Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
scale of values. bookburn
In the Anchorage Daily News, www.adn.com.
(quote)
Tale of Carl the company cat will end in court
WHO OWNS HIM? Ongoing tussle has failed to resolve the issue.
Daily News staff
Published: March 24, 2007
Last Modified: March 24, 2007 at 02:04 AM
PALMER -- The custody battle over Carl the Cat is going to trial.
People on both sides of a lawsuit filed in the Valley last year say
all efforts to resolve ownership of the big orange tabby have failed
and a trial date has been set for Sept. 10 in Palmer Superior Court.
What's so great about Carl, a 6-year-old stray found as a kitten in
2000? According to admirers, Carl is really friendly, used to like
drowning stuffed toys in the toilet and gets along great with other
animals
One of the people tussling over him is Catherine Fosselman, who says
she got legal title to Carl last year when she bought out her partner
in a Mat-Su accounting firm. Carl lived at the office and thus is part
of the property she bought, she said in court filings.
Her lawsuit asked for $100,000 in damages for having been deprived of
Carl's company, but Fosselman said she doesn't care about the money.
"Before we even filed charges, all we wanted was him back," she said.
"We have since offered to drop the lawsuit and everything just so long
as they gave the cat back. This has nothing to do with money."
On the other side is Staci Fieser. She used to work at the accounting
office. She took Carl home after a fire in February 2006 and has cared
for him ever since. Her husband, Jason, is an Alaska state trooper who
has since been transferred to Dillingham, where Carl now lives with
the Fiesers. They say they have no intention of giving him up.
"I don't feel like we need to give in to somebody that's just trying
to push us around," Jason Fieser said. "I don't think anybody should."
The Fiesers claim Fosselman didn't really care about Carl, especially
after she took him home one weekend and he peed on her bed. Staci
Fieser and another employee fed and cleaned up after Carl at the
office, stopped in to see him on weekends, and paid for food and vet
services, she said in court filings.
Fosselman says she can trump that. She not only paid for cat food but
paid employees for the time they spent taking care of Carl at the
office, to the tune of $7,000. She's not dropping the lawsuit.
"If someone was baby-sitting your child and they wouldn't return your
child, what would you do?" she asked.
According to the Fiesers, news of the cat custody lawsuit arrived in
Dillingham before Carl did.
"People wanted to come over and see Carl," Jason Fieser said. They
wanted to know how Carl was doing and they wanted to know the story,
stuff like that. Basically because they just can't believe this is
happening."
(unquote)
> Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
> Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 55 lines]
> "If someone was baby-sitting your child and they wouldn't return your
> child, what would you do?" she asked.
If you were in the habit of leaving your child alone for days at a time with
someone paid to visit them, child protective service would step in.
> According to the Fiesers, news of the cat custody lawsuit arrived in
> Dillingham before Carl did.
[quoted text clipped - 4 lines]
> happening."
> (unquote)
With all the cats in the world that no one wants.....
I find the story fascinating, because I have to wonder if Carl is a
descendent of the orange trailer park Tom we knew in Alaska thirty five
years ago. Palmer isn't all that far from where we lived.
There aren't as many feral cats in Alaska per capita as there might be
elsewhere, just because it is so inhospitable for them. Between weather,
predators, and food sources they have it pretty rough. If I'm not mistaken,
it is now illegal to let your cat outdoors in an unenclosed area.
Our last year in Alaska, we lived in an 8ft by 38ft trailer with a lean-to.
The park of about 50 trailers was home to a very large very wild orange tom
cat, called of course Tom by everyone. He lived by eating from the trash
(and food that was left out for him) and when it was cold he would go from
car to car as they came in at night. Sleeping under the warmest one. He
fought any and all other cats, and wouldn't let anyone touch him. He was
the only unowned cat in the park. The residents did let their cats our in
nice weather. And there were the usual number of kittens born every spring.
Most of them orange.
Jo
Joy - 30 Mar 2007 01:12 GMT
>> Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>> Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 91 lines]
>
> Jo
Where in Alaska were you? My sister lives in Valdez.
Joy
jofirey - 30 Mar 2007 03:06 GMT
>>> Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>>> Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 95 lines]
>
> Joy
We lived in Anchorage from 1968 to 1971. We were back two years ago. My
things have changed. But plenty has also stayed the same.
I liked Valdez, but that was pre pipeline. But the main thing I remember
about our visit was that we were still tent camping. And woke up in the
morning with everything covered in snow. The dog and cat that were camping
with us had never seen snow before. They were just babies.
But after that we decided out camping had to be inside something you can
heat better than a tent. Come to think of it at that point we were still
driving the blue Chevy that never passed a ditch it didn't like.
Jo
Jo
Kreisleriana - 30 Mar 2007 04:06 GMT
>> Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>> Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 90 lines]
>
>Jo
Orange again. I can just hear Muddy Waters in the background,
singing "I'm a hoochy-koochy man . . ." ;)
Theresa
Stinky Pictures: http://community.webshots.com/album/125591586JWEFwh
Make Levees, Not War
>Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 64 lines]
>happening."
>(unquote)
Carl the cat custody case goes to trial
PALMER: Woman seeks $100,000 over alleged office catnapping.
By ANDREW WELLNER
awellner@adn.com
Published: September 21, 2007
Last Modified: September 21, 2007 at 03:04 AM
PALMER -- Jason Fieser's neck and ears flushed red as he sat on the
witness stand Thursday in Judge Eric Smith's Superior Court.
In a note to the judge that Smith read aloud, a juror asked Fieser, an
Alaska state trooper, why he turned red.
"This is upsetting to me," Fieser answered.
His wife's former boss at a Palmer accounting firm had pressured
Fieser's superiors to fire him over, of all things, a cat, he
testified.
Fieser, now posted in Dillingham, said a note from a superior had
warned him of "internal consequences" and possible criminal charges
should his wife, Staci, fail to hand over the cat, a 7-year-old orange
tabby named Carl.
"I cannot make the decision whether to return the cat," Fieser said he
replied. That was for his wife to decide.
"I told them not to threaten me. If they were going to charge me then
charge me," he said.
Thursday, trial began in civil court to decide who owns Carl, who
survived a February 2006 fire that destroyed Fosselman & Associates,
an accounting firm on South Bailey Street. Catherine Fosselman, the
firm's owner, according to her employees disregarded her car keys and
company files to carry Carl to safety that night. She is suing the
woman, Staci Fieser, with whom she placed Carl for safekeeping but who
has kept Carl since.
Fosselman said she never meant for Fieser to have Carl permanently.
She wants him back. And she wants $100,000 in punitive damages for
loss of his companionship, she testified Thursday.
"Loss of cat consortium," said the Fiesers' attorney, Eric Conard, as
he questioned Fosselman.
"I am not here to get rich. I am here to get my cat back," she said.
The punitive damages, her attorney, Andrew Robinson, told the jury,
are meant to "send a message to anybody out there who wants to pull
this kind of stuff that there are consequences to this type of
action."
Fosselman filed suit in October 2006. Neither side in the dispute will
acknowledge any attempt to settle the case short of trial.
However, Conard, on the eve of trial, said, "If there were
discussions, they obviously didn't work."
Fosselman in a previous interview has denied trying to have Jason
Fieser fired.
Prospective jurors were asked Wednesday whether they had any pets and
whether a trial over a cat is a waste of court time and resources.
"If somebody had my dog, I'd probably sue them to get my dog back,"
said one woman.
"I'd rather see them come to court than go to the extremes of
violence," said another.
One man said he could decide who gets the cat, but couldn't envision
awarding monetary damages.
All three were eventually picked to serve on the 12-member jury, with
two alternates, hearing the case.
For six years, Carl lived in the accounting office, brought there as a
stray kitten picked up by Traci Weiland, a former Fosselman business
partner. Another cat, Chloe, arrived in the office later. She did not
survive the fire.
Conard asserts that Weiland signed an affidavit in October 2006 giving
Carl to Staci Fieser. Fosselman claims Carl was not Weiland's to give.
Employees, former employees and clients took their turns testifying
Thursday to Carl's charm.
Carl lay atop documents, begging for attention and impeding work in
the office. His keepers showered him with toys, blankets and treats
that were kept at nearly every desk. Fosselman said Carl came to
prefer bottled water only and learned to drink from the water cooler.
"He seemed like a very popular cat," said her husband, Dale Fosselman.
At Christmas time Carl and Chloe had stockings hung next to those for
the employees.
Carl's "had more in it than mine," testified employee Amy Levinson.
Robinson expects to conclude his case today.
-----------------------
See Carl's picture at:
http://www.adn.com/news/alaska/matsu/story/9319377p-9233913c.html
EvelynVogtGamble(Divamanque) - 21 Sep 2007 19:10 GMT
>>Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>>Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
>>scale of values. bookburn
>>PALMER -- The custody battle over Carl the Cat is going to trial.
>>
>>People on both sides of a lawsuit filed in the Valley last year say
>>all efforts to resolve ownership of the big orange tabby have failed
>>and a trial date has been set for Sept. 10 in Palmer Superior Court.
Why not do as so many family court judges do in custody
battles over older children? (Let the child - in this case
cat - choose?)
jmcquown - 21 Sep 2007 19:17 GMT
>>> Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure
>>> if Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of
[quoted text clipped - 9 lines]
> battles over older children? (Let the child - in this case
> cat - choose?)
In theory that's a good idea. But if the cat is familiar with both parties
to the lawsuit, how is the judge supposed to know what the cat is thinking?
The cat could easily run from one person to the other in chambers. I think
it should depend on the *proof* (and I do mean proof) of who had the cat in
their "possession" longer. This is problematic since this was an office cat
initially. But further proof should include who paid for most of the food
and vet care over a period of years. Just IMHO.
Jill
jXwXeXrXmXoXnXt@sonic.net - 21 Sep 2007 20:12 GMT
>Here's a cat anecdote that's taking place in Alaska. I'm not sure if
>Alaska's low cat to human population figures in this kind of human
[quoted text clipped - 5 lines]
>Tale of Carl the company cat will end in court
>WHO OWNS HIM? Ongoing tussle has failed to resolve the issue.
I don't know why, but this story depresses me. Cats shouldn't inspire
such human ugliness. They should bring out the best in us! It makes me
sad to see people stooping to nasty behavior over something that I
have such tender feelings about.
And I also worry about Carl. When people squabble over something,
occasionally that something gets harmed in the process, due to spite.
I sure hope these people are better than that, but they sound like
jerks to me.
Joyce