Cat Forum / Health and Behavior / May 2004
Cat pigmentation and behavior
|
|
Thread rating:  |
Jack Crane - 18 May 2004 10:43 GMT On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social behavior.
"Genetics and Pigmentation Epinephrine has the same metabolic pathway as the pigment melanin, and the same precursor is needed for the synthesis of both. Genetic manipulation of coat color could then be useful for breeding in or out certain behavioral characteristics, such as fear and aggression."
A footnote says, "Todd NB: Cats and commerce, Sci Am, 237:100-107, Nov 1977."
Now, that's a very old Scientific American article. I'd like to know if there has been any more research done on this topic. In particular, has a positive correlation been found between coat color and patterns and behavior? All I have been able to find is a lot of anecdotal talk about "torties with attitude" and the even temperament of tabbies.
CPT \(former!\) Deborah - 18 May 2004 12:27 GMT > On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) > there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > behavior? All I have been able to find is a lot of anecdotal talk about > "torties with attitude" and the even temperament of tabbies. I don't think I've ever seen any research regarding the topic, but I can tell you that it cannot possibly be a coincidence that many calico cats *do* have an attitude! A disproportionate number of the most aggressive/temperamental cats that I have seen in my career are calicos or torties. Most everyone who works with animals has undoubtedly seen the same thing. So it makes perfect sense to me that there are certain behavioral tendencies that are color-linked. If you do find any research into it, please let us know!
Deborah, DVM
Annie Wxill - 18 May 2004 16:38 GMT > I don't think I've ever seen any research regarding the topic, but I can > tell you that it cannot possibly be a coincidence that many calico cats *do* > have an attitude! A disproportionate number of the most > aggressive/temperamental cats that I have seen in my career are calicos or > torties. ...> > Deborah, DVM My childhood cat was a calico, as was one of our most recent cats, who died of liver disease last summer. I've also cared for two calico cats who were between permant homes. Every one was sweet-natured and easy to handle. My childhood cat had no objections to being dressed in doll clothes and pushed around in a doll carriage. We climbed trees together and went for walks in the fields. When I was 14 (and beyond dolls) I had to leave her behind with a neighbor when my parents moved from rural Oregon to a neighborhood with high traffic in California. The neighbor said the cat was the best friend for her children, who also dressed her in doll clothes, etc. That cat, an outdoor cat, lived at least into her teens, as she died a few years after I finished college. The most recent cat, Moxie, was dumped at our house when she was about four months old. Our two older neutered males took her under their respective care. Moxie was the best behaved and gentle cat you could ever see. When she was near the end of her life, and being treated for her liver disease, she saw several vets. They all commented on what a sweet cat she was when undergoing exams and treatments. One of the other cats lived next door to us for a while. When her owner moved to a nursing home, we cared for the cat until the woman's family came from another state to get her. Although the cat, to my knowledge, had never been around a toddler, she hopped right up on the couch and snuggled up to a friend's child who had gone down for a nap. The fourth calico was a tiny kitten that someone dumped near our home in the country. She walked right up to me and when I spoke to her, she purred. Her whole face was covered with puss from an upper respiratory infection. I gave her water to rehydrate her and then fed her and took her to a vet who worked with a rescue group. The cat we have had with the most attitude is Cinder, who is solid black with yellow eyes. Annie
Nicole H - 18 May 2004 18:28 GMT Neighbors cat is a calico. She's hilarious at times. She steals things (took a watch off the bed side table and dumped it in the toilet).... if they go out of town and leave her home or put her in a kennel, she will let them know how angry she is. She will poop right at their feet, or on the bed. She definitely has an attitude. Nicole
> > On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) > > there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > > Deborah, DVM Spot - 20 May 2004 02:44 GMT LOL......I'll back her up on this one 100%. I had a tort who I swear to god had multiple personalities. She could go from sweet lovable to 110% bitch cat from hell in seconds flat. My mother has the another tort who is the Aunt to the one I described above and she's not any different.
I have never done anything to her other than take her to the vets for my mom and she hates me with a passion. All I have to do is walk in the house and she'll hiss & run. Then the next time she'll sit completely still and let me pet her and she'll purr like crazy.
The calico I have now isn't quite so moody with me but she is a devious and sneaks up on my other two and instigates them. It's no long before you know it and they are brawling. I keep a water bottle in all the obvious places just for the occasions when I yell at them and they don't listen and break it up.
Celeste
> > On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) > > there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social [quoted text clipped - 25 lines] > > Deborah, DVM Becky Smith - 21 May 2004 00:09 GMT To defend the tort (although I believe cats with orange on them do tend to have lots of attitude), I have several feral kittens I have tried to tame and have only been successful with one of them - she is a sweet, not-the-least-bit-aggressive tortie.
> LOL......I'll back her up on this one 100%. I had a tort who I swear to god > had multiple personalities. She could go from sweet lovable to 110% bitch [quoted text clipped - 47 lines] > > > > Deborah, DVM Becky Smith - 21 May 2004 00:12 GMT Are torties predominantly female like calicos? Aren't females more likely to have attitude?
Becky
> To defend the tort (although I believe cats with orange on them do tend to > have lots of attitude), I have several feral kittens I have tried to tame [quoted text clipped - 62 lines] > > > > > > Deborah, DVM kworley - 21 May 2004 01:32 GMT > Are torties predominantly female like calicos? Aren't females more likely > to have attitude? A single gene is responsible for orange and black. The gene that controls for the orange color and the varient that creates "not orange" (IOW- black) is found on the "X" chromosome. Females have two Xs, so females can have orange and black. A male has only one X, so can have either orange OR black, but not both (unless he has two X chromosomes... XXy males do occur, but are sterile). Any color pattern that includes orange and black will be a female pattern. White and other color genes (such as the "dilute" gene that makes the black appear grey and the orange appear kind of peachy) are separate and not found on the sex chromosomes, so all cats can have two copies.
Something that I just found out is that the "Siamese" gene (technically the "color point" gene) is a varient of the albino gene, but rather than eliminating color all over the body, it only does so in areas of the body that are warm. This is why Siamese and other color point cats have dark limbs, tails, ears and faces (that's where the hair is short and the skin temperture is lower), and also why they darken in the winter.
There, more than you probably wanted to know about cat genetics....
Katrina (not getting into the issue of "attitude") --
DMW - 21 May 2004 05:13 GMT Yes, all but a few genetically quirky calicos are females. I can't say that I've noticed among other colours/breeds of cats that there's much of a lean towards one sex or another being more hostile than the other.
I too have witnessed the attitude of calicos/torties (torties always seem dependably a bit worse than the calicos amongst the ones I've seen). They seem to fit into 3 camps: 1) Angels all the time; 2) Devils all the time; 3) Those that flip between Angel and Devil with apparently NO warning whatsoever. Those in camp #3 are the ones I dread the most, especially if the owner doesn't warn anyone that they bite/scratch until they've already bitten/scratched (then proceed to pull up their sleeve and show off what Fluffy did to their arm as they tried to get her into the carrier that day).
DMW
> Are torties predominantly female like calicos? Aren't females more likely > to have attitude? [quoted text clipped - 80 lines] > > > > > > > > Deborah, DVM Annie Wxill - 21 May 2004 23:40 GMT ...> I too have witnessed the attitude of calicos/torties (torties always
> seem dependably a bit worse than the calicos amongst the ones I've > seen). They seem to fit into 3 camps: 1) Angels all the time; 2) Devils > all the time; 3) Those that flip between Angel and Devil with apparently > NO warning whatsoever. ...> DMW I don't see how this is limited to one color pattern. It seems to me that you could be describing behaviors of cats in general, regardless of color pattern. Annie
minerva nine - 18 May 2004 18:04 GMT > On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) > there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social [quoted text clipped - 14 lines] > behavior? All I have been able to find is a lot of anecdotal talk about > "torties with attitude" and the even temperament of tabbies. It's not really clear what the link IS between epinephrine and melanin -- does the study mean that cats with more melanin have more ephinephrine? In that case, one would have to conclude that all-black cats (assuming their skin is also black, which it isn't always) have more ephinephrine than all-white cats, true? I guess torties would fall in the category of having a lot of pigment, as they tend to be mostly black/brown with some orange mixed in. However, a lot of calicos have a lot of white, so they wouldn't be expected to follow the same pattern. I would think tabbies would have a lot of pigment (again, without actually shaving my cats, I can't say for sure, and I'm not going there), yet I have two brown tabbies with significantly different personalities. It's an interesting scientific fact, though. I wonder if it carries over to humans? Oy, I can hear the political fallout already.... M9
buglady - 18 May 2004 22:51 GMT It's an interesting scientific fact,
> though. I wonder if it carries over to humans? Oy, I can hear the > political fallout already.... M9 ........Hmmmmm, the old saw about redheads with a temper could be true, huh?
buglady take out the dog before replying
Nicole H - 19 May 2004 08:08 GMT My all black cat has white skin
> > On p. 147 of _Feline Behavior: A Guide for Veterinarians_ (2nd ed., 2003) > > there is a provocative, small section in the chapter on feline social [quoted text clipped - 28 lines] > though. I wonder if it carries over to humans? Oy, I can hear the > political fallout already.... M9 Natalie Rigertas - 21 May 2004 11:07 GMT In alt.med.veterinary minerva nine <minervanine@yahoo.com> wrote:
> mixed in. However, a lot of calicos have a lot of white, so they wouldn't > be expected to follow the same pattern. I would think tabbies would have a [quoted text clipped - 3 lines] > though. I wonder if it carries over to humans? Oy, I can hear the > political fallout already.... M9 Don't forget torties with white! I wonder how that works to "balance out personality"
natalie
 Signature The turtle lives twixt plated decks Which practically conceal its sex. I think it clever of the turtle In such a fix to be so fertile. ---Ogden Nash
Natalie Rigertas - 21 May 2004 11:04 GMT In alt.med.veterinary Jack Crane <jdcrane7@yahoo.com> wrote:
> Now, that's a very old Scientific American article. I'd like to know if > there has been any more research done on this topic. In particular, has a > positive correlation been found between coat color and patterns and > behavior? All I have been able to find is a lot of anecdotal talk about > "torties with attitude" and the even temperament of tabbies. Then, how would you explain my torbie? She's a dilute tortoiseshell with *heavy* tabby markings (the tabby markings are not just on teh various spots, but she's tabby marked like a solid red tabby would be). But both she and her sister are definitely tortoiseshells.
natalie
 Signature The turtle lives twixt plated decks Which practically conceal its sex. I think it clever of the turtle In such a fix to be so fertile. ---Ogden Nash
buglady - 21 May 2004 20:00 GMT I'd like to know if
> there has been any more research done on this topic. In particular, has a > positive correlation been found between coat color and patterns and > behavior? All I have been able to find is a lot of anecdotal talk about > "torties with attitude" and the even temperament of tabbies. How about nutrition and coat color:
full text available at www.nutrition.org J. Nutr. 132:2037-2042, 2002 Nutrient Requirements Cats Require More Dietary Phenylalanine or Tyrosine for Melanin Deposition in Hair than for Maximal Growth1 Peter J. B. Anderson, Quinton R. Rogers and James G. Morris2 Department of Molecular Biosciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of California, Davis, CA
Introduction The color of mammalian hair results mainly from the secretory products of the melanocytes. Organelles referred to as melanosomes within these specialized dendritic cells synthesize melanin, which is secreted into the surrounding keratinocytes where they become incorporated into the hair. Follicular melanocytes differ from those in the epidermis in that they synthesize larger melanosomes, are active only during anagen stages III?VI of hair growth, and are inactive during telegen (1 ). Two types of melanin are synthesized in follicular melanocytes: eumelanin, which is brown to black, and pheomelanin, which is reddish-brown (2 ). The pathways for the synthesis of these two types of melanin were presented by Morris et al. (3 ). The physiologic signals that regulate this switch include the -melanocyte?stimulating hormone and the agouti protein (4 ). Dihydroxyphenylalanine (DOPA),3 the hydroxylated product of tyrosine, is the precursor of both types of melanin. We have been unable to find any reference to the effect of dietary tyrosine (or phenylalanine) on the color of mammalian hair. However, the tendency for phenylketonuric human subjects to have fair hair has been commented upon from time to time since the first observations of Folling in 1934 (5 ).
Am J Vet Res. 2004 May;65(5):671-80. Assessment of the neurologic effects of dietary deficiencies of phenylalanine and tyrosine in cats. Dickinson PJ, Anderson PJ, Williams DC, Powell HC, Shelton GD, Morris JG, LeCouteur RA. Department of Surgical and Radiological Sciences, School of Veterinary Medicine, University of California, Davis, CA 95616, USA. OBJECTIVE: To determine the neurologic effects of reduced intake of phenylalanine and tyrosine in black-haired cats. ANIMALS: 53 specific pathogen-free black domestic shorthair cats. PROCEDURE: Cats were fed purified diets containing various concentrations of phenylalanine and tyrosine for < or = 9 months. Blood samples were obtained every 2 months for evaluation of serum aromatic amino acid concentrations. Cats were monitored for changes in hair color and neurologic or behavioral abnormalities. Three cats with neurologic deficits underwent clinical and electrophysiologic investigation; muscle and nerve biopsy specimens were also obtained from these cats. RESULTS: After 6 months, neurologic and behavioral abnormalities including vocalization and abnormal posture and gait were observed in cats that had received diets containing < 16 g of total aromatic amino acid/kg of diet. Electrophysiologic data and results of microscopic examination of muscle and nerve biopsy specimens from 3 cats with neurologic signs were consistent with sensory neuropathy with primary axonal degeneration. Changes in hair color were detected in cats from all groups receiving < 16 g of phenylalanine plus tyrosine/kg of diet. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Findings suggested that chronic dietary restriction of phenylalanine and tyrosine in cats may result in a predominantly sensory neuropathy. In cats, the long-term nutritional requirement for phenylalanine and tyrosine appears to be greater for normal neurologic function than that required in short-term growth experiments. Official present-day recommendations for dietary phenylalanine and tyrosine in cats may be insufficient to support normal long-term neurologic function. PMID: 15141890 [PubMed - in process]
buglady take out the dog before replying
|
|
|