.com/album/56955940rWhxAe Raw Diet Info: http://www.holisticat.com/drjletter.html http://www.geocities.com/rawfeeders/ForCatsOnly.html Declawing Info: http://www.wholecatjournal.com/articles/claws.htm
KellyH - 29 Oct 2004 15:13 GMT >I asked Gina Henderson abot our statistics so I can give you an > accurate answer. However, I can tell you now that we do not take in [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > they might still have a chance to find another place, but not after > you euthanize them! What do you think is happening to all the animals you don't take in? Do you think after someone tries to place and animal with you, and is told that you are full, they just decide to keep it? An Open Admission shelter HAS to take every single animal that comes to its door. It is much more humane than turning the animal away and leaving it to get hit by a car or whatever else might happen. I do not have the stomach to volunteer at an Open Admission shelter, but I applaud those that do. I'm not saying they are all great, but we have to get off this myth that no-kill shelters are a utopian setting.
Again, for the third time, I ask, why are you taking in highly adoptable animals and making them live in a sanctuary? Why not give them a chance to have a forever home? Or, if you are going to go through all the trouble and expense of having a sanctuary, why not do it for those that really need it, like cats with FeLV or FIV? You could still look for homes for them, but these cats take much longer to find homes and often are put down or turned away at most shelters.
> We are perfectly aware of HSUS guidelines, our shelter meets and > exceeds them. > You keep calling us collectors, when it could not be further from the > truth, yet YOU took over 70 animals more than you could care of last > year for the solely reason to try to profit from them and when you > realized you couldn't you killed them. BS! A shelter is trying to profit from the animals it takes in?? Give me a break! YOU only take in animals that come with a convenient $50. The shelter I'm with takes in cats and dogs without a donation, spays/neuters them, gives them their first round of FVRCP and Rabies vaccines, and any other necessary vetting. And, then we try to find them a home! What are you doing? Taking in perfectly adoptable animals and letting them sit, never to have a true home of their own. Yes, our shelter has cages, but the cats are not in the shelter for very long. For those more long-term residents that are having difficulty getting adopted, we find other places for them, like foster homes or the office. I keep hearing that your barn is 2000 sq ft. But, then I saw in another post that you have 150 cats. 2000 sq ft might sound huge, but it's really only the size of an average house. If you heard on the news that a house had 150 cats in it, wouldn't that turn your stomach?
 Signature -Kelly kelly at farringtons dot net www.kelltek.com Check out www.snittens.com
Mary - 29 Oct 2004 16:54 GMT > I keep hearing that your barn is 2000 sq ft. But, then I saw in another post that you have 150 cats. 2000 sq ft might sound huge, but it's really only the size of an average house. If you heard on the news that a house
> had 150 cats in it, wouldn't that turn your stomach? Another thing that keeps occuring to me: they must only adopt cats that are good with other cats. At the shelter where I got my Cheeks some cats are in cages because they don't get along with the others. They are let out into a general play room regularly where the volunteers play with them, but they do better in cages. Having over 100 cats all thrown together doesn't sound quite safe to me. Or healthy. Do they have a sick room, or do they all have to get a cold if one of them does. Is there vet care?
Sherry - 29 Oct 2004 21:58 GMT >Another thing that keeps occuring to me: they must only adopt cats that are >good with other cats. At the shelter where I got my Cheeks some cats are in [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] >quite safe to me. Or healthy. Do they have a sick room, or do they all have >to get a cold if one of them does. Is there vet care? And, are they all vaccinated, and have they been feleuk tested? Disease would run rampant if they aren't.
Sherry
Sunflower - 29 Oct 2004 15:37 GMT >I asked Gina Henderson abot our statistics so I can give you an > accurate answer. However, I can tell you now that we do not take in [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > year for the solely reason to try to profit from them and when you > realized you couldn't you killed them. I do not work at a closed admissions facility that turns animals away when they don't come with a fee or they're full. I work out of a city's ANimal Control facility, which pays for two employees to go out and pick up new animals but not for their care, and let me tell you, it's a damn sight harder to do this than is collecting animals here and there that come with money. We do accept owner surrenders with a $25 fee, but if the person refuses to pay the fee, and more than half do, we still take the animal. And, the money doesn't even go to us. It goes to the City. We take every single animal that is brought to us, whether owner surrender, stray, or found. How many do you turn away? What do you think happens to them? They end up at places like mine---if they're lucky and aren't just dumped on the side of the road.
We operate a Trap, Test, Neuter, and Release program for a feral colony in our Old Town section and work with other feral colony managers to provide food and services to help them. We sponsor a low cost spay/neuter vet to make low cost surguries available to the community. We do an annual $5 rabies clinic for the public. We travel to schools to do humane education for the next generation. We're liasoning with the HSUS to sponsor the Rural Area Veterinary Service to come in and spay/neuter 100 animals *for free* to a medically underserved area. We work with rescues all across the USA to pull animals from our shelter into their programs so that just because we're overcrowded we don't have to euthanize. And when we do have to euthanize, we hold them and love them like they are are own, and we cry and grieve for them. But, we at least gave them a chance by accepting them into our shelter, which you won't do unless the animal comes with that $50 fee. We have zero paid employees, and every single cent goes to the care of the animals. It's laughable to even say the word "profit".
At first I was trying to give you the benefit of the doubt because you were obviously clueless about animal rescue in general and Usenet specifically. But you're now trying to be deliberately offensive, which is the mark of a troll. Y'all are the ones with your hands out. People have the right to request information about your group. Read your non profit charter. If you refuse to provide the information, that charter can be revoked. You've pissed me off enough now (deliberately) that I'm through trying to educate you, and now if you don't provide the information I've requested, then I'm going to file a complaint with the PA Bureau of Charitible Organizations and let you deal with them.
Great PR attempt, BTW. Contrary to the popular saying, any publicity is not good publicity and you've probably just informed a whole lot of people all across the world exactly what nasty defensive collectors your group really is composed of. There has not been one single *reasonable* response to any of the questions that anyone posed. And, guess what? You are *required by law* to answer those questions. So get off your high horse and do so, or else get your charter revoked.
f.ck you very much, and have a nice day!
Sherry - 29 Oct 2004 16:15 GMT >Great PR attempt, BTW. Contrary to the popular saying, any publicity is not >good publicity and you've probably just informed a whole lot of people all >across the world exactly what nasty defensive collectors your group really >is composed of. Exactly. What her high-horse name-calling has accomplished is creating a situation that's gotten them nothing but negative publicity. I wonder if they realize, that these threads are archived forever. From now on, anybody curious about their shelter can google "Last Resort Animal Sanctuary, Inc." on google groups, and that's going to be the impression of their shelter. Not an impression I'd want to make.
Mary - 29 Oct 2004 17:06 GMT And when we do have to euthanize,
> we hold them and love them like they are are own, and we cry and grieve for > them. Ahh, gad, this would just kill me. You are made of tougher stuff than I, and for the animals you help, I'm glad someone is.
Sharon Talbert - 29 Oct 2004 22:02 GMT I am following this debate with interest. I respect the efforts of private shelters who call themselves "no-kill," but my heart is with the public shelters who have no choice but to kill to make space as more animals pour in from irresponsible pet owners.
Sharon Talbert Friends of Campus Cats
Cathy Friedmann - 29 Oct 2004 02:04 GMT > if you go in > one of better known operations such as the SPCA you will see that > they have 4-5 cats in a cage, wall to wall. The shelter here - the Humane Society - has one adult cat/cage, unless it's a double width cage, then sometimes 2 cats. If the kittens are still young & small and from the same litter - but are weaned, then they may be together in one cage.
> As for the pictures of the cat room...they were taken in a multiple > level-2000 square feet barn with plenty of room for the cats to play > climb, etc As others have noted, it appears that the room is very crowded & possibly small. It also looks quite dark - partly because the overall image is dark, & partly because of the reflective glow of the cats' eyes. Those are the images one comes away with from visiting the site. (I saw only one picture, not pictures.) If the shelter is truly spacious, & if it's well-lit, then IMO you need a new/different picture on the web page - one that indicates the true qualities of the space.
Cathy
|
|
|