Cat Forum / Health and Behavior / June 2004
My Name is Sam - A true story about euthanasia (not pretty)
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Karen M. - 08 Jun 2004 18:02 GMT "My Name is Sam"
After I was discharged from the Navy, Jim and I moved back to Detroit to use our GI bill benefits to get some schooling. Jim was going for a degree in Electronics and I, after much debating, decided to get mine in Computer Science.
One of the classes that was a requirement was Speech. Like many people, I had no fondness for getting up in front of people for any reason, let alone to be the center of attention as I stuttered my way through some unfamiliar subject. But I couldn't get out of the requirement, and so I found myself in my last semester before graduation with Speech as one of my classes. On the first day of class our professor explained to us that he was going to leave the subject matter of our talks up to us, but he was going to provide the motivation of the speech. We would be responsible for six speeches, each with a different motivation. For instance our first speech's purpose was to inform. He advised us to pick subjects that we were interested in and knowledgeable about. I decided to center my six speeches around animals, especially dogs.
For my first speech to inform, I talked about the equestrian art of dressage. For my speech to demonstrate, I brought my German Shepherd, Bodger, to class and demonstrated obedience commands. Finally the semester was almost over and I had but one more speech to give. This speech was to take the place of a written final exam and was to count for fifty per cent of our grade. The speeches motivation was to persuade.
After agonizing over a subject matter, and keeping with my animal theme, I decided on the topic of spaying and neutering pets. My goal was to try to persuade my classmates to neuter their pets. So I started researching the topic. There was plenty of material, articles that told of the millions of dogs and cats that were euthanized every year, of supposedly beloved pets that were turned in to various animal control facilities for the lamest of reasons, or worse, dropped off far from home, bewildered and scared. Death was usually a blessing.
The final speech was looming closer, but I felt well prepared. My notes were full of facts and statistics that I felt sure would motivate even the most naive of pet owners to succumb to my plea.
A couple of days before our speeches were due, I had the bright idea of going to the local branch of the Humane Society and borrowing a puppy to use as a sort of a visual aid. I called the Humane Society and explained what I wanted. They were very happy to accommodate me. I made arrangements to pick up a puppy the day before my speech.
The day before my speech, I went to pick up the puppy. I was feeling very confident. I could quote all the statistics and numbers without ever looking at my notes. The puppy, I felt, would add the final emotional touch.
When I arrived at the Humane Society I was met by a young guy named Ron. He explained that he was the public relations person for the Humane Society. He was very excited about my speech and asked if I would like a tour of the facilities before I picked up the puppy. I enthusiastically agreed. We started out in the reception area, which was the general public's initial encounter with the Humane Society.
The lobby was full, mostly with people dropping off various animals that they no longer wanted. Ron explained to me that this branch of the Humane Society took in about fifty animals a day and adopted out only about twenty.
As we stood there I heard snatches of conversation: "I can't keep him, he digs holes in my garden." "They are such cute puppies, I know you will have no trouble finding homes for them." "She is wild, I can't control her."
I heard one of Humane Society's volunteer explain to the lady with the litter of puppies that the Society was filled with puppies and that these puppies, being black, would immediately be put to sleep.Black puppies, she explained, had little chance of being adopted. The woman who brought the puppies in just shrugged, "I can't help it," she whined. "They are getting too big. I don't have room for them." We left the reception area. Ron led me into the staging area where all the incoming animals were evaluated for adoptability. Over half never even made it to the adoption center. There were just too many. Not only were people bringing in their own animals, but strays were also dropped off. By law the Humane Society had to hold a stray for three days. If the animal was not claimed by then, it was euthanized, since there was no background information on the animal. There were already too many animals that had a known history eagerly provided by their soon to be ex-owners. As we went through the different areas, I felt more and more depressed. No amount of statistics, could take the place of seeing the reality of what this throwaway attitude did to the living, breathing animal. It was overwhelming. Finally Ron stopped in front of a closed door. "That's it," he said, "except for this."
I read the sign on the door. "Euthanasia Area." "Do you want to see one?" he asked. Before I could decline, he interjected, "You really should. You can't tell the whole story unless you experience the end." I reluctantly agreed. "Good." He said, "I already cleared it and Peggy is expecting you." He knocked firmly on the door. A middle-aged woman in a white lab coat opened it immediately. "Here's the girl I was telling you about," Ron explained. Peggy looked me over. "Well, I'll leave you here with Peggy and meet you in the reception area in about fifteen minutes. I'll have the puppy ready." With that Ron departed, leaving me standing in front of the stern-looking Peggy. Peggy motioned me in. As I walked into the room, I gave an audible gasp. The room was small and spartan. There were a couple of cages on the wall and a cabinet with syringes and vials of a clear liquid. In the middle of the room was an examining table with a rubber mat on top. There were two doors other than the one I had entered. Both were closed. One said to incinerator room, and the other had no sign, but I could hear various animals' noises coming from behind the closed door. In the back of the room, near the door that was marked incinerator were the objects that caused my distress: two wheelbarrows, filled with the bodies of dead kittens and puppies. I stared in horror. Nothing had prepared me for this. I felt my legs grow weak and my breathing become rapid and shallow. I wanted to run from that room, screaming. Peggy seemed not to notice my state of shock. She started talking about the euthanasia process, but I wasn't hearing her. I could not tear my gaze away from the wheelbarrows and those dozens of pathetic little bodies.
Finally, Peggy seemed to notice that I was not paying attention to her. "Are you listening?" she asked irritably. "I'm only going to go through this once." I tore my gaze from the back of the room and looked at her. I opened my mouth to say something, but nothing would come out, so I nodded. She told me that behind the unmarked door were the animals that were scheduled for euthanasia that day. She picked up a chart that was hanging from the wall. "One fifty-three is next," she said as she looked at the chart. "I'll go get him." She laid down the chart on the examining table and started for the unmarked door. Before she got to the door she stopped and turned around. "You aren't going to get hysterical, are you?" she asked, "Because that will only upset the animals." I shook my head. I had not said a word since I walked into that room. I still felt unsure if I would be able to without breaking down into tears. As Peggy opened the unmarked door I peered into the room beyond. It was a small room, but the walls were lined and stacked with cages. It looked like they were all occupied. Peggy opened the door of one of the lower cages and removed the occupant. From what I could see it looked like a medium-sized dog. She attached a leash and ushered the dog into the room in which I stood.
As Peggy brought the dog into the room I could see that the dog was no more than a puppy, maybe five or six months old. The pup looked to be a cross between a Lab and a German shepherd. He was mostly black, with a small amount of tan above his eyes and on his feet. He was very excited and bouncing up and down, trying to sniff everything in this new environment. Peggy lifted the pup onto the table. She had a card in her hand, which she laid on the table next to me. I read the card. It said that number one fifty-three was a mixed Shepherd, six months old. He was surrendered two days ago by a family. Reason of surrender was given as "jumps on children." At the bottom was a note that said "Name: Sam."
Peggy was quick and efficient, from lots of practice, I guessed. She lay one fifty-three down on his side and tied a rubber tourniquet around his front leg. She turned to fill the syringe from the vial of clear liquid.
All this time I was standing at the head of the table. I could see the moment that one fifty-three went from a curious puppy to a terrified puppy. He did not like being held down and he started to struggle. It was then that I finally found my voice. I bent over the struggling puppy and whispered, "Sam. Your name is Sam." At the sound of his name Sam quit struggling. He wagged his tail tentatively and his soft pink tongue darted out and licked my hand. And that is how he spent his last moment. I watched his eyes fade from hopefulness to nothingness. It was over very quickly. I had never even seen Peggy give the lethal shot. The tears could not be contained any longer. I kept my head down so as not to embarrass myself in front of the stoic Peggy. My tears fell onto the still body on the table. "Now you know," Peggy said softly. Then she turned away. "Ron will be waiting for you."
I left the room. Although it seemed like it had been hours, only fifteen minutes had gone by since Ron had left me at the door. I made my way back to the reception area. True to his word, Ron had the puppy all ready to go. After giving me some instructions about what to feed the puppy, he handed the carrying cage over to me and wished me good luck on my speech. That night I went home and spent many hours playing with the orphan puppy. I went to bed that night but I could not sleep. After a while I got up and looked at my speech notes with their numbers and statistics. Without a second thought, I tore them up and threw them away. I went back to bed. Sometime during the night I finally fell asleep.
The next morning I arrived at my Speech class with Puppy Doe. When my turn came, I held the puppy in my arms, I took a deep breath, and I told the class about the life and death of Sam. When I finished my speech I became aware that I was crying. I apologized to the class and took my seat. After class the teacher handed out a critique with our grades. I got an "A." His comments said "Very moving and persuasive."
Two days later, on the last day of class, one of my classmates came up to me. She was an older lady that I had never spoken to in class. She stopped me on our way out of the classroom. "I want you to know that I adopted the puppy you brought to class," she said.
"His name is Sam."
by Chris Benton Please Spay or Neuter your pet.
Permission to cross-post
Annie Wxill - 08 Jun 2004 18:53 GMT > "My Name is Sam" snip>
> by Chris Benton > Please Spay or Neuter your pet. Wow, that is a powerful piece. Annie
Sherry - 08 Jun 2004 19:31 GMT It isn't pretty, but it is one of the most accurate, and universal stories written. The author could be Any Man. The shelter is Everywhere. This is the reason I can't work at the shelter for more than four months at a stretch. I get depressed and hopeless and start having nightmares. I have to sit out for a couple of months and work strictly on fundraisers,newsletters and other off-site projects. It's also the reason I turn into a frothing crazywoman every time I run across the sheer ignorance as portrayed by the author re: the incomings. It's absolutely true. All of it. My heartfelt sympathy and admiration goes to the people who *can* face that situation, day after day, and not lose their determination or hope, keeping hanging in there and trying like hell to bring about even the smallest change. Sherry
RobZip - 08 Jun 2004 19:43 GMT >It's also the reason I turn into a frothing crazywoman > every time I run across the sheer ignorance as portrayed by the author re: the > incomings. It's absolutely true. Regarding the 'incomings'. I'm sure those who work the intake side hear all the lamest excuses. These people need to be made aware in the most graphic terms possible of the impact their stupidity has. How hard would it be to invoke a policy where people are selected at random to 'help' guide their hopelessly unadoptable animal through the euthanasia process? Example - "You carry it back there, observe the piles of bodies, hold it while shots are given, and place it in the wheelbarrow yourself or you will have to return another day. Our holding cages are full and we are shorthanded, so if you want it disposed of, you're going to have to help." Have language absolving shelter from responsibility for emotional trauma, etc, buried in surrender agreement. Then beat on 'em real hard about doing volunteer time or getting someone they know to volunteer. Y'all let these a.sholes off too easy..... Screw it if they run home puking... Those who do it every day will agree that there's plenty of grief to go around.
MaryL - 08 Jun 2004 20:31 GMT > >It's also the reason I turn into a frothing crazywoman > > every time I run across the sheer ignorance as portrayed by the author re: [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > invoke a policy where people are selected at random to 'help' guide their > hopelessly unadoptable animal through the euthanasia process? This "sounds" good, but I suspect that the end result would be that still more people would simply dump their cats and dogs somewhere rather than face what you just described. This means that the poor animals would suffer more painful deaths.
MaryL
Sherry - 08 Jun 2004 22:11 GMT >> Regarding the 'incomings'. I'm sure those who work the intake side hear >all [quoted text clipped - 9 lines] > >MaryL That's the absolute truth. That's why I don't work the counter, hardly ever. The first time I ever lost control of my mouth was when a mother with two grade-school-aged children brought in four kittens. I asked where the mother was. She says, she wants to keep the mother, but she really didn't want the kittens. She only wanted the kids to witness the miracle of birth. It was kitten season and we were enundated with kittens. I asked her to stick around so her kids could witness the miracle of euthanasia. I then started babbling about how many kittens were killed, just like hers. In front of the kids. That's when I quit working the counter for a while. You just have to be careful. You want to get the message to the public, but the last thing you want is for them to avoid bringing them to us, and end up dumping them to starve.
Sherry
KellyH - 08 Jun 2004 22:31 GMT > That's the absolute truth. That's why I don't work the counter, hardly ever. > The first time I ever lost control of my mouth was when a mother with two [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > last thing you want is for them to avoid bringing them to us, and end up > dumping them to starve. This is why I could never volunteer at an Open Admission shelter. I admire those who are strong enough to do it. I volunteer at a "low-kill", technically not no-kill since we do PTS FeLV and FIV, and advanced illnesses. Those are hard enough to deal with. I do the cat intakes, and I also hear all kinds of lame excuses. If we can't take a cat in right that second, then I get the "well I'm just going to dump her outside". We usually cave and figure out a way to take in the cat. It's very, very hard to keep my mouth shut sometimes. The "moving" excuse is one of the worst ones in my book, because I know they are going to get another cat when they move to their new place, and then dump that one.
 Signature -Kelly kelly at farringtons dot net Check out www.snittens.com
MadHatter - 08 Jun 2004 23:06 GMT
>> That's the absolute truth. That's why I don't work the counter, hardly >ever. [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] >ones in my book, because I know they are going to get another cat when they >move to their new place, and then dump that one. that's horrible! the only time we ever had to give our cat away, and we gave her to our friends, was when we moved from the USSR to the US. our cat simply could not travel at all. we tried to get her accustomed to traveling by taking her out in a car, but she would scream, run around, hide under the seat and defecate and vomited all over the care. she looked utterly scared. we just couldn't take her on a 12hr plane flight. she didn't go to a shelter. our friends are taking care of her. i could never part with my cat just because i was moving to another house, not even to another state! in the US there are plenty of ways to sedate a kitty for transport.
-L
Laura R. - 08 Jun 2004 23:07 GMT circa Tue, 08 Jun 2004 21:31:26 GMT, in rec.pets.cats.health+behav, KellyH (Kelly@whatever.com) said,
> This is why I could never volunteer at an Open Admission shelter. I admire > those who are strong enough to do it. I volunteer at a "low-kill", [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > ones in my book, because I know they are going to get another cat when they > move to their new place, and then dump that one. People should have to get licensed to have pets or to reproduce, IMO. We make people get licenses to drive, but we'll let anybody fsck up a kid or an animal with impunity.
Laura
 Signature Experience is the name every one gives to their mistakes. -Oscar Wilde
Sherry - 09 Jun 2004 00:41 GMT >People should have to get licensed to have pets or to reproduce, IMO. >We make people get licenses to drive, but we'll let anybody fsck up a >kid or an animal with impunity. > >Laura Yup. What's even worse is when someone actually gets nailed for abuse or neglect. We always ask the judge to hand down a decision that includes the defendant *never* be able to legally own another companion animals. Sometimes the judge won't do it. Unbelievable. Sherry
Laura R. - 09 Jun 2004 06:33 GMT circa 08 Jun 2004 23:41:40 GMT, in rec.pets.cats.health+behav, Sherry (sriddles@aol.comkitty) said,
> Yup. What's even worse is when someone actually gets nailed for abuse or > neglect. We always ask the judge to hand down a decision that includes the > defendant *never* be able to legally own another companion animals. Sometimes > the judge won't do it. Unbelievable. That's sickening.
Laura
 Signature Experience is the name every one gives to their mistakes. -Oscar Wilde
Sherry - 09 Jun 2004 00:43 GMT >If we can't take a cat in right that >second, then I get the "well I'm just going to dump her outside". We >usually cave and figure out a way to take in the cat. And they will dump it outside, too, you can bet on it. It's not unusual to find boxes of kittens or dogs tied up at the front door by people who are too stupid and uncaring to wait till the shelter opens. Last spring we found a litter of kittens in a bucket that had drowned in a rainstorm early that morning at the front door. I hate people sometimes.
Sherry
Laura R. - 09 Jun 2004 06:34 GMT circa 08 Jun 2004 23:43:56 GMT, in rec.pets.cats.health+behav, Sherry (sriddles@aol.comkitty) said,
> >If we can't take a cat in right that > >second, then I get the "well I'm just going to dump her outside". We [quoted text clipped - 5 lines] > kittens in a bucket that had drowned in a rainstorm early that morning at the > front door. I hate people sometimes. I hate 'em most of the time, especially when I read things like the above. Stupid people abound. :-(
Laura
 Signature Experience is the name every one gives to their mistakes. -Oscar Wilde
Sherry - 08 Jun 2004 22:17 GMT >Regarding the 'incomings'. I'm sure those who work the intake side hear all >the lamest excuses. Oh, man. I've heard it all. The more inventive people will just lie and tell you they "found" the animal. Then when you ask how old it is, they say "Oh, her birthday is April 16. She is four."
These people need to be made aware in the most graphic
>terms possible of the impact their stupidity has. Hey, I couldn't agree with you more. But see MaryL's post about people dumping in the country. We exist to protect and alleviate suffering in all animals. It is imperative they bring them to us so that they at the very least get a chance.
Sherry
RobZip - 08 Jun 2004 22:28 GMT > Hey, I couldn't agree with you more. But see MaryL's post about people dumping > in the country. We exist to protect and alleviate suffering in all animals. It > is imperative they bring them to us so that they at the very least get a > chance. I agree with both of you that my extremist action would probably cause people to skip the shelter rather than reform anyone's actions. Perhaps some nicely done 24 x 36 high quality photos of various euthanasia shots ?
KellyH - 09 Jun 2004 18:32 GMT > > Hey, I couldn't agree with you more. But see MaryL's post about people > dumping [quoted text clipped - 6 lines] > people to skip the shelter rather than reform anyone's actions. Perhaps some > nicely done 24 x 36 high quality photos of various euthanasia shots ? Too bad you can't say to someone who's turning in a cat for some bullshit reason, "Oh sure, we can take in your cat. Now just follow me and pick out the cat you want us to kill in order to make room for yours."
 Signature -Kelly kelly at farringtons dot net Check out www.snittens.com
Karen M. - 08 Jun 2004 23:57 GMT > It isn't pretty, but it is one of the most accurate, and universal stories > written. The author could be Any Man. The shelter is Everywhere. [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > hell to bring about even the smallest change. > Sherry I think this should be mandatory reading for *anyone* trying to dump their pet at the shelter, or who let their animals breed. Just makes me sick.
K
kaeli - 08 Jun 2004 19:34 GMT > "His name is Sam." > > by Chris Benton > Please Spay or Neuter your pet. > > Permission to cross-post Making me cry at work is not very nice.
What a powerful read.
 Signature -- ~kaeli~ You feel stuck with your debt if you can't budge it. http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace
Karen M. - 08 Jun 2004 23:56 GMT > > "His name is Sam." > > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > -- Sorry, Kaeli. I tried to warn. I felt ill after I read it, and I already pretty much knew what it was leading up to... :(
K
kaeli - 09 Jun 2004 14:29 GMT > > Making me cry at work is not very nice. > > [quoted text clipped - 4 lines] > Sorry, Kaeli. I tried to warn. I felt ill after I read it, and I > already pretty much knew what it was leading up to... :( Don't be sorry. I went and read it.
I think everyone who has or wants a pet should read it.
 Signature -- ~kaeli~ Synonym: the word you use in place of a word you can't spell. http://www.ipwebdesign.net/wildAtHeart http://www.ipwebdesign.net/kaelisSpace
Mary - 09 Jun 2004 20:17 GMT > > > Making me cry at work is not very nice. > > > [quoted text clipped - 8 lines] > > I think everyone who has or wants a pet should read it. I am such a pussy, I know, but I didn't read it. Too many things make me cry anyway. (In private only, of course.)
MaryL - 08 Jun 2004 20:32 GMT > "My Name is Sam" > > by Chris Benton > Please Spay or Neuter your pet. > > Permission to cross-post What a powerful, emotional essay. It made me cry. Literally!
MaryL
Laura R. - 08 Jun 2004 23:05 GMT circa 8 Jun 2004 10:02:07 -0700, in rec.pets.cats.health+behav, Karen M. (misskittymcgill71@yahoo.com) said,
> In the back of the room, near the door that > was marked incinerator were the objects that caused my distress: two > wheelbarrows, filled with the bodies of dead kittens and puppies. I > stared in horror. Nothing had > prepared me for this. I saw just such a thing, accidentally, just once. It was an image I'll not forget as long as I live.
This post made me cry.
Laura
 Signature Experience is the name every one gives to their mistakes. -Oscar Wilde
Cheryl - 08 Jun 2004 23:59 GMT In the fine newsgroup "rec.pets.cats.health+behav", misskittymcgill71 2004:
> "His name is Sam." No words Karen. Only tears. Passing it on with hope in my heart.
 Signature Cheryl
~*Connie*~ - 10 Jun 2004 01:06 GMT I actually took a speech class, And I did my final speach on spay neuter. I used the example of a stray I took in named Melody, and how I had to have her euthanised because she was suffering from Felv.
This was extremely powerful. What is the source?
|
|
|