> > Animals are instinctual, they do not have a conscience.
> > Even without a conscience cats do sense when something
> > is wrong with dey owners.
>
> Is this not the very definition of conscience, knowing right from
> wrong?
> You just proved that cats DO have a conscience.
>
> They know when they are being bad without a doubt.
> > > Animals are instinctual, they do not have a conscience.
> > > Even without a conscience cats do sense when something
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
> They have no appearance of having a conscious until they are caught.
> Then what we are really seeing is not the working of the conscience.
But this is also true of many people. They become religious or show
concern only after getting caught, for example.
This does not mean they do not have a conscience. It indicates that the
dictates of a cats' conscience are not the same rules applying to
people.
For example, I do not have to attack every mouse that I see. What we
view as negative conscience is positive conscience for a cat. They have
different rules and different frames of reference. Same universe,
different priorities.
My cat behaves herself when I am not around. I do not find toilet paper
strewn about. Almost never do I find things knocked on the floor. In
fact, she is the soul of wit and brevity and decorum.
> > You just proved that cats DO have a conscience.
> >
[quoted text clipped - 3 lines]
> what is it that makes them want to stay close...
> many many animals are like this.
This is so for many living creatures. And the gathering together of
living creatures shows that it's instinctual and not because of
conscience?
> It's instilled in them from birth; to touch and be touched.
People who are touched tend to do much better than those who are left
alone.
Bad pun but it' true.
whitershadeofpale - 08 Dec 2005 22:57 GMT
> But this is also true of many people. They become religious or show
> concern only after getting caught, for example.
yayaya
Cats are not aware of thier own existence. A cat doesn't get up in the
morning, take a deep breath and say, I'm alive, and I know I'm alive.
Of course not, he just experiences his living.
> This does not mean they do not have a conscience. It indicates that the
> dictates of a cats' conscience are not the same rules applying to
[quoted text clipped - 25 lines]
> alone.
> Bad pun but it' true.
lol
no, I hear ya, and it sounds pretty good, but your missing one
fundamental ingredient.
Cats are smart, they will behave knowing the consequence. If the
consequence is seperation from you, they will avoid that action
altogether. This can be put under the category of survival. Sure, it
takes the love out of things to say, they only do it for survival, but
it is true.
Avoiding the toilet paper only proves they want to survive. You don't
have to say *I* proved cats have a conscience to convey your opinion on
the matter...do you? why are you doing that! stop doing that! Not only
are you trying to sway my opinion but you want it come out of my mouth
too! ? !
ALL OR NONE EH?
What else you need to know.